Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS: Canada Sucked into U.S. Prisoner Maelstrom

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Jan 30 2002 (IPS) - Canadian soldiers fighting alongside U.S. troops have handed three prisoners taken in southern Afghanistan to U.S. military authorities without a hearing, Defense Minister Arthur Eggleton said Tuesday.

Eggleton said he knew last week of the prisoner hand-over, which took place Jan. 21, but did not tell Prime Minister Jean Chretien until Tuesday morning.

Chretien defended the minister’s decision to keep the prisoner hand-over secret and voiced his support for the transaction but the move clearly has opened a rift within the government that resembles the fault line that separates the defence and foreign policy wings of the U.S. administration.

The revelations have fuelled furious debate here over Canada’s role in the U.S.-led “war against terrorism”. Canada is the only country to send soldiers to assist U.S. forces searching for Taliban and al-Qaeda fighters in Afghanistan. Canadian requests to send troops to serve in the British-led peacekeeping force based in Kabul had been turned down.

Eggleton’s admission also came as a surprise to Foreign Affairs Minister Bill Graham and others who just the night before had debated what the prime minister said was a hypothetical question: Whether prisoners taken by Canadian troops should be processed in keeping with Canadian and international law, and their treatment subject to Canadian judicial review, or whether they should simply be handed over to U.S. authorities regardless of current controversies under international law and custom.

“I think the government has made it very clear that all detainees will be treated, when held by Canadian Forces, in accordance with international law and particularly in accordance with the Geneva Conventions,” Graham said in Parliament.

“We have been involved in the capture of prisoners, yes,” Eggleton said after a cabinet meeting. “This is with respect to the JTF2 (a Canadian counter-terrorism unit) so I can’t go into the details other than to tell you that, as I have said, they were turned over to the United States military.”

Eggleton said he heard of the elite troops’ operation last Friday and told the cabinet on Tuesday. He confirmed that an Associated Press photo printed in U.S and Canadian newspapers last week showed the Canadian soldiers hustling three bearded prisoners off a plane at Kandahar airport.

Chrétien said Canada expects the United States will treat the prisoners humanely. He added that a preliminary agreement said Washington would respect international law but the details still have to be worked out.

Member of Parliament Svend Robinson, military critic for the centre-left opposition New Democratic Part, said “the government’s position on prisoners in Afghanistan is not only legally indefensible but it is morally bankrupt.

“If Canada is not prepared to allow prisoners that are captured to be executed, why is it that we are prepared to turn over those same prisoners to the United States to be tried before a military tribunal and by a majority vote to be sentenced to death? Is that not the ultimate in outsourcing of our moral obligations?”

Chretien said the turnover of prisoners “has been conducted entirely within international rules and Canadian law. We have transferred those detainees to the United States as is covered in international law. They are the ones who have to determine, through a competent tribunal, the status of those particular detainees. They are the ones who establish the military commissions.

“All of this needs to and will be done in a fair and humane way. That has been understood right from the beginning,” Chretien said.

The issue of the disposition of prisoners hits several Canadian hot buttons. In 1991, Canadian troops tortured to death a Somali non-combatant at a Canadian peacekeeping force camp near Mogadishu. The killing sparked a political scandal when the military tried to cover up details of the murder.

Later, the Chretien cabinet shut down a government inquiry into the killing before it could issue its report.

As well, government critics say Canada has sent 800 troops -50 commandos and 750 infantry – to Afghanistan to curry favor with Washington. The administration of President George W. Bush deployed 1,500 soldiers and National Guard troops along the Canadian border after last September’s terrorist attacks; since then, searches of trucks and trains have slowed Canadian exports to the U.S. Trade with its southern neighbour accounts for 40 percent of Canada’s gross domestic product.

New Democrat leader Alexa McDonough told Parliament, “Secret tribunals leading to the death penalty are not Canadian values. This government may choose to wear a moral blindfold but Canadians care a great deal about what we stand for at home and abroad.”

In an interview, she said the Canadian government has become a proxy for the Bush administration.

“The government has been blindfolded to the safety issues here and the moral issues. It’s been quite clear from day one that Canada was not prepared to take the principled, independent role that is called upon us to play as an independent, sovereign nation. I think it’s just been ‘aye, aye sir’ every step of the way. The answers to really serious questions have been ‘we don’t know yet because we haven’t been given instructions from Washington.

“We are coming more and more under the American economic orbit. And people are understandably very concerned and upset in the aftermath of September 11 and it’s very easy to turf your values and set aside fundamental principles in that very charged atmosphere. That’s when leadership really counts, and we’re not getting leadership on that,” she added.

Conservative Party leader Joe Clark, a former Prime Minister and minister of foreign affairs, said, “What kind of keystone cops are running this government?”

Chretien said he put his faith in the Bush administration. “At this moment, we are of the view that international and Canadian law should apply,” he added. “There is a debate going on in the United States and abroad, and I think that international law has to apply.”

Eggleton said the Canadian government does not have qualms about the treatment of prisoners at the U.S. Camp X-Ray at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. “They’ve done that in the case of these prisoners because these people were violent and they wanted to kill their captors,” he said of the extraordinary security measures at the prison camp.

Washington has refused to label the detainees prisoners of war because this would circumscribe their ability to interrogate them. Pentagon officials have said, however, that treatment of the detainees is in keeping with the spirit of the Geneva Conventions.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags