Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-PALESTINE: Israel Inviting Trouble Upon Itself

Ferry Biedermann

JERUSALEM, Apr 3 2002 (IPS) - Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has finally laid his cards on the table: he has now said he wants to get rid of Yasser Arafat by trying to push him into exile.

This follows earlier statements that he regretted not having eliminated the Palestinian leader 20 years ago in Lebanon. He cannot harm him for now, though, because he has given assurances to the United States.

The plight of the Palestinian leader, besieged in his own half-demolished headquarters with Israeli troops inside, has only boosted support among his own people. “If anything happens to Yasser Arafat we will all take up arms, and this family has hundreds of members,” says Hisham Barghouti. He is a brother of Marwan Barghouti, the leader of Arafat’s Fatah ovement on the West Bank. Marwan Barghouti is a wanted man by the Israelis.

The Barghoutis have not always seen eye to eye with Arafat. Marwan, who also heads Fatah’s Tanzim militia, has at times challenged his authority. But now they feel they are in the same boat.

The family lives in Kobar, a tiny village just a few miles north of Ramallah. The village was raided over the weekend by Israeli troops, searching for Marwan. “We will take up arms if something happens to Arafat or to Marwan,” says a cousin, “because they are both leaders of our people.”

Television footage on Tuesday showed Sharon seemingly joking around with army chief-of-staff Shaul Mofaz. “We have to expel Arafat, we have to seize this occasion and get rid of him,” says Mofaz. Sharon laughs and replies that he is looking for a way to do just that. Later Sharon said European countries could at any time send a helicopter to pick up the alestinian leader, but it would be “a one-way ticket”.

Sharon’s own Minister of Foreign Affairs, Shimon Peres, was furious. The cabinet had voted against such a proposal, he said. And he thought it ill-advised.

Palestinian reactions was scathing. One of Arafat’s advisers who is holed up with him in Ramallah called it “a joke”. The Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erakat said that no Palestinian would voluntarily accept exile.

The U.S. has spoken out against Sharon’s idea. Secretary of State Colin Powell said that Arafat still had a role to play and that “sending him into exile will just give him another place from which to conduct the same kinds of activities and give the same messages that he is giving now.”

Powell said that Arafat was recognised as the leader of the Palestinians and that he would remain so abroad. “It seems to me that we need to work with him where he is — and where he is, is Ramallah,” Powell said.

Khalil Shikaki, director of the Palestine Centre for Political and Survey Research in Ramallah warns of the dangers of removing the Palestinian leader from the scene. “If Arafat is exiled or killed, a younger generation of leaders will emerge who will only go the way of violence and who will not have a political option,” he says.

“When Arafat is removed from the scene there will no longer be a Palestinian address,” Shikaki says. Despite everything the Israelis accuse the Palestinian leader of, at least he constantly says that he is willing to resume negotiations, he says.

Shikaki argues the Palestinians will only be able to negotiate a way out of the violence if there is prospect of a political solution. “If Arafat is removed the new leaders will certainly feel that the only option is violence and it will take years before they themselves develop a peace option,” he says.

The ongoing Israeli military offensive, with troops now having moved into Qalqilya, Beit Jala, Bethlehem, Tulkarem and Jenin as well as Ramallah, has not yet succeeded in its stated objective of bringing security to Israel. On Monday a police officer was killed near the centre of Jerusalem when he stopped a suicide bomber.

Another suicide bomber was caught trying to sneak into Israel Tuesday, hardly evidence that the Palestinians are giving up, or that their capacity to mount these operations has been totally eroded.

“This military offensive is not going to bring Israel security,” says Yossi Alpher, an Israeli strategic analyst and former officer with Mossad, the Israeli secret service. The action is doomed, says Alpher, because it is not accompanied by a political component. “Sharon has been trying to manipulate the Arabs by force since he entered public life,” he says. “It has not worked and it is not working with the Palestinians”.

In the short run some of the militants may be arrested or killed, says Alpher, but soon “there will be even more angry Palestinians to replace them”.

Isolating Yasser Arafat or removing him from the scene is a “totally misconceived strategy” says Alpher, who has little sympathy for the besieged Palestinian leader, whom he accuses of employing “monstrous violence” to achieve his political aims.

Shikaki fears that undermining the Palestinian Authority is already damaging Arafat’s ability to lead the Palestinians back into negotiations. “If they cannot provide services to the population and distribute funds and pay salaries, that gap will be filled by others and the only ones who are there are the Islamic fundamentalists and the radical opposition,” he says.

Shikaki describes the situation in the centre of Ramallah where he lives. “After five days they lifted the curfew for a few hours to let us buy food,” he says. “Apparently they forgot to tell the bakers because we couldn’t find bread anywhere and the supermarkets are also running out of basic foodstuff. We still don’t have electricity and most places haven’t had water for five days.”

If the Palestinian Authority and Arafat are allowed to re-establish control, he believes that the majority can still be made to go along with a new peace process, despite the effects of the current military offensive.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags