Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS: Home Troubles Curb Canada Commission’s Work Abroad

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Mar 15 2002 (IPS) - Racked with dissent, criticised for abusive management and accused of waste and ineffectiveness, the Canadian Human Rights Commission is leaderless as it grapples with a legacy of neglect at home and immersion overseas.

Michelle Falardeau-Ramsay, once touted as a strong candidate for the Supreme Court, left the commission at the end of last month. In December, she asked the government not to renew or extend her five-year term, saying she was exhausted.

Whoever replaces Falardeau-Ramsay, a lawyer who rose through the federal bureaucracy and the ranks of the commission to the chair’s job, will have to deal with damning reports released last year by management consultants and by a retired Supreme Court of Canada justice.

One of the main criticisms levied against Falardeau-Ramsay was that she spent too much time traveling and advising developing countries on human rights issues. The commission’s mandate is to deal with Canadian issues only. Yet, according to critics, the body under Falardeau-Ramsay allowed human rights problems at home to fester.

Last year, the body received 1,238 new complaints. It settled 286 old cases and referred another 123 to tribunals.

Consultants Watson Wyatt Worldwide, brought in by the government to help solve the agency’s morale problems, has recommended the commission pull back on international commitments.

Falardeau-Ramsay’s travel expenses showed she spent 87, 119 and 80 days traveling outside Canada in 1997, 1998 and 1999 respectively. Her travel bill in those years was 173,000 dollars. Other government departments, such as the Canadian International Development Agency, picked up the costs.

Among 165 recommendations contained in last year’s report by retired Supreme Court Justice Gerard LaForest’s was a controversial proposal to prevent discrimination against the poor. This was considered significant because, in an interview in 1997 when she began her term, Falardeau-Ramsay had said her main goal would be a rule against social class discrimination. There has been little political will in the government for this, however.

The commission declined to comment for this article and said Falardeau-Ramsay, who did not respond to numerous requests for an interview, no longer talks to the media.

The body had been in trouble even when Falardeau-Ramsay took over.

Bell Canada, the telecommunications giant, challenged the tribunal’s independence when pay equity hearings began in 1996. A Federal Court justice ruled the tribunals were not independent enough from the human rights commission to conduct fair and impartial hearings. The government quickly passed legislation to address the court’s concerns.

In 1999, Auditor General Denis Desautels examined the agency and issued a report criticising its impartiality and speed in handling cases. He urged the government to revamp the commission and rewrite its mandate.

Desautels’s report said the commission could not be an impartial investigator and conciliator of complaints while, at the same time, promoting and advocating human rights policies.

The commission has more pressing problems than a need to reform and extend its mandate, however. Commissioners and staff lawyers have quit and criticised the agency. Morale among those who have stayed is said to be very low.

Over the past year, more than 60 percent of the staff has left. According to one survey, all of the rest are looking for other jobs.

Commissioner Robinson Koilpillai said the agency has spent too much time and effort on international issues, which are not even part of its mandate.

“As far as money, domestic programmes are not suffering but if human resources and energies are expended there without increase in human resources to deal with domestic demands, well then, something will give,” said Koilpillai.

Watson Wyatt’s report described a remote and controlling senior management that workers felt shows little respect for them. Employees complained about the commission’s direction, leadership, and poisoned working environment.

A six-member senior management committee runs the commission. The report singled out Falardeau-Ramsay and Secretary General John Hucker, the chief operating officer who oversees day-to-day operations. The commission employs 200 people and has a 10 million dollar budget.

Consultants surveyed 300 present and former employees. Staff said it was typical that Falardeau-Ramsay was traveling in Indonesia when the report was released last fall. Before leaving, she had suspended a commission lawyer for talking to the media about morale at the agency.

Employees complain senior executives publicly criticised their work, cast blame on others for mistakes, never consulted workers and retaliated against staff members who expressed disagreement. Managers were also accused of playing favourites, discriminating against women when promoting, and trying to undermine the staff union.

“While many of (these) practices and behaviours should not be acceptable in any workplace they are all the more disturbing in an organisation that is dedicated to human rights and equality,” the report said.

At a press conference after the report was released, Falardeau-Ramsay said she found the employees’ perceptions sad and added: “I don’t think we really have to take blame for those failures. We did always the best that we could with the resources, the tools we had at our disposal.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags