Monday, November 16, 2026
Yojana Sharma
- Germany’s all-party special Commission on Immigration delivered its much-awaited recommendation Wednesday that 50,000 highly skilled immigrants should be imported to ease labour shortages in the country.
However tough political horse-trading is about to begin over when the immigrants should be allowed in and under what conditions.
The report of the commission, set up last year by Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder, and headed by Rita Suessmuth of the opposition Christian Democratic party, marks a radical change in German thinking – that the country is a land of immigration.
It will lead to the country’s first ever system of managed immigration.
Germany has seven million foreigners, most of them from Turkey, Greece and the former Yugoslavia who mostly arrived in the 1950s and 1960s, termed “Gastarbeiter” or guest workers. It was assumed they would fill vacant job slots but would leave when they were no longer needed.
Even after third generation Turkish immigrants began to come of age, Conservative politicians were still insisting “Germany is not a country of immigration”.
“In the past, discussion on the subject (of immigration) was more emotional and remote from reality. For a long time we denied that there was any immigration into Germany but now we accept that Germany has become a de facto immigration country,” said interior minister Otto Schily.
Germany’s ageing population and low birth rate are a matter of concern. “No one claims it (immigration) will solve the problem of an ageing population but it can reduce it,” Suessmuth said on Wednesday. But the main catalyst for inviting immigration on a sustained and long-term basis is a severe shortage of highly skilled workers expected to last well into the future.
Globalisation and competition for academics, scientists and information technology workers have led to the report’s recommendation for quotas of visas in key hi-tech branches.
A major debate about the global competition for computer- literate Indians led to provision for 20,000 visas for high-tech workers being made for this year – the first time immigrant visas have been allocated since 1973 when the inflow of workers from Turkey was stopped.
Some 8,000 of these have been taken up so far, mostly by technology workers from Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union, rather than Indians, but the special visas put the debate on immigration high on the political agenda.
The Suessmuth Commission recommends a system similar to Canada’s to select applicants for immigration based on age, education, skills and “willingness to integrate” – often seen as German language proficiency. Some 20,000 applicants a year will be selected under this category.
Immigrants will have the right to bring their families. Another 20,000 visas a year are proposed for industries with labour shortages, they will be temporary in nature, linked to the job, and with only limited rights of family entry.
Additional 10,000 visas a year would go to those training or studying in German universities or firms, particularly in science and engineering, bringing the total annual quota to 50,000. “It is not right to make it easier for companies to bring in people from overseas rather than give work to those already here,” said Suessmuth.
However Suessmuth stressed that the figures proposed in the document were not a fixed quota. “We have not had this experience of managed immigration before. We need to gather experience first then decide how it will work. That’s why its wrong to talk of quotas or upper limits or lower limits,” she said, foreshadowing a stiff battle ahead in the Federal parliament on the overall numbers – an emotive issue in the country.
The Commission’s recommendations are expected to form the basis for Germany’s first comprehensive immigration law to be presented to parliament by the end of the year. Officials close to Schily, the interior minister, who will draft the immigration bill, also have hinted that the interior minister does not favour a fixed quota but a system “with room to breath” which is able to react “flexibly” to the needs of the economy.
Politicians are worried about public reaction – particularly in the former East Germany where racism and xenophobia are widespread and attacks on foreigners are common. Even in the western German states surveys have shown people fear being “flooded by foreigners” or that the German lifestyle will be threatened.
But the Suessmuth Commission emphasises that programmes must be in place to ensure immigrants “integrate”. The report recommends that all immigrants take “at least 600 lessons in German” as well as classes in “German lifestyle”.
Says Friedrich Merz, opposition CDU parliamentary leader, “the formal fulfilment of the demands that immigrants abide by the law and learn the language is unlikely to prevent what has already happened in many German cities – the development of parallel societies.”
“We have to make sure that these children and families do not live in ghettos, that they are forced to attend schools where they also learn the German language and where they grow up in a German environment,” he says.
Also sensitive is the issue of family reunion. Germany is under pressure to bring its laws on family reunion in line with EU norms for the reunion of all children under 18 years of age, a policy which the opposition Christian Democrats strongly oppose.
But even the Christian Democrats, traditionally opposed to immigration of any kind, have undergone a sea-change under pressure from business – its main constituency – to recognise the need for immigration to overcome labour shortages. But it has yet to decide whether to back an immigration law.
Much will hinge on when the proposed immigration programme would start.
Some favour a date of 2010 when labour shortages are expected to be most acute because of the ageing population. By then East European applicant countries to the EU will have acceded, providing for free movement of East European Workers – likely to be the main applicants to Germany under any immigration scheme.
However many industries facing shortages now are clamouring for a much earlier kick-off date.
Also proposed by the commission is the setting up of a Federal Office for Immigration to process applications – seen as essential to avoid discrepancies in handling immigrant applications by the different Federal states.
Recently there has been much criticism of some federal states for their far stricter processing of naturalisation applications under a new law passed last year to make it easier for those born in Germany to apply for citizenship.