Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- A bill before the U.S. Senate, if enacted, would violate the land rights of Western Shoshone Native Americans in the state of Nevada and pave the way for further exploitation of the region’s natural resources, according to tribal leaders.
Under the controversial proposed Western Shoshone Claims Distribution bill, introduced last year by Senator Harry Reid, a Democrat from Nevada, the government would pay the 6,000-strong Western Shoshone about 130 million dollars to settle long-standing claims the United States illegally usurped the tribe’s land and resources.
The funds would be released from a federal trust fund that has been accumulating interest since the government decided in 1979 to award the tribe 26 million dollars.
Proponents of the legislation argue the money will help lift the Native American tribe out of poverty. They say the proposal enjoys wide support from the tribe. “The Western Shoshone have waited long enough for the distribution of these much needed funds,” says Reid.
However, the Western Shoshone National Council, which represents a number of communities, strongly opposes the measure. The claims, it argues, do not represent an adequate accounting of the land taken by the government. Accepting the funds, it says, would thwart any attempt to get title to some of the traditional homelands, which the tribe is guaranteed under an original 1863 treaty between the Western Shoshone and the U.S. government.
“This bill would foreclose any litigation in U.S. courts over land title disputes involving the Western Shoshone,” says Ian Zabarte, secretary of state of the Nevada-based Western Shoshone National Council. Zabarte is visiting Washington this week.
He says the legislation does not have the support of the Western Shoshone as Reid claims. When the proposal was put to a referendum in Nevada, 1,230 Western Shoshone voted in favour of disbursement of funds and 53 opposed it. More than 4,500 did not vote.
The Western Shoshone, he explains, typically “vote with their feet,” meaning that they usually do not vote at all if they disagree with a proposal.
“The Senators have been misinformed about what we want,” says Bernice Laylow, an elder who belongs to the Council. “We believe the bill does not resolve the larger issue of land and title.”
Christopher Sewall, with the Nevada-based Defence Project, an advocacy group under the Native American foundation Seventh Generation Fund, says the bill “would wipe away any cloud” concerning land ownership in the region — a move that would benefit large mining companies and others interested in buying up land currently claimed by Western Shoshone communities.
“Reid would be able to say that there are no more questions about land titles,” says Sewall.
Mining interests have long sought to exploit the Western Shoshone’s gold-rich land. Mining by white settlers began on territory claimed by the tribe in the early 1800s. Today, about half a dozen mines operating in the area account for the majority of gold produced in the United States.
The industry has strong ties to Reid. Mining companies were one of the main industries supporting his election bids from 1997 until 2002, according to the Washington-based Centre for Responsive Politics (CRP), a non-partisan group that tracks money in politics. Newmont Mining and Barrick Goldstrike Mines – two companies in the region – donated more than 20,000 dollars each to his campaign during the same time period.
Those Western Shoshone who do support Reid’s bill argue that the communities need the claim money and tribal governments have been dragging their feet on disbursement of funds.
A small non-profit organisation, known as the Western Shoshone Claims Steering Committee, which helped Reid draft and promote the legislation, says that it supports land, grazing, hunting, and fishing rights, but that the tribe deserves to have the claim money disbursed.
“Let’s get the money to the people,” says Larry Piffero, co-director of the committee, “We need it very badly.”
The Western Shoshone claims against the United States stem from a 1946 Indian Lands Claims Commission decision to compensate Native Americans for lands and resources taken from them by the federal government.
In 1962, the commission determined that Western Shoshone land – which at one time covered at least one-third of the state of Nevada, as well as parts of Utah, Idaho and California – have been taken through gradual encroachment. The commission awarded the tribe more than 26 million dollars in 1977. In 1979, the government appropriated the funds to reimburse the tribe.
The Western Shoshone National Council and the Western Shoshone Defence Project, however, say that the commission proceedings denied the tribe due process and ignored evidence of existing Western Shoshone land title, as described in the 1863 Treaty of Ruby Valley.
When Western Shoshones have tried to seek justice through U.S. courts over land disputes, judges have deferred to the commission’s findings. Exhausted by the U.S. court system, the Council has been pursuing its grievances against the U.S. government through the United Nations Committee to Eliminate Racial Discrimination (CERD) and the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights of the Organisation of American States.
A Western Shoshone delegation went to Geneva last July seeking the support of CERD. The U.N. committee expressed concern regarding the treatment of the Western Shoshone in its August 2001 concluding observations about racial discrimination in the United States.
The committee noted “with concern” that treaties signed by the United States and Indian tribes “can be abrogated unilaterally by Congress and that the land they possess or use can be taken without compensation by a decision of the government.”
It said it also was concerned about the “expansion of mining and nuclear waste storage on Western Shoshone ancestral land, for placing their land to auction for private sale and other actions affecting the rights of indigenous peoples.”