Monday, November 16, 2026
Brian Kenety
- Czech Prime Minister Milos Zeman – under fire by neighbouring Austria and Germany for labelling ethnic Germans deported from the former Czechoslovakia after World War II as “traitors” and “Hitler’s fifth column,” lucky to have escaped the death penalty – has promised to make a symbolic “humanitarian gesture” to honour anti-fascists.
Over 2.5 million ‘Sudeten Germans’ were stripped of their Czechoslovak citizenship and property and expelled from the country under a set of August 1945 decrees by the then president Eduard Benes. The measures, which modern-day critics say, were tantamount to sanctioning collective guilt of the Czech-German population, were formally approved by the Allies at the Potsdam peace conference. These have never been taken off the law books.
A humanitarian gesture to honour anti-fascists “would show that the dividing line is not between Czechs and Germans or Sudeten Germans, but between collaborators with, and fighters against, totalitarianism,” Zeman told German television last week, while maintaining that those who “participated in the genocide of the Czech people” should not be eligible for any compensation.
Though the Czech prime minister has ‘clarified’ his remarks in letters to his German and Austrian counterparts, observers here note that with Czech parliamentary elections coming in June, he remains unapologetic in public.
“In local politics, the Benes Decrees were a moot point. Zeman rose to the challenge from Haider and now the gloves have been taken off. It could again become acceptable to exploit the issue for short-term political gain,” an official from a Czech-German association, who did not wish to be identified, told IPS.
“I am angry: a decade of progress has been undermined. Old grudges are resurfacing just when relations had stabilised,” said the official.
Zeman’s comments, which he has since significantly toned down, touched a raw nerve among the small but politically very active Czech-German Diaspora. A two-day official visit by Germany Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder, like Zeman a centre-left Social Democrat, scheduled for Mar. 22-24, was nearly called off, with Berlin demanding an explanation from Prague.
The lower house of the Austrian parliament is considering a call for a class-action law suit demanding the repeal of WWII-era legislation and the restitution of property.
Five years ago, in January 1997, the Czech Republic and Germany signed a ‘Declaration of Reconciliation,’ in which a ‘gentleman’s agreement’ was reached wherein Prague and Berlin pledged their respective politicians would not try to gain political mileage from exploiting WWII-era laws. No agreement along such lines has been reached with Vienna; calls by Sudeten German groups in Austria are falling on deaf ears.
Analysts here say that has been portrayed in the Czech media as an infantile ‘war of words’ between Zeman and Joerg Haider of Austria’s ultra-right Freedom Party (FPOe) over the Benes Decrees, has threatened to undermine Prague’s bilateral relations with Austria and Germany and embolden right-wing nationalists across borders.
“In the past, Austrians and Germans were all considered to be ‘Germans’. This is no longer the case. Since 1990, the relationship between the Czech Republic and Austria has worsened, from very cordial to rather tense; whereas, the relationship with Germany has been improving all the time, until it stabilised last year”, Jaroslav Huk, an analyst for the Prague-based STEM polling agency, told IPS.
The cool in Czech-Austrian and Czech-German relations came on the heels of a petition drive by Austria’s Haider to close the Czech nuclear reactor Temelin, a controversial hybrid of Soviet-era design with Western safety upgrades located in southern Bohemia, some 60 kilometres from the Austrian border.
In a January interview for the Austrian newsweekly ‘Profil’, Zeman said Haider’s petition, signed by nearly one million Austrians, was “not aimed at Temelin, but rather against Czech membership in the European Union” and compared it to the 1938 Nazi-organised referendum promoting the Anschlusss, Germany’s annexation of Austria.
“It would be good if you got rid of your Haider and his post- fascist party as soon as possible,” said Zeman, a Social Democrat. “I believe in the friendship between our two peoples. However, there are more and more provocations coming from the Austrian side. Austria was not the first victim of Hitler’s Germany, but rather its first ally.”
STEM’s Huk said the Czechs “understand that Haider is acting for his own domestic political purposes; the same goes for Zeman. Whereas Czechs agree with what Zeman has said, many disapprove of the provocative manner in which he said it.”
This week Conservative German chancellor candidate, Edmund Stoiber, speaking at a rally of his Christian Social Union party in Passau, said it was unacceptable in a European Union expanding to East for the Czech premier to refer to the Sudetens as a fifth column of Hitler.
“The Czech prime minister has a lot to learn in order to arrive in Europe,” warned Stoiber, adding to cheers that Sudetens could rely on him to look after their interests.
Although in 1999 the European Parliament approved a resolution calling for the Benes Decrees to be abolished, as much as Prague would like to ensure a smooth entry into the EU, it would be “political suicide” for a Czech politician to do take the laws off the books, said political analyst Jiri Pehe.
Pehe, an advisor to Czech president Vaclav Havel when the 1997 Czech-German declaration was agreed, told IPS that the five-year old agreement was a “rather inelegant attempt to sweep the issue of the (Benes Decrees) under the carpet” but the negative feelings still remain and “the Czech politicians still simply have not come to terms with the need for some apology” for applying collective guilt to the German diaspora.
“Unfortunately, the moment a Czech politician says something conciliatory, he is open to attacks as a traitor. If you look at opinion polls in this country, 70 to 80 percent of Czechs believe that the WWII expulsions were the right thing to do and that we should not apologise,” he said.
“Even (President) Havel has stopped short of issuing a formal apology. When he tried to do so shortly after the fall of Communism in 1990, he was immediately accused of selling out,” said Pehe.
The Sudeten German Landsmannschaft in Austria (SLOe) intends to file a lawsuit at Czech courts against the Czech Republic, demanding the abolition of the consequences of injustice caused by the Benes decrees. The move is designed to achieve the restitution of property nationalised after 1945 or an adequate compensation.
The SLOe has also sent a letter to Czech President Vaclav Havel calling on him to push through a reassessment of the “retribution decrees” from 1945-1946. The SLOe points to the recent abolition of 7,000 verdicts in Russia and asks Havel to “send a similar signal” for redressing the post-war wrongs committed on Sudeten Germans.
In an interview with CTK news agency, Josef Blahoz from the Czech Academy of Sciences Institute of State and Law said that on a practical level, Czech courts would likely reject such complaints.
“However, the Landsmannschaft can support unsuccessful restitution claimants who have launched a great number of individual appeals against the rejection of their property claims,” said Blahoz. The Czech Constitutional Court could also study whether the Benes decrees correspond to the Czech Constitution, he said.