Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Global Groups Seek Action on Mining Industry

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, May 28 2002 (IPS) - A network of environmental organisations and community-based groups worldwide has launched a campaign to pressure governments and international institutions to develop enforceable environmental and human rights standards for mining companies.

While the industry says it takes every precaution to minimise negative impacts on the environment and communities, the coalition of activists – known as the Global Mining Campaign – argue that modern mining practices around the world still lead to the forced relocation of local populations, the polluting of rivers with raw mining waste, and the destruction of landscapes and livelihoods.

“We call on governments to make a commitment to guarantee fundamental human, indigenous and environmental rights, and to put an end to practices that allow the mining industry today to externalise risks and costs to governments and society,” says Geoff Evans, director of the Australia-based Mineral Policy Institute.

As part of the campaign, advocacy groups have launched a new website and released two reports here and in Bali, Indonesia, at the fourth and final preparatory meeting for the World Summit on Sustainable Development to be held in Johannesburg in September.

Even a mine designed with state-of-the-art technologies intended to minimise the impact on the environment will have dramatic and lasting impacts on communities, the landscape, clean water and other resources, according to the report, “Digging Deep: Is Modern Mining Sustainable?”

Technical solutions are not enough to fully address the broader environmental and social issues that the industry faces, including fair compensation for communities, protecting nature preserves and respect for indigenous sacred sites, says Stephen D’Esposito, president of the Washington-based Mineral Policy Centre.

“The more important question is this: What is the most responsible and least polluting and wasteful way for society to provide itself with the material it needs?” says D’Esposito.

The report contains case studies of mines that have contaminated the surrounding environment and harmed local communities.

A gold mine in Valle de Siria, Honduras operated by Entremares Honduras S.A, a subsidiary of U.S.-based Glamis Gold Ltd, for example, has resulted in deforestation, water contamination, and destruction of several tourist sites. National mining and environmental regulations, according to the report, appear to have been ignored.

“The development of this mine, despite community concerns and objections, has resulted in a number of serious environmental and social problems,” says Roger Esocber, vice president of the Environmental Committee of the Valle de Siria.

The case studies also include mine proposals that, the critics say, are being pushed through by proponents without the consent of affected communities. One such project is an open-pit gold mine in Tambogrande in northern Peru, proposed by the Canadian company Manhattan Minerals. In an effort to dig out massive sulphide deposits containing gold, silver, copper and zinc, the mine could displace more than half the town’s population of about 16,000, according to the report.

More than three quarters of the agricultural district’s 37,000 voters have signed a petition to block the mine, and both the town’s mayor and the local Catholic archbishop are also opposed, according to Oxfam America.

“The struggle between the people of Tambogrande and the mining company is about more than just the choice between mining and agriculture,” says Keith Slack, a policy adviser with Oxfam America. “It’s about the right of local communities to protect their livelihoods and have a voice in development decisions that affect them.”

Communities in Kaispur, India have been fighting a similar battle against a proposed bauxite mine promoted by the Utkal Aluminum Project Ltd., a joint venture between the Hydro Aluminum of Norway, Indian Aluminum Company and Alcan of Canada. The mine, says the report, could displace three villages.

In response to the project, villagers organised against the project and resisted all activities – including road and bridge building – initiated by the company.

Their grievances and protests have been met with violence from the local police, says Ravi Rebbapragada, an activist with the Hyderabad, India-based group, Mines, Minerals and People. In December 2000, police opened fire at people for having organised a large public meeting. Three tribal members were killed and many seriously injured.

“At its core, the struggle over the Uktal Aluminum Project is an issue of community consent,” says Rebbapragada.

Other mines described in the report include: the Bulyanhulu gold mine in Tanzania; the proposed Poboya Park mine in Palu, Indonesia; the Kumtor Gold Project in the Kyrgyz Republic; the Ok Tedi Mine in Papua New Guinea; and the proposed TVI Pacific Mine in the Philippines.

While a different attitude in the industry toward environmental and social issues will be helpful in resolving some of the these problems, the new mining campaign says that far more than voluntary commitments and partnerships between governments, corporations, and civil society will be required to reform the mining sector.

Governments and international institutions need to develop enforceable standards and codes of conduct for mining companies that clearly define unacceptable practices and ensure that the rights of affected community are respected, says the other report released by the campaign: “Digging for Change: Towards a Responsible Minerals Future, an NGO and Community Response.”

“Communities affected by mining can then have some confidence that the mining industry’s promises are not mere words,” says Anna Cody, programme coordinator of the New York-based Centre for Economic and Social Rights.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags