Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

ECUADOR: First Indigenous Minister not Backed by His People

Kintto Lucas

QUITO, Sep 24 2001 (IPS) - Luis Maldonado, the first indigenous person to form part of the government in Ecuador, has begun his work as minister of social welfare without the support of the large associations that represent the country’s native population, the best organised in Latin America.

A native of the highlands city of Otavalo in northern Ecuador, Maldonado studied philosophy and political science, and was named to the cabinet of President Gustavo Noboa after heading the Council of Nationalities and Peoples of Ecuador (CODENPE) and the World Bank’s Development Project for the Indigenous Peoples of Ecuador (PRODEPINE).

The Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador (CONAIE) and the Pachakutik political movement criticised Maldonado’s decision to accept the post, arguing that his designation would be used to undermine the unity of the movements representing the country’s Indians, who account for more than 30 percent of a total population of 12.4 million.

The associations linking the country’s indigenous communities are opposed to backing a government which in their view has failed to comply with the agreements signed in the wake of the nationwide wave of protests in January and February.

Pachakutik, which recently held its national congress, issued a communique declaring that Maldonado did not have the support of the movement, which would never take part in a government that had “repressed” indigenous peoples.

“In the peaceful uprising of January and February, repression at the hands of the government of Noboa cost the indigenous movement lives. How can we support a government responsible for the death of our companions?” Miguel Lluco, who was reelected as National Coordinator of Pachakutik by a broad majority in the movement’s national congress this month, told IPS.

Maldonado, who has served as a CONAIE advisor and as an alternate parliamentary deputy for Pachakutik, said last Thursday when he assumed his ministerial post that the decision to accept the position was a personal one that involved neither CONAIE nor Pachakutik.

“This is a personal choice, not one that involves the indigenous movement or Pachakutik. President Noboa’s decision was that I would assume this responsibility as a personal option, without pressure,” he said.

The president of CONAIE, Antonio Vargas, also publicly called into question Maldonado’s designation as minister of social welfare.

Defending himself, Maldonado charged that Vargas was not being sincere, because he had initially accepted the decision. Vargas’ position “changes on the basis of expediency,” Maldonado said in an interview with a Quito radio station, La Luna.

“On the other hand, I accept the stance taken by Blanca Chancoso [another CONAIE leader], who told me from the start that I should not accept because it would be tantamount to supporting the government’s conduct,” he added.

Vargas’ “statements were made in the context of internal electoral Pachakutik politics, and on the eve of the [October] CONAIE congress,” Maldonado asserted.

The new minister of social welfare explained that he had not distanced himself from CONAIE, and that he continued to participate in the group’s meetings and decision-making on some points, although “that does not mean everyone agrees with what I’ve done.”

According to political analysts, Maldonado’s naming to the cabinet indicated a “democratisation” of the government, and the designation offered the indigenous movement a new opportunity.

However, long-time leaders of the indigenous movement like Luis Macas, the director of the Scientific Institute of Indigenous Cultures, said Maldonado’s designation was just another expression of the aim to co-opt the movement.

Macas, who has a doctorate in political science and is also the dean of the International University of Indigenous Peoples, said the World Bank had adapted its discourse to the new reality of today’s world, in which specific social actors, especially native peoples, had taken on a new influence.

“The World Bank, in the face of criticism from environmental activists and indigenous communities, has incorporated sustainable development into its strategy of economic liberalisation, giving rise to the new discourse of ‘ethno-development’,” said Macas.

The indigenous leader cited the creation of the Development Project for Indigenous Peoples of Ecuador (PRODEPINE) as an example of the World Bank’s new policy.

In his view, PRODEPINE, the World Bank’s showcase project for indigenous peoples, is endangering the unity of Latin America’s strongest native movement, within whose bosom it has taken shape.

“The dynamic that gave rise to this project is part of a welfare mentality, and the project was set up based on techno- bureaucratic forces that are being strengthened as structures of power within the movement, thanks to the funds they manage,” he said.

Since the project began to be implemented in 1998, it has failed to address the political and social problems that affect indigenous people in this Andean nation, according to Macas.

“These are entities that use outside funding to thrive on the basis of the organisational strength and mobilisation capacity of our peoples,” said Macas, a former president of CONAIE who served as a parliamentary deputy representing Pachakutik from 1996 to 1998.

Maldonado’s designation as a cabinet minister arose from the same intentions that spawned PRODEPINE – which is headed by Maldonado himself, said Macas.

The new minister of social welfare has also been criticised for his performance at the head of PRODEPINE and CODENPE.

During the July 1999 “social uprisings” against the government of then-president Jamil Mahuad, who was overthrown in January 2000, indigenous people from Otavalo denounced that Maldonado, after signing certain private agreements that supposedly represented that region, called for a lifting of the protests.

In the ceremony in which he assumed his ministerial post, Maldonado gave a key role to indigenous rituals. He was accompanied by several shamans (native priests) who set up an altar representing the sun god, with herbs, flowers, fruit, crafts and incense.

Shaman Jaime Picatuña blew a conch shell to greet the guardians of nature: Inti (the sun god), Pachamama (mother earth), the ancestors and the four directions.

After the ceremony, Maldonado said his “historic” naming as the first indigenous government minister would enable him to carry out “true community labour…especially on behalf of all of the country’s children.”

For his part, President Noboa said the designation was a demonstration of Ecuador’s multi-cultural nature. “Five centuries have had to pass before an indigenous person became a cabinet minister, and this designation arises from respect for indigenous peoples,” he said.

We are paying “homage to marginalisation, and to the neglect that indigenous peoples have suffered throughout the history of Ecuador,” the president added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags