Monday, November 16, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Human rights activists across North America are demanding a public inquiry into the U.S. and Canadian governments’ roles in the deportation of a Canadian citizen to Syria, where he was detained and tortured for 10 months.
Maher Arar, a 33-year-old computer technician, was arrested in New York in June 2002 by U.S. immigration officials while changing planes at John F. Kennedy Airport as he returned to Canada from a family vacation in Tunisia. He was held for nine days in New York and then deported to Syria without a hearing.
While there, he was held for nine months in a rat-infested cell, beaten, and whipped with wire cables. He was never charged with a crime.
Arar was born in Syria but left when he was 17 and is a naturalised Canadian citizen.
Syria released him Oct. 5 and since his return to Canada, Arar has campaigned for Ottawa to call an inquiry into his arrest and torture.
Those demands have been picked up by Canadian politicians, immigration activists and rights groups in Canada and the United States.
Among the documents he allegedly signed are admissions he travelled to Afghanistan in 1993 and trained at a mujahadeen paramilitary camp.
“The only way I will be able to move on and have a future is if I find out why this happened to me. The only way I can learn is to have all the truth come out in a public inquiry,” Arar told the media.
One of the Canadian and U.S. lawyers working on the case charges that Arar was deported with the collaboration of the national Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) and the Canadian Security and Intelligence Service (CSIS).
“It appears that our people are willing to use rogues states like Syria to do what they’re not allowed to do at home,” Lorne Waldman said in an interview.
His criticism was echoed by Toronto immigration lawyer and human rights advocate Arif Raza, who told IPS he believes Canada’s security agencies engineered Arar’s deportation.
Raza said domestic attempts to use harsh new anti-terrorism laws have been struck down by Canadian courts. ”Rather than prosecute these cases here, (security agencies) prefer to have suspects interrogated in places where there is no rule of law,” he said.
”We need a public inquiry to find out what happened and ensure it doesn’t happen again.”
At the media conference, Arar said the RCMP and CSIS used U.S. security agencies to send him to be tortured based on intelligence they supplied.
“The Americans did the dirty work by deporting me to a country where torture is commonplace, but from the facts I presented, especially the lease (of a house) the Americans had – and other private information – it seems very likely this information came from Canadian sources,” he said.
U.S. activists took up Arar’s cause this week, using it to shed light on a now common U.S. practice of deporting foreign nationals to countries that use torture to gather information.
Tuesday, attorneys with the Centre for Constitutional Rights (CCR) delivered letters asking the Senate and House Intelligence Oversight Committees to conduct hearings into the case.
The CCR also asked U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft to investigate whether U.S. officials condoned and aided torture. Arar has retained CCR to investigate the U.S. role in his ordeal.
U.S. media back the CCR’s claims.
On Nov. 4, the ‘Washington Post’ reported the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) maintains a covert programme called ”extraordinary rendition”, which the newspaper says is “the practice of turning over low-level, suspected terrorists to foreign intelligence services, some of which are known to torture prisoners”.
A recent report in the ‘New Yorker’ magazine by investigative journalist Seymour Hersh told of how after the Sep. 11, 2001 attacks on New York and the Pentagon, Syria emerged as one of the CIA’s most effective intelligence allies in the fight against the al-Qaeda terrorist group.
Hersh said the Syrian government shared hundreds of dossiers on al-Qaeda cells throughout the Middle East and in Arab exile communities in Europe with Washington.
Some Canadian government officials are critical of the way domestic security agencies handled the Arar case. His ”confessions” to the Syrian authorities were leaked to Canadian reporters in September, and security agents blocked attempts by Canada’s foreign ministry to help Arar.
Gar Pardy, a recently retired consular affairs chief at Canada’s Department of Foreign Affairs, says the RCMP and CSIS persistently opposed his department’s efforts to bring Arar’s case to the prime minister for intervention.
“The RCMP and the security people, that’s where the division came down,” Pardy said in an interview with IPS. “They were saying ‘we have our responsibilities and we don’t agree’.”
“I think it delayed our efforts to get him out of there to some extent, although I don’t think by a heck of a lot, quite frankly.”