Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America

DEVELOPMENT-ENVIRONMENT: Novel Study Touts New Linkages

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Oct 12 2001 (IPS) - The main ingredients necessary for a nation to achieve high quality of life and environmental health are freedom, good governance, and education, according to a new country-by-country index.

Going beyond economic indicators like gross domestic product (GDP) to assess a country’s development, Canada’s International Development Research Centre (IDRC) and the World Conservation Union (IUCN), used a new approach to survey 180 countries’ human and ecosystem “well being.”

Building on previous quality-of-life yardsticks, such as the U.N. Human Development Index, which includes health and education data, the “Well Being Index” covers a fuller range of statistical indicators.

The index combines data on health, good governance, press freedom, corruption, education, crime, and equity with environmental trends including air quality, resource use, and species diversity loss. Data are derived from official U.N. and government sources.

“The key conditions for combining high human well being and low ecosystem stress are freedom, good governance, and education,” said Robert Prescott-Allen, a prominent researcher and author on environmental issues, who wrote the report.

Some 141 countries, including almost all of sub-Saharan Africa, the Middle East, and Central Asia – “combine high levels of human deprivation and environmental degradation,” said the 342-page report, published in cooperation with various U.N. agencies and international institutions.

Scandinavian countries, Iceland, Austria and Canada – long-time residents of the top-tier of global progress tables – were at the top of the new list.

Some of the rankings, however, were “startling,” and differed widely from other indexes, said Prescott-Allen.

Dominica, for example, was ranked sixth, while Guyana, Latvia and Peru were ranked 10th, 16th and 19th, respectively. The United States and the Netherlands – 6th and 8th in the latest U.N. Human Development Index – dropped to 27th and 38th respectively in the Well Being Index.

“The global progress chart has been radically reshuffled,” said Prescott-Allen. Inclusion of the environment and a wider view of human development explain much of this change, he said, but lack of data was also a factor.

Latvia, he said, owed “its promotion to its moderate environmental impact and to levels of education, freedom, and peace that more than offset its modest wealth.” Low consumption of water and other resources, limited damming of rivers, and minor impacts on the global atmosphere boosted the positions of Guyana and Peru.

Guyana, said the report, benefited from a combination of fair respect for political rights and civil liberties but also from a lack of data on crime. Dominica, said Prescott-Allen, “performs spectacularly” on health, freedom, and land protection but was rated on less than two-thirds of the indicators.

The demotion of the Netherlands reflected its poor environmental performance. Its “natural land has disappeared, its rivers are burdened with nutrients, it produces heavy quantities of carbon dioxide and ozone depleting substances, and it consumes more than its sustainable supply of timber and other resources,” said Prescott-Allen.

The United States slipped down the chart because of the wide gap between rich and poor, a combination of impacts on the global atmosphere, and high percentages of threatened or endangered species (29 percent of plants and nine percent of animals are threatened).

But the rankings, said Prescott-Allen, are not as important as the position of each country in relation to the goal of a good level of human and ecosystem well being.

“Although number one, Sweden is as far from this goal as Cape Verde (ranked 60th) is from Sweden,” he said.

“Significantly, most countries with a high ratio of human well being to ecosystem stress (such as Sweden and Switzerland) also have high levels of freedom, good governance, and education – essential conditions for sound decision making,” he said.

The report noted that, contrary to notions that environmental protection is dependent upon the wealth of a nation, large differences in ecosystem health occur between countries with similar standards of living. Austria, for example, has the same quality of life as Belgium, but takes less of a toll on the environment.

“Latvia caused less environmental damage for its living standard than Estonia, as does Ecuador in comparison with Colombia, or Indonesia with China,” said the report.

These differences, said Prescott-Allen, show that growth in human well being does not necessarily result in greater environmental damage.

Much of the relationship between people and the environment is a matter of policy choices, he said.

“The report suggests that a high standard of living is possible without ruining the environment by changing the way that development is pursued,” said Achim Steiner, director of IUCN, a non-governmental organisation based in Switzerland.

A practical strategy to achieve environmentally sustainable human development, said Prescott-Allen, would be to minimise the environmental impacts of making money while maximising the quality of life obtained from each dollar.

Easier said than done?

Lithuania, he said, seemed to be going in the right direction. It has a modest GDP (6,655 dollars per person in 1999) yet managed to combine a fair level of human well being with a medium level of environmental stress.

“Although Lithuania ranks 59th in the world in income, it ranks 22nd in well being,” he said.

World Bank officials and development and conservation experts here praised the new index as a way to help them make better decisions on where aid money should be focused.

“It’s an enormous advance in sophistication in grappling with the elusive concept of sustainable development,” said Thomas Lovejoy, lead environmental specialist for Latin America and the Caribbean at the World Bank.

Melinda Kimble, senior vice president for programmes at the United Nations Foundation, called the new index an important tool she hopes will lead policy makers to think far beyond national income accounting as a measure of human development and quality of the environment.

“We need to go farther in our ability to apply analytical tools so that policy makers and the public can derive a better consensus of what steps to take,” she said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags