Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Jorge Piña
- The existence of Juan Diego, a 16th century Mexican Indian convert to Christianity, which is questioned by a group of Mexican clergymen, “has been absolutely proven,” according to the Vatican, which is getting ready to canonise the man to whom the Virgin of Guadalupe supposedly appeared.
Pope John Paul II plans to travel to Mexico on Jul 28 to declare Juan Diego a saint. The official announcement of the canonisation will be made after a meeting of cardinals to be called by the pope.
Tradition holds that the Virgin of Guadalupe, proclaimed by the Vatican the “patron saint” of Latin America in 1920 and “the mother of the Americas” in 1960, appeared to Juan Diego in 1531, on the site where the Basilica of Guadalupe – Latin America’s leading religious pilgrimage site – now stands.
The Miracle of Guadalupe was officially recognised by the Vatican in 1745.
In 1990, Juan Diego was beatified by Pope John Paul – the step before full sainthood.
However, the process of canonisation ran into hurdles when a group of priests asked the pontiff to study the matter carefully, citing historical facts to argue that there was no clear evidence that Juan Diego actually existed.
Sceptics say the story of Juan Diego was concocted to convert local Aztec Indians to Christianity and weaken a brewing insurgency.
They point out that the church built where the Virgin Mary supposedly appeared just happened to be constructed on Tepeyac, the very site of an Aztec temple dedicated to Tonatzin – earth goddess and mother of the gods – which had been destroyed on the orders of a Catholic bishop.
Mexican Archbishop Javier Lozano Barragán, president of the Pontifical Council for Health Pastoral Care, told IPS that this is the first time in the modern history of the Roman Catholic Church that a canonisation process has awakened controversy among the clergy of the future saint’s country.
Lozano Barragán, whose post is equivalent to minister of health, dismissed a letter sent by four Mexican priests to Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Angelo Sodano, calling into question the existence of Juan Diego.
The letter, which was datelined Dec 4, was not made public until Monday. The Vatican has issued no official statement on the matter.
The Mexican archbishop, who said the priests were only “making a lot of noise and causing a lot of harm,” stated that the existence of Juan Diego “has been absolutely proven.
“Their position is completely false, because (the question) has already been examined with full scientific rigour,” said Lozano Barragán.
“These clergymen continue to insist on this, even though they are totally mistaken,” said the Mexican archbishop. “They already came here to Rome and visited the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, where they were told to present their arguments to the Congregation of the Saints.
“They did not do that. But the Congregation of the Saints set up a special panel that carried out an in-depth study into the case and issued its verdict,” he added.
In the past, church authorities in Mexico have threatened to excommunicate the sceptical priests, although they have not done so.
The reporter who published the letter from the Mexican priests in the Italian daily Il Giornale, Andrea Tornielli, told IPS that “the case is closed, and Juan Diego will be proclaimed a saint by the pope.”
Tornielli, an expert in Vatican affairs, predicted that the letter would have no effect on the final outcome, because the Catholic Church had already investigated the criticisms set forth by the four clergymen.
The letter, signed by the abbot emeritus of the Basilica of Guadalupe, Guillermo Schulenburg, the former director of the basilica’s library, Esteban Martínez, and two priests who are also university professors – Carlos Warnholtz and Manuel Olimón – states that “the existence of the Indian Juan Diego has not been demonstrated.
“We could obtain the signatures of many well-informed clergymen as well as lay intellectuals to back this letter, but we don’t want to cause a useless scandal. We only want to prevent the credibility of our Church from being eroded,” said the letter’s authors.
Schulenburg, Martínez, Warnholtz and Olimón maintained that the Vatican was committing a grave error, and recommended a postponment sine die of the canonisation.
If the process goes ahead, they argued, the infallibility of the pope – one of the doctrines of the Roman Catholic Church – would be affected, because it is impossible to declare someone who did not exist, as may be the case of Juan Diego, a saint.
On Dec 20, before the Mexican priests’ letter had been made public, the daily L’Osservatore Romano published an essay by Colombian priest Fidel González, which cites a number of documents that supposedly prove that Juan Diego existed.
One of the documents, discovered by a Spanish Jesuit priest, shows Juan Diego’s death certificate, dated 1548, and contains the signature of Antonio Valeriano, who wrote poems in a local indigenous tongue describing the appearance of the Virgin of Guadalupe.
Sources at the Vatican say the only thing that could stand in the way of the pope’s fifth visit to Mexico would be his health. Mexico, population 100 million, is the country with the largest number of Roman Catholics in the world, second only to Brazil (population 170 million).
In his 23 years as pontiff, John Paul, who is now 81, has beatified 1,235 clergy or faithful and canonised another 443.
One of the decisive elements in the Church’s determination to canonise Juan Diego was a Vatican panel’s ruling that the recovery of a man who tried to commit suicide by throwing himself from the third floor of a building in 1990 was a miracle attributed to Juan Diego.