Thursday, November 19, 2026
Ferry Biedermann
- The red flags of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine come to a halt in front of the Church of the Nativity in the centre of Bethlehem, the traditional birth place of Jesus.
One by one the mourners in the funeral procession enter the sanctuary through its narrow door. The service for 16-year old Johnny Thaljiye is the first one for a victim of the current intifadah – uprising – held in the church.
Bethlehem has been the focus of fierce fighting since the murder of the ultra-rightwing Israeli cabinet minister Rehavam Ze’evi mid-October.
The radical, leftist Popular Front, PFLP, has claimed responsibility for the attack in revenge for the Israeli assassination of their leader, Abu Ali Mustafa in August.
The large Christian population in Bethlehem does not support militant Islamic groups such as Hamas and Jihad, instead the town is known as a PFLP stronghold. Israeli troops have entered the outskirts, as well as those of five other West Bank towns. The army says the action is aimed at radical groups and not at the Palestinian Authority. The international community is urging a speedy withdrawal.
Along some of the arteries leading into the centre, lightly armed Palestinian irregulars are fighting Israeli soldiers backed by tanks. Yasser Arafat’s Palestinian Authority has mostly kept out of the fighting. The Israelis have occupied the high ground around town and several large buildings. No place is safe from the bullets.
Thaljiye, an altar boy at the Church of the Nativity who reportedly wanted to become a priest, was killed by a bullet in Manger Square in front of the church, just around the corner from his house.
His family says neither he nor they were involved in politics but he has posthumously been claimed by the intifadah.
“The PFLP is proud to announce the death of its martyr Johnny Thaljiye,” read the announcements plastered onto the walls of the caf, where the mourners meet before the funeral. It is the only place in the deserted looking town where a group of people stands together.
Several activists are trying to fasten a huge poster of Mustafa, their murdered leader, to the facade. A gust of wind blows the canvas away and it lands on some of the people in the street.
Hassan Abdul Jawwad, a longstanding member of the PFLP, has come to pay his respect but also to show the flag. “We have nothing to feel guilty about,” he says, “Ariel Sharon would have launched this onslaught anyway, he is planning to destroy the Palestinian Authority and Yasser Arafat.”
The PFLP disagreed with Arafat’s participation in the peace process but had lately been seeking a rapprochement.
In 1999 Mustafa was even allowed by the Israelis and the Palestinian Authority to settle in Ramallah and open an office there. During the current intifadah the left-wing group has turned to violence, as a means of keeping up with its Islamic rivals.
Since the assassination of minister Ze’evi, the Palestinian Authority has outlawed the PFLP’s military wing and arrested more than 20 political activists. “I think that is a mistake, the Palestinians should stand united against Israel,” says Abdul Jawwad.
He dismisses the idea, though, that there could ever be an armed confrontation between militant Palestinian groups and the Palestinian Authority.
Abdul Jawwad says that he has spent more than two years in Israeli prisons until 1998, for his membership in the PFLP. He considers the current intifadah long overdue. “Even the killing of minister Ze’evi was a legitimate act of resistance against the occupation, we have nothing to be ashamed of,” he says.
During the Israeli incursion, more than 30 Palestinians have been killed, at least 15 of them in Bethlehem and neighbouring Beit Jalla. Many of the victims have been innocent civilians, such as a 13-year old girl, whose school was hit in Jenin, and Thaljiye.
“The Israelis know how to make enemies,” says Samir Zablah, a neighbour of the killed teenager. “We Christians used to be moderate but now that they are killing us we are furious.”
In Bethlehem, residents of Aida and Dahayshe refugee camps have so far largely borne the brunt of the intifadah. The mostly middle class, partly Christian, population of the town itself was more interested in commerce and tourism.
Since the incursions started two Christian inhabitants of neighbouring Beit Jalla have been killed as well, apart from Thaljiye in Bethlehem. “We were not political but our anger will definitely translate into more activism,” says Adnan Thaljiye, one of Johnny’s uncles.
Bullets also have hit the Church of the Nativity; some of its stained glass windows are broken. During the service for Thaljiye, the Greek-Orthodox priest says, “Johnny (Thaljiye) you died like a hero, a martyr for all Palestinians”. Some of Thaljiye’s relative are overcome by emotions and carried out of the church.
The mayor of Bethlehem, Hanna Nasser, waiting outside for the service to finish, stands just metres away from the patch of cobbled stones with Thaljiye’s dried-up blood. “It doesn’t matter whether a martyr is Christian or Muslim,” he says. “At moments like this we are all one.”
The perception of Bethlehem, as the traditional birthplace of Christ, having a special status and enjoying more protection from the Israelis, is dismissed with a shrug.
“The Israeli’s have been doing the same to Bethlehem these last few days as to other cities on the West Bank. If we were so special, why has the world than not done anything to stop it?” says Nasser.
After the service is finished, a modest crowd braves the ongoing fighting to accompany the coffin to the nearby cemetery. Along the route gunman fire in the air, the sound of his shots mixing with those from the battle.