Europe, Headlines | Analysis

//REPEATING//POLITICS: Berlin Voters Divided about the War Against Terrorism

Analysis - Yojana Sharma

BERLIN, Oct 22 2001 (IPS) - Results of local elections in Berlin have shown that East and West Germans are divided about the war against terrorism.

Almost one in two easterners voted for the former communists who have staunchly opposed Germany’s military support of U.S. action against Afghanistan.

The election Sunday of the German capital’s local government is seen as a reflection of the country’s mood since the Sep 11 attacks on New York and Washington.

The Social Democrats, the party of chancellor Gerhard Schroeder, obtained almost 30 percent of the vote, compared to 24 percent for the conservative Christian Democrats who lost out due to allegations of sleaze and mismanagement of the near-bankrupt capital.

No party has an outright majority, but the Social Democrats now have a mandate to negotiate a coalition to run Berlin.

It may have to form a coalition with the communist successor party, the Party of Democratic Socialism (PDS), bringing the communists back into the Berlin government for the first time since the fall of the Berlin wall a decade ago.

Commentators described the PDS as the clear “winner” of this “earthquake election”. Riding on its anti-war platform and the only party to do so unequivocally, the former communists obtained 22.5 percent of the Berlin vote, coming third behind the Social Democrats and Christian Democrats.

However, in former eastern parts of Berlin it garners almost 48 percent of the vote – a staggering result that no other party could match.

The support of both mainstream parties, the Social Democrats and Christian Democrats, was far lower in the East than in the West. The Social Democrats obtained just 22 percent of the eastern vote compared to 34 percent in western Berlin districts.

Even the PDS was astonished at its showing. Often regarded as a pariah party, it had fielded its charismatic leader Gregor Gysi but had not expected its pacifist message to have such resonance.

At its party conference last month, the PDS stated that world military intervention would not resolve the problems of insecurity (unleashed by the events of Sep 11), and that NATO’s structure was “completely inappropriate” for combating terrorism, points that were repeated by its candidates on the hustings.

“Clearly the PDS has notched up points with its anti-war campaign,” said Andreas Geisel, a Social Democrat Candidate in Berlin.

The election results confirmed earlier opinion polls – East Germans in particular do not want to be drawn into a war as an ally of the United States.

A survey in mid-September showed that two thirds of western Germans but only one third of eastern Germans regarded as justifiable that Germany should participate in such military action to combat terrorism – opinions that helped bolster the ex- communists.

Klaus Schroeder, former head of a research group at Berlin’s Free University, maintains that the anti-war attitudes in the east may have less to do with pacifism than with people’s reluctance to accept insecurity in their lives, particularly after the upheavals of German reunification a decade ago.

The unification, he says, affected lives in the former east fundamentally and barely at all in western Germany that has enjoyed decades of stability.

Recent opinion polls have shown that 57 percent of Germans fear the attacks on Afghanistan could lead to a new World War.

This may not be the whole picture. Much of the PDS’s swing attributed to gaining new voters among the under-30s. Many have become disillusioned with the environmental Green party which has strong roots in the anti-war movements of the 1960s but which has changed tack over German participation in the war against terror.

Green party leader Joschka Fischer, Germany’s foreign minister, has thrown his weight squarely behind Chancellor Schroeder’s support of U.S. action, and willingness to provide military backing, leaving the PDS as the only party with an undiluted anti- war position which has found favour among the young.

“The PDS is the only political party in Germany that has stayed true to itself by not changing (since Sep 11). It is the only party that allows itself the luxury of beliefs that are free of contradictions,” said Berliner Zeitung daily, commenting on the party’s continued pacifism.

The paper adds that the party’s views are a throwback to the anti-Americanism of its communist past rather than a genuine commitment to peace.

Berlin’s new mayor, Social Democrat Klaus Wowereit, now has a difficult task on his hands – whether or not to include the PDS in Berlin’s ruling coalition, a move that could have a significant impact on the PDS’s standing countrywide by propelling it into mainstream politics.

Wowereit would otherwise have to conduct more difficult negotiations with the Greens and the Liberals that would mean greater concessions by the Social Democrats.

But many Social Democrats, particularly at the federal level, say a coalition at this time with the PDS would be inappropriate, and even “unpatriotic”.

In recent speeches Chancellor Schroeder has made it clear that together with Britain and France, he is willing to back U.S. military action even outside the NATO structure to which it is contractually committed.

In such a climate, the PDS’s pacifist stand has irritated the Chancellor who now excludes the party from all government briefings on national security held regularly since Sep 11 and which includes deputies from other parties.

Social Democrats already rule two former eastern states in coalition with the PDS but Berlin, the symbol of the divided country is considered different. Some believe a coalition in Berlin could pave the way for cooperation between the Social Democrats and the PDS at national level after elections in 2002.

“I rule it out completely,” says Peter Struck, Social Democrats parliamentary leader on a possible national coalition with the PDS. “Besides questions about the past – which continue to play a role for Social Democrats, there is incompatibility on political issues.”

“In foreign and security policy but also in economic policy the PDS is totally unreliable and we have absolutely nothing in common with them. They have absurd ideas about the armed forces and the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO),” he says.

Even so, the PDS cannot be ignored by politicians mindful of the need to appeal to both west and former east where voters are disillusioned by the mainstream parties.

The election this weekend could serve as a warning to Schroeder, gung-ho about military action this year, but facing national elections next year.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags