Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

RIGHTS-MEXICO: Court Annuls Elections in Indigenous Community

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, Jun 6 2002 (IPS) - A court in Mexico annulled the results of local elections that were based on indigenous “customs and habits”, a traditional practice recognised by Mexico’s laws as well as international conventions, but which some academics and legal experts consider anti-democratic.

The elections, which were held in December in Santiago Yaveo, a municipality inhabited by indigenous people in the impoverished southern state of Oaxaca, entailed elements that were “incompatible with the fundamental rights outlined by the national judicial system,” stated a ruling handed down Wednesday by the judiciary’s Electoral Tribunal.

The Electoral Tribunal magistrates ruled that the town council elections must be repeated, because not all of the members of the community were allowed to participate. They argued that there are limits to the right to hold elections based on customs and habits.

But local election authorities in Santiago Yaveo, a municipality of around 7,000 people, said local traditions bar people living within the limits of the municipality but outside of the town proper from voting for town councillors.

However, the judicial system’s Electoral Tribunal responded that “the right of election via ‘customs and habits’ is not valid if it stands in the way of exercising the recognised rights of all citizens of this country, or if it is incompatible with internationally recognised human rights.”

One of the amendments approved by Congress in response to demands set forth by the commanders of the Zapatista National Liberation Army (EZLN) on their March 2001 visit to Mexico City guaranteed the validity of elections based on customs and habits in indigenous communities.

The amendment states that the right to use traditional practices applies only insofar as it does not contravene the guarantees and rights enjoyed by all of Mexico’s 100 citizens, 10 million of whom are indigenous people.

A study by the National Autonomous University of Mexico reported that at least one-third of the country’s indigenous communities elect their local authorities through traditional channels.

The report also notes that in most indigenous groups, women are not allowed to participate in politics, voting secrecy is not guaranteed, not everyone is free to vote, and voters’ choice to elect whoever they wish, free of religious or party pressures, is not guaranteed.

“The coexistence of a legal system of ‘customs and habits’ at a local level with a national system based on liberal, democratic principles generates major inconsistencies,” said Guillermo Trejo, a researcher with the Political Research division at the Centre of Economic Research and Teaching.

“Essential democratic values like the universal, free and secret vote are irrelevant in elections based on ‘customs and habits’,” he added.

Mexico must decide whether traditional but undemocratic forms of holding elections are valid, he maintained.

But the EZLN, a largely indigenous group that rose up in arms in January 1994 demanding recognition of the right of indigenous peoples to autonomy and self-determination, argues that elections based on customs and habits are an essential part of the lives of native communities, and must be respected.

Sergio Sarmiento, a columnist with the daily newspaper Reforma, wrote that allowing elections based on customs and habits and other indigenous traditions that discriminate against women is “absurd” in a country governed by a democratic system.

Nearly every election based on customs and habits is anti- democratic, according to Sarmiento.

One example that is frequently cited by those who question unlimited respect for indigenous autonomy is the case of the community of San Juan Chamula in the southern state of Chiapas, where the EZLN is based.

Arguing their right to govern themselves according to local traditions, authorities in San Juan Chamula have expelled more than 30,000 Indians from the community over the past 20 years because they were not “traditionalist Catholics.”

Indians living in the zone of influence of the EZLN – which only fought for two weeks in early 1994 before agreeing to an armed truce with the army, and has remained in a remote mountainous jungle region since then, staging periodic political initiatives – have complained on a number of occasions that they live under a “dictatorship” run by the rebel group.

But the EZLN commanders argue that in the communities under their control, all decisions are reached by assemblies, in a democratic manner – the same argument used by local leaders in San Juan Chamula.

There is a fine line between the necessary respect for the autonomy and traditions of indigenous peoples and the guarantees that all citizens, without distinction, must enjoy, said constitutionalist lawyer Ignacio Burgoa.

Mexico is a signatory to International Labour Organisation (ILO) convention 169, which guarantees indigenous groups’ right to autonomy.

The EZLN and organisations that back it are demanding that the government comply with the ILO convention and recognise native peoples’ right to self-determination, without restrictions.

But political scientist Jesús Reyes Heroles says that while the prospect of self-determination should not frighten Mexico’s political leaders, it must be made clear that indigenous traditions which violate the rights of women or others cannot be accepted.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags