Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-US: Senate Rejects Bush Plan to Drill for Arctic Oil

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Apr 19 2002 (IPS) - Dealing a severe blow to President George W. Bush’s proposed energy policy, the Senate sided with environmentalists on Thursday and blocked oil drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR).

Drilling in the pristine refuge was a key component of the administration’s proposed energy strategy, which passed last year by the House of Representatives. Even though Bush cast drilling as important to national security, job growth and energy independence, the president could not sway enough senators to support his plan.

Lawmakers voted 54 to 46 to end debate on drilling in the refuge. Eight Republican senators broke ranks with the president by joining 45 Democrats and Senator James Jeffords, Independent of Vermont in voting against opening up the refuge, a vast wilderness tucked along Alaska’s shore near the U.S.-Canada border north of the Arctic Circle.

President Bush’s spokesman, Ari Fleischer, said Thursday that Bush would continue to fight for opening up the refuge.

“The Senate today missed an opportunity to lead America to greater energy independence,” he said.

Democrats and environmentalists, who argued that drilling for oil in the refuge would destroy a national treasure and not make the country any less dependent on foreign oil, were exuberant.

Key to the presidential setback was the work of three possible Democratic presidential contenders: Senate Majority Leader Thomas Daschle, Senator John Kerry and Joseph Lieberman, who ran with presidential candidate Al Gore in 2000.

“We’ve sent this misguided plan to the refinery,” said Lieberman, who has called the refuge “the heart of a thriving, beautiful ecosystem”.

Daschle, who has been increasingly critical of the Bush administration in recent months even as the president’s support in public opinion polls remains high, was the chief engineer in the defeat of the proposal.

In October, he sought to thwart the measure by halting deliberations in the energy and natural resources committee over an energy bill when it appeared there were probably enough votes on the panel to approve drilling. He then presented the Republicans with the impossible task of garnering 60 votes to get the drilling proposal put back in the legislation while he mustered opposition to drilling.

Environmentalists were exuberant Thursday. “We’re thrilled that a majority of the Senate stood up to save this spectacular landscape,” said Carl Pope, executive director of the Sierra Club, a national advocacy group.

Brooks Yeager, vice president of the World Wildlife Fund’s global threats programme, said the vote was an important “goal-line” for the environment. “This vote is a significant victory for those who believe that we can develop a future-oriented energy policy that protects our wilderness and wildlife resources now and for our children’s future,” she said.

Established in 1960 by President Dwight Eisenhower, the 600,000-hectare Arctic refuge is home to more than 180 species of birds and numerous mammals including polar bears, caribou, musk ox, wolves, wolverine, moose, arctic and red foxes and black and brown bears.

The reserve is also the birthing grounds for the 129,000 animals of the Porcupine River caribou herd, and it is considered sacred land to the Gwich’in Indians, an indigenous tribe whose traditional lifestyle depends on the caribou.

Government scientists have estimated that six billion to twelve billion barrels of oil could probably be produced there. The country consumes about seven billion barrels of oil a year.

Critics of drilling in the refuge pointed to government estimates that said opening up the preserve to exploitation would not yield oil for at least seven years and then could possible yield only enough for 140 days.

Environmentalists and Democrats argued that even if drilling was allowed in Alaska, the Department of Energy projects a 25-30 percent increase in U.S. oil imports from the Middle East and Caspian Sea over the next 20 years. The United States imports almost 60 percent of its daily oil consumption, up from 47 percent a decade ago.

And conservationists warned that even without drilling in the ANWR, Bush’s energy strategy remained a wrong-headed, anti-environment proposal. Among its more environmentally controversial recommendations, the strategy proposed the construction of 1,300 new coal-fired power plants, more nuclear power plants and reduced environmental regulations for the energy industry as a whole.

“Despite the Senate’s rejection of Arctic refuge drilling, its energy bill in its current form fails to provide a strong plan for meeting the country’s energy needs, and should not be passed unless this problem is fixed,” said a statement by the Sierra Club.

Environmentalists also warned that the refuge was not the only area where the administration was hoping to drill for more oil and gas. The bureau of land management has been considering drilling in more than 50 different sites, particularly in the Western states encompassing the Rocky Mountains.

Environmentalists were already preparing for battles as heated as the one over the Arctic refuge. On Thursday, the Sierra Club filed a complaint in Federal District Court in Texas, Bush’s home state, seeking to block a gas-drilling proposal on Padre Island National Seashore, a national park.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags