Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- Oil industry and conservation advocates are using the Sep. 11 terrorist attacks on U.S. soil to advance their opposing energy strategies as essential for national security.
Rekindling debate over the direction of U.S. energy policy, Kenneth Dickerson, former senior vice president of Atlantic Richfield Company (ARCO), says the attacks prove once more that domestic energy supplies need to be increased.
Dickerson says U.S. dependence on imported oil “means that over 10,000 tankers enter U.S. ports each year, bringing foreign crude oil to U.S. refineries.”
Echoing President George W. Bush’s proposed energy strategy, Dickerson says more coal-fired power plants must be built and exploration for oil and gas in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) will be key to meeting the nation’s energy needs.
“ANWR is the single best opportunity we have to increase domestic production,” says Dickerson. Environmental groups and some Democratic lawmakers strongly oppose opening up the pristine refuge, a vast wilderness tucked along Alaska’s shore near the U.S.-Canadian border north of the Arctic Circle.
In early August, the U.S. House of Representatives approved a broad energy bill that would allow some oil drilling in the Arctic refuge. The Senate has yet to vote on the measure. To pass, it must win approval from the Senate Environment Committee, headed by Jim Jeffords, a long-time supporter of environmental protection.
Conservationists argue that in addition to possibly harming pristine ecosystems, Bush’s energy plan, with its focus on more oil and gas production and distribution, would create more potential targets for terrorists.
Peter Asmus, a senior associate with the American Hazard Control Group, a Washington-based environmental and energy research organisation, says that following the Sep. 11 attacks, oil, natural gas, and nuclear power companies stepped up security measures.
“One of the first public policy casualties in Washington, D.C. linked to the terrorist assault could be Bush’s national energy strategy – and rightly so,” says Asmus.
He says Bush’s energy strategy, which also touts the creation of more nuclear power plants, will create unnecessary security risks.
Asmus acknowledges that a nuclear explosion would not occur if a commercial aeroplane crashed into one of the nation’s 103 operating nuclear reactors. But he says huge deadly radioactive clouds could result from a direct hit to a power plant.
On the other hand, he argues, renewable energy sources like wind and solar power are decentralised in nature and therefore add to the nation’s energy supply without creating possible targets.
“Distributed networks of clean micro-power systems offer national security benefits that the Bush administration should not only recognise but embrace as it ponders energy supply in the aftermath of America’s darkest hour,” he says.
Other environmentalists say the recent attacks should prompt policy makers to focus on reducing the nation’s increasing demand for energy by promoting conservation and efficiency.
Byron Kennard, executive director of the Centre for Small Business and the Environment, says that after Sep. 11, an energy policy rooted in conservation, efficiency and renewable sources has become “absolutely imperative.”
“The days of America’s prodigious energy waste are over,” he says. “Now we must conserve fuel for national security needs and to reduce our dependence on foreign oil.”
Kennard says the key to saving energy lies in changing the wasteful behaviour of the 23 million small businesses in the United States.
Small firms account for more than half of all commercial energy use, he says, and “one half to one third of this energy is wasted.”
Businesses can make a big dent in energy demand, he adds, simply by improving lighting and installing better thermostats and insulation.
Despite the significant role small firms play in energy consumption, Kennard says Bush’s energy plan scarcely mentions creating incentives for small enterprises to invest in efficient technologies.
Conservationists are optimistic that the Senate energy bill will favour efficiency and renewable energy to a greater extent than the House or administration plans.
Senator Jeff Bingaman, chair of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, has included two legislative proposals designed to encourage investments in new renewable energy resources.
Both proposals “provide very significant opportunities for the nation to move toward a more sustainable and secure energy future fueled by abundant, domestic clean energy sources,” according to the Washington-based Environmental and Energy Study Institute.
The first policy proposal would require retail electric suppliers to obtain a minimum percentage of their electricity from renewable energy sources. The percentage rate would vary from state to state. Currently, 14 states have enacted such standards, but each state’s provisions vary widely in time frames and requirements.
The second proposal would establish a fund – paid for by a small charge added to electric bills throughout the country – to help implement renewable energy and energy efficiency technologies.
When the Senate will debate and vote will take place on these energy proposals remains uncertain, however, as lawmakers concentrate on the aftermath of the attacks.