Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Shareholders Challenge Companies on Global Warming

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, May 2 2002 (IPS) - Several of the world’s largest corporations — ExxonMobil, General Electric, and Occidental Petroleum among them — are confronting demand from their own shareholders to reduce emissions of heat-trapping greenhouse gases.

Fed up by what they see as inaction on curbing emissions that scientists blame for global warming, activist investors have filed 18 shareholder resolutions this year that focus on their companies’ impact on climate change.

This is about twice as many resolutions as in any previous year, according to the U.S.-based Investor Responsibility Research Centre (IRRC) and the Social Investment Forum, which promote “socially responsible” investing.

Most of the resolutions ask corporations to disclose estimated greenhouse gas emissions from their operations and the products they make, the organisations say in a joint Shareholder Advocacy Report. Investors also are asking for assessments of the costs of reducing those levels.

“Resolutions are a tool to force management to confront the issue and get shareholders to acknowledge there is some risk involved with not recognising climate change,” says Peter Altman, coordinator of Campaign ExxonMobil, an advocacy group founded by religious groups that own stock in the oil company and are concerned about its stance on global warming.

Shareholder resolutions are not legally binding under law and generally have little chance of being approved by the majority of shareholders. The five resolutions on global warming that were voted on last year garnered an average of 9.7 percent support from voting shareholders, up more than 2 percentage points from the previous year.

Despite the low percentages, activists continue to use the proposals in order to attract management’s full attention and raise awareness among shareholders.

This year’s expansion of resolutions is due in part to increased interest in climate change issues by the Interfaith Centre on Corporate Responsibility and the Coalition for Environmentally Responsible Economies (CERES), according to the report.

The New York-based Interfaith Centre is a 30-year-old advocacy group of almost 300 religious institutional investors, including churches and endowments. Boston-based CERES is an umbrella for 70 environmental groups, investors, and managers and says it represents 300 billion dollars in assets.

As of Monday, five of this year’s 18 global warming resolutions remained pending. Several — including those filed at Unocal, Wisconsin Energy and American Electric Power, reportedly the largest U.S. emitter of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide — have been withdrawn after the companies’ management agreed to produce the requested information on emissions and engage in dialogue with shareholders.

The resolutions that have already come to a vote have done better than expected, proponents say. A proposal asking General Electric to measure and report on its emissions, for example, garnered 19.1 percent of the vote last week.

“This is the highest vote we’ve ever seen for a resolution on climate change,” says Meg Vorhees, director of social-issue services at IRRC.

Most of this year’s resolutions skirt the issue of the size of emission reductions needed at individual firms for fear of running afoul of U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission rules governing shareholder proposals. Instead, according to the shareholder advocacy report, the proposals ask company managers to bear in mind the overall reductions that scientists say are necessary to halt the build-up of greenhouse gases in Earth’s atmosphere.

Companies still facing votes on their global warming practices include Allegheny Energy Inc., American Standard, Eastman Chemical Company, ExxonMobil and Occidental Petroleum.

Investor activists are closely watching two resolutions filed by ExxonMobil shareholders. One calls for a report on the company’s plans to develop clean energy and the other asks for executive compensation to be linked to environmental and social performance.

Shareholder activists have long denounced ExxonMobil’s refusal to accept that global warming is real, its refusal to set emissions reductions goals, and its resistance to invest in renewable energy sources such as wind and solar power.

“This company simply refuses to address these issues head on in a responsible manner,” says Michael Crosby, a priest of the Province of St. Joseph of the Capuchin Order, the primary filer of the resolution on renewable energy.

Fifty-six investor groups filed the resolutions, but they represent only a small percentage of total shareholders. The renewable energy resolution received 6.1 percent support in 2000 and 8.9 percent in 2001.

The Securities and Exchange Commission approved both of the ExxonMobil resolutions but excluded another that had been filed by veteran corporate governance activist Robert Monks, chairperson of LENS Investment Management and Ram Trust Services.

Monks’s resolution asked ExxonMobil to separate the positions of chief executive and chair of the board. Lee R. Raymond, identified by activists as an unmoving opponent of action on climate change, serves in both capacities.

Prompted by shareholder resolutions filed year after year, several companies have announced that they will work toward reducing their greenhouse gases.

After sustained shareholder pressure, rail and shipping company CSX Corporation agreed to post on its website the greenhouse gas emissions from its rail operations dating back to 1999. Management says it will update the information annually to prove that it is making progress in reducing its emissions.

The company says it has also developed a popular portable power unit that its trains can use in rail yards, enabling engineers to shut down the big diesel engines rather than letting them idle.

Also in response to repeat shareholder resolutions, Wisconsin Energy has acknowledged that global warming is a serious problem and has pledged to launch some major initiatives involving renewable energy. The company says it will also start reporting on its power plant emissions using a system developed by the Washington-based World Resources Institute.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags