Thursday, November 19, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- A Canadian company has filed a complaint under the North America Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) to overturn a recent U.S. government decision to ban many hemp products.
Last October, the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) banned ingestible hemp products. Merchandise must be off shop shelves by Feb. 6.
A Canadian company, Kenex Ltd. of Chatham, Ontario, filed last week a 20 million dollar claim under NAFTA’s Chapter 11, the section of the treaty that requires equal treatment for companies operating in Canada, the United States, and Mexico. Canadian companies have filed very few Chapter 11 cases but U.S. firms have used the section to challenge Canadian and Mexican environmental laws.
Kenex argues it is being penalised because it will not be able to ship its hemp seed oil across the border, even though it can still be sold legally in the United States for use in soap and cosmetics. Although hemp cultivation is banned in the United States, the hemp business there is worth more than 30 million dollars per year.
The Canadian government has supported this country’s hemp producers. Trade officials here recently warned the DEA that its ban was an attack on a legal, regulated Canadian industry. Canada requires hemp products to be labeled. Stems, seeds, or flowers of industrial hemp plants can contain more than 0.3 per cent THC, a psychoactive ingredient. Marijuana contains between 10 and 30 per cent THC.
Canada also has said the DEA rules violate World Trade Organisation requirements that countries conduct risk-assessment tests before prohibiting products.
Canada has allowed commercial farming of hemp since 1998 and has actively encouraged farmers, many of them ex-tobacco growers, to plant it.
“The notice is a way of saying that we have a problem, and we want a solution. Once it was filed, the sides involved have three months to work it out,” Todd Weiler, a Toronto-based lawyer representing Kenex, told IPS.
“Our Chapter 11 claim says that it’s unfair the way the Drug Enforcement Administration has gone about banning these products, that what they did was not fair and equitable. Under NAFTA, foreigners have to be given the same treatment as citizens of a signatory country. People in the U.S. can sell poppy seeds, which contain very minute traces of opium, a controlled substance, while my clients can’t sell hemp seeds, which contain minute traces of THC. That’s not fair.
“Originally, the DEA proposed a rule that any product that had hemp in it was gone. Now, they say anything that has hemp in it can stay, as long as you can prove it doesn’t enter the body. They believe all hemp and marijuana is the same thing. The truth is the opposite. And they claim that hemp products give false positives for THC on drug tests. That’s not true at all.”
U.S. officials were unavailable for comment.
Kenex’s suit is modeled on one filed by the U.S.-based Metalclad Company, which successfully challenged the denial of a construction permit by a Mexican municipality for the building of a toxic waste facility. Likewise, environmental and health bans against suspected toxins have been challenged, with one case already resulting in the reversal of a Canadian government ban on the gasoline additive MMT and a 12 million dollar payout by the Canadian government to the additive’s makers.
A number of Canadian Chapter 11 cases now are working their way through the system. A Canada-U.S. dispute over softwood lumber tariffs and a dispute between a Quebec steel company and the U.S. state of Virginia over “Buy American” favoritism in awarding highway construction contracts are heading to arbitration.
A U.S. court also is trying the case of a Canadian funeral home chain, Loewen Group Inc., which was hit by a Mississippi court jury with 500 million dollars in punitive damages. For the first time, the United States is being sued by a private corporation for cash damages under the “investor-to-state” provisions of Chapter 11 of NAFTA.
The DEA’s hemp prohibition also is being fought by the U.S. hemp- food industry, which every year sells five million dollars’ worth of grocery items such as Hemp Chips, Hempmylk, Healthy Hemp Sprouted Bread, Hemp Plus Granola Bars and Hempzel Pretzels.
The Hemp Industry Association recently filed a lawsuit of its own against the DEA in a San Francisco court. Kenex is listed as a co- plaintiff.
DEA Administrator Asa Hutchison, who announced the ban Oct. 9, argued hemp must be banned because THC is a controlled illegal substance. “Many Americans do not know that hemp and marijuana are both parts of the same plant and that hemp cannot be produced without producing marijuana,” he said.