Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

RIGHTS-VENEZUELA: Problems Enforcing Progressive Law on Minors

Mildred Pineda

CARACAS, Apr 16 2001 (IPS) - Venezuela’s new law protecting children and adolescents, considered one of the most advanced in Latin America, is still not adequately enforced a year after it went into effect, due to a lack of political will and difficulties in adapting the justice system to the new requirements, say experts.

Government officials and non-governmental organisations dedicated to children’s issues recognise the positive aspects of the new law, which considers children full citizens with rights and responsibilities. However, they say the law has not been fully implemented, due to difficulties in bringing the legal system up to par with the new legislation.

The new law that went into effect on Apr 1, 2000, replacing legislation dating to 1980, reflects the standards and guidelines laid out in the International Convention on the Rights of the Child.

The Convention, approved by the United Nations General Assembly in 1989, abandoned the view of children as “wards”, and underlines that children share all of the rights and responsibilities inherent to human beings.

The advances made in Venezuela’s legislation in the area of protection for minors, also reflected in the new constitution introduced by Chávez in December 1999, were part of the “social revolution” announced by the president when he took office two years ago.

The new legislation guarantees the right of children to food, health, education in general as well as sex education, freedom of expression, an identity, regulated working conditions for those over 14, and respect from parents and teachers.

It also states that adolescents who have committed offences have the right to defence under the concept of “juvenile penal responsibility,” under which it must be clearly demonstrated to the minor that he or she has committed a crime and is subject to the sanctions put in place by the justice system.

Statistics from the National Council on the Rights of the Child and Adolescent indicate that since the new law went into effect, 90,000 family cases have been attended. The most common problems are child abuse, visiting schedules and educational problems.

The non-governmental Community Learning Centre (Cecodap), which works in the defence of the rights of minors and was one of the main contributors to the drafting of the new law, says enforcement of the new legislation continues to run up against problems of infrastructure.

The general coordinator of Cecodap, Fernando Pereira, told IPS that “the number of judges, prosecutors and public defenders has doubled,” and praised the advances observed in the legal system because “the Convention on the Rights of the Child has been put into practice” in Venezuela.

But he pointed to the lack of “a political commitment to equip the institutions with adequate funding and resources,” and added that it was not yet possible to close down the juvenile detention centres which are criticised for falling short in their duty to reinsert young offenders in society.

A year after the law was put into practice, its chief sponsors say there is still much to be done to protect minors, who constitute one of the most vulnerable social groups in this South American country of 24 million.

According to the Central Office of Statistics and Informatics, eight percent of Venezuela’s minors – some 330,000 – were working in 1998, and 40 percent of them were under 16.

Authorities are also concerned about the number of minors sent to juvenile detention centres. From 1993 to 1997, over 27,000 minors spent time in detention centres, many of them accused of theft, drug possession and homicide, according to statistics compiled by the now-defunct National Institute of the Minor (INAM).

The president’s wife Marisabel Chávez, one of the people who played a key role in getting the new law passed, admitted that there were enforcement problems due to the judiciary’s failure to adapt to the new legal requirements.

The First Lady, who is also the president of the Children’s Foundation, has called on authorities to facilitate the creation of new institutions and the training of personnel to address the needs and concerns of children and adolescents.

Minister of Education, Culture and Sports, Héctor Navarro, also complained of a lack of political will regarding the need to implement the new law.

This year authorities have been working on boosting the stability of local institutions addressing the problems of minors, and on creating new institutions, in order to put into practice a “law that highlights our country’s position with respect to the need to defend the rights of the young,” he said.

Experts also say the difficulties experienced in implementing the new law are an indication of the inexperience of the Chávez administration and the justice system.

They point out that progressive legislation was approved, without the accompanying training and capacity building for judges and juvenile detention centres.

“The executive branch lacks the political will or managerial capacity to assume its share of responsibility,” maintained juvenile court Judge María Cristina Parra.

She added that the judges did not know what to do with youngsters who committed crimes, “because we have nowhere to send them where their human rights will be protected.”

Compounding the institutional difficulties is the lack of awareness among minors regarding the reach of the new law. At a school in Caracas, Juan José Escobar, 14, said he was not familiar with the new law, but that he was happy to know that legislation had been approved that protected him from physical and verbal abuse from adults.

“Grown-ups don’t listen to us. We have a teacher who hurts us with what he says, and that affects us,” he said.

Another student, Carlos Velásquez, said “there is physical mistreatment in the homes,” and added that he had heard that the new law “punishes adults who mistreat minors.”

Testimony like that of Escobar and Velásquez give credence to United Nations children’s fund (UNICEF) reports which indicate that Venezuela is one of the countries in Latin America with the highest incidence of child abuse.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags