Monday, November 16, 2026
Bob Burton
- A small human rights group scored a stunning legal victory against the Australian government when the Federal Court ruled that the expulsion of 433 asylum seekers who had been held against their will aboard a Norwegian cargo ship was illegal.
Federal Court Judge Justice Tony North on Tuesday delivered a sweeping victory to Liberty Victoria, a small non-government organisation, in its ‘David vs Goliath’ struggle against the Australian government to prevent the removal of the mainly Afghan asylum-seekers picked up at sea.
The government said it would appeal the decision.
“The applicants have established that the rescuees were held in detention by the respondents without lawful authority. An ancient power of the court is to protect people against detention without lawful authority,” North said, reading his judgement to a hushed court.
“They did not allow communication with the rescuees, they did not consult with them about the arrangements being made for their physical relocation or future plans. After the arrangements were made, the fact was announced to them, apparently not in their native language, but no effort was made to determine whether the rescuees desired to accept the arrangements,” North wrote in his scathing 50-page.
He said the Australian government decided “at the highest level” to “use an unlawful process to detain and expel the rescuees”. When he finished reading his judgement, North looked up and calmly asked, “Does anyone have anything to say?” For a moment there was a stunned silence before the supporters of the asylum seekers in the packed public gallery burst into applause.
Liberty Victoria is elated with its win. “What the court has said today, is that the very ancient traditions of the law, that you cannot imprison somebody without due cause or without a proper authority, still holds in Australia. That’s the very thing that these people were fleeing from,” Liberty Victoria spokesman, Greg Connellan, said outside the court.
The legal drama began 16 days ago when Australian Special Air Services troops stormed onto a Norwegian container ship, the MV Tampa that had rescued 433 asylum seekers from a sinking wooden boat at the request of Australian rescue services. When the captain of the ship sought to land the asylum seekers on the remote Christmas Island, the Australian government dispatched the SAS to prevent any refugees being offloaded.
In the face of mounting international pressure, an obstinate Australian Prime Minister, John Howard, negotiated a deal under which the asylum seekers would be transferred to the tiny Pacific nation of Nauru and some to New Zealand for assessment of their asylum applications.
North directed the government to return the 433 people removed from the Tampa to mainland Australia by Friday unless it wished to appeal. On Tuesday evening the Australian government announced it would appeal to the full bench of the federal court and, if necessary, to the High Court.
Australian Defence Minister Peter Reith, who directed the SAS to occupy the Tampa, described Federal Court ruling as a “bad decision”.
The Minister for Immigration, Phillip Ruddock, revealed that the asylum seekers will remain on the Australian Navy ship the HMAS Manoora which was carrying them to Port Moresby, from where they were originally due to be dispatched to Nauru and New Zealand.
The asylum seekers could now remain on the ship for several more weeks. “Ultimately, the length of time that people remain at sea, will be determined by the amount of time that the courts and those people who wish to push these matters, take in relation to them,” Ruddock said.
“The Commonwealth will argue on appeal that it did not detain the rescuees,” Peter Reith, and the Commonwealth Attorney General, Daryl Williams, revealed Tuesday night.
While the Australian government has suffered a humiliating legal defeat, its strident actions against the asylum seekers have boosted its electoral stock. A series of opinion polls reveals that support for Howard’s coalition has jumped five percentage points to give it its strongest lead in the last two years.
Earlier this year, Howard was considered likely to suffer certain defeat at the polls, likely to be held in late November. However, a series of opinion polls shows the coalition government is now ahead of its rival opposition Labour Party by four to five percentage points.
In the aftermath of the court decision, the Labour Party backed the government’s decision to appeal against the decision. Fearing that it would lose further electoral support, the Labour Party proposed special legislation to retrospectively legalise the government’s actions and offered to support the emergency recall of parliament.
“The Opposition has repeatedly indicated that it is prepared to offer a bipartisan solution to the question of illegal immigration,” Labour’s Shadow Attorney General, Robert McLelland, said.