Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

CHILDREN-INDONESIA: Child Stardom Has an Ugly Side

Kafil Yamin

JAKARTA, May 18 2001 (IPS) - He is already a television star, so it is only natural for him to also be one of the top endorsers of consumer products in Indonesia.

But Joshua Suherman is only 12, and some child rights advocates worry that child celebrities like him are not only being exploited, they are also sending the wrong message to their peers.

Parents themselves are now complaining about their suddenly more demanding offspring, who want what Joshua seems to be enjoying on television,

Unfortunately, they say, what child stars like Joshua often push are food products that contain little nutritional value or are too pricey for many of Indonesia’s impoverished families.

“Before seeing Joshua promoting instant noodles of a certain brand, my son did not like noodles. Now he asks me for (that) noodles every day,” says Linda, a housewife in Bandung, West Java.

“But he does not really eat it all,” she adds with exasperation. “He would just have several spoonfuls of it and leave the rest.”

Many child rights advocates sympathise with parents like Linda. But they have fewer kind words for the parents of child celebrities, as well as the companies that hire these minors for shows and commercials.

Arist Merdeka Sirait, executive director of the National Commission on the Protection of Children (Komnas-PA), for instance thinks that many of the child stars’ parents become too engrossed with the adulation their children get, as well as with the financial windfall.

This makes it easy for them to fail to notice that their offspring are being put to work for hours at a time or are no longer enjoying what they are doing, he says.

Arist has thus linked up with some non-government organisations (NGOs) to press the House of Representatives for laws that would protect the rights of children as well as women, and for an ethics code that would respect the children’s “fundamental interests”.

“It is obvious that they (child stars) are abused and so depressed,” he says. “It is (also) evident that economically, they do not gain the portion they deserve.”

At present, there are at least 50 popular child stars in Indonesia who have parlayed their success in television shows or record albums into lucrative commercial endorsements or movie contracts. A few are believed to be raking in multimillions in rupiah each year.

There are child stars’ parents, of course, who see to it that their children are well taken care of, and that these have money tucked away for the future.

Child rights advocates, though, want this not as an “option” that parents can choose not to take, but as something they will have to do for their children. At the same time, they want to make sure that child celebrities still have time for play and for school.

Renowned psychiatrist Teddy Hidayat says that his research so far shows that child stars often perform poorly in school, partly because they frequently miss class. But he says it could also be because these children are really not as brilliant as they are made to appear.

He points to several child stars whom he says are not really talented in singing and acting, but whose rich and ambitious parents are able to hide these weaknesses with their wealth.

Says Hidayat: “This is dangerous to the children because in time they will realise what they really are. Then they don’t trust themselves.”

He also believes that many of the children in showbusiness are in the limelight not because they want to but because of their parents’ own ambitions. He argues, “Children wish for things, naturally. (But) it is their parents who want them (on) top, cheered by many and become great attractions.”

What is worse, says Hidayat, is that despite the fame and privileges they enjoy, many child stars have difficulty growing up normally.

“(They) bypass important periods of their development,” he says. “They have tight schedules made for them. They should pretend or hide their true feelings to please the audience.”

The results of all these begin to surface by the time they reach their teens, says Hidayat. He notes, “Normally, entering the adolescent period, they become fragile and emotionally immature.”

Some experts meanwhile observe that while television is used as “surrogate parents” by many families, what is emerging is a medium that has failed in its “parenting chores” and inculcating values that are alien to Indonesia.

This has prompted Dr Seto Mulyadi, an educator, to conclude that Indonesia’s child stars are unlikely to turn out as “good children” in real life.

“Television can become a good medium for developing children talent,” says Mulyadi. “Problems arise when certain parties and interests dominate the media, and when there is no proper control by regulation and ethics.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

CHILDREN-INDONESIA: Child Stardom Has an Ugly Side

Kafil Yamin

JAKARTA, May 18 2001 (IPS) - He is already a television star, so it is only natural for him to also be one of the top endorsers of consumer products in Indonesia.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags