Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- The George W. Bush administration is seeking changes in pollution rules for power plants and oil refineries under the Clean Air Act, considered one of the most important U.S. environmental laws.
Critics denounced the move, long awaited and announced Thursday, as tantamount to a rollback of the Act. Environmentalists said the proposals would halt government efforts to stop some of the world’s largest energy companies from polluting.
The new rules appear destined to be challenged in court. They would give industries greater flexibility in expanding electricity production without having to install additional emissions controls. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), which issued the proposals, said the changes would make plants more efficient and therefore cleaner.
EPA Administrator Christie Whitman said the existing rules “have deterred companies from implementing projects that would increase energy efficiency and decrease air pollution.”
The utility industry had lobbied intensely for the rules to be changed, arguing that pollution regulations had inhibited industrial expansion.
“At the end of the day, power plant operators need to be able to run their facilities without the perpetual threat of litigation,” said Dan Reidinger, a spokesperson for Edison Electric Institute, an industry organisation.
Democratic lawmakers and environmental organisations said energy companies might as well have dictated the proposals. They said the move would create new loopholes allowing factories, power plants, and oil refineries to emit more of the pollution that causes global warming, acid rain, and health problems.
Richard Gephardt, Democratic leader in the House of Representatives, said the administration’s plan would give utilities a choice of using any two years in the past ten as their baseline for measuring progress on emissions.
“That guarantees significant emissions increases, making it easier for utilities to evade the Clean Air Act, undermining the public health,” he said.
Environmentalists vowed to launch new lawsuits against the administration. They said the new rules would increase greenhouse gas emissions, particularly of carbon dioxide, which most scientists say trap heat and cause global warming.
“The president is trying to give polluters permission to ignore modern technology and keep fouling our air,” said Carl Pope, executive director of the Sierra Club, a national advocacy group.
The announcement follows Bush’s request that the EPA and Department of Energy conduct a review of the impact of the Act’s regulations on coal, gas and oil power plants. Vice President Richard Cheney’s energy task force urged a re-examination of the air pollution act more than a year ago.
At issue was a section of the law called New Source Review, which prohibits power plant operators from expanding old plants without also installing state-of-the-art pollution control devices.
Under the administration of Bill Clinton, the Justice Department, on behalf of the EPA, filed several lawsuits against older refineries that had allegedly expanded in recent years without installing modern pollution controls – a violation of the New Source Review requirements.
In recent months, the EPA and the Justice Department had threatened heavy fines against utilities unless they paid for pollution controls that would limits emissions of sulphur dioxide, which causes acid rain; smog-causing nitrogen oxides; and mercury, a neurological toxin. Environmentalists said power plants built between 1940 and 1970 emitted four to 10 times more pollution than modern plants.
Several state governments and environmental organisations have joined the government in suing the industry. For example, eight state attorneys general and 17 groups have joined the EPA’s suit against industry titan American Electric Power. Northeastern states have claimed that pollution from power plants in the Midwest drifts eastward.
Industry has argued that the Clinton administration had wrongly interpreted the Act’s New Source provision by applying the rule to routine changes at power plants. Utilities argued that the New Source provision was meant to apply only to non-routine changes that increase pollutants significantly.
Janet Henry, assistant general counsel for American Electric Power, said the company has complied with the Act and that power plants listed in the lawsuit were not expanded but underwent routine maintenance, replacement of degraded equipment or failed components, and other repairs that are exempt from New Source Review requirements.
“American Electric Power believes firmly that these complaints are without merit,” said Henry.
Environmentalists said the Bush revisions threaten the pending lawsuits the agencies brought to make large utilities comply with the Act.
“This is the end of the Clinton administration’s long attempt to force dirty coal-fired power plants to clean up,” said Phil Clapp, head of the National Environmental Trust.