Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Debra Percival
- Hopes are running high among European diplomats that this week’s summit of European Union (EU) leaders will put an end to the protracted squabbling between the EU’s 15 member states over the distribution of its aid package.
EU leaders, who meet in Cannes France on Monday and Tuesday, are still at loggerheads over grants to 70 African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) nations, six Eastern European countries — all in line for EU membership — and 12 Mediterranean countries.
But the biggest row is over funding for the next five years to the 70 ACP states under the five-year second financial protocol of the Lome IV Convention (1990-2000) — the EU’s flagship of development aid and trade preferences to developing countries.
Unlike other development funds which come from the EU’s general budget, Lome funds are pooled from the national contributions of EU member states whose allocations are decided on the basis of a Gross National Product (GNP) key.
The eighth European Development Fund (EDF) for the ACP states which will run from 1995-2000, should have been sealed at the end of February.
But it was delayed because of internal wrangling over the size of national allocations of several EU member states, notably Germany and Britain, both of whom wanted to put in considerably less this time around.
Over the past four months France has struggled to get support for a 11.8 billion European Currency Units (ecus) — about 15.57 billion dollars) package which in itself represents a drop in real terms over the current 10.8 billion ecu (14.25 billion dollar) aid budget of the seventh EDF.
But diplomats in Brussels told IPS at the weekend that a compromise arrangement may be in sight.
If agreed on, the compromise arrangement would see an aid package of 13.3 billion ecus (about 17.55 billion dollars) which still would not represent a “real” increase in development funds to ACP states for the rest of the decade, taking into account inflation rates.
Under the compromise, all EU states, barring Britain would be called on to up their national contributions.
This is not going down well in some EU nations, particularly The Netherlands and Italy.
The Netherlands, which currently contributes more to the Lome than the “GNP key” dictates, will be asked to increase its contribution from 606.12 million ecus (800 million dollars) to 690 million ecus (910 million dollars).
Italy, which currently puts in slightly less than it should, will have to increase from 1.417 billion ecus (1.87 billion dollars) to 1.63 billion ecus (2.15 billion dollars).
Germany, which along with Britain has been asking all along for a sizeable cut, will have to up its contribution in line with its “GNP key” to three billion ecus (3.96 billion dollars).
To the fury of the Netherlands and Italy, Britain on the other hand which currently puts in slightly more than is required on the GNP scale at 1.790 billion ecus (2.36 billion dollars) will be allowed to reduce its contribution to 1.630 billion ecus (2.15 billion dollars).
A senior British official told IPS that the deal meant that Britain, whose aim is to reduce its contributions to multi-lateral donor bodies and direct more of its aid budget to bi-lateral projects, could accept the compromise.
Other factors paving the way to a possible settlement in Cannes is that France, which relinquishes the rotating presidency this week, is willing to up its contribution from 2.665 billion ecus (3.517 billion dollars) to 3.1 billion ecus (4.092 billion dollars) to become the biggest contributor to the fund.
Also, the executive European Commission In Brussels has agreed to scrape the drawers for previously unspent EDF to come up with some 450 million ecus (594 million dollars) in unused special loans, emergency aid and money that had been earmarked for Somalia, which because of civil conflict, has never ratified Lome.
One Dutch official described the compromise as “totally unacceptable”, but the senior British diplomat said he expected the compromise arrangement to get the nod. Some member countries are still “shadow boxing”, he said.
ACP states diplomats have however said that 13.3 billion ecus is inadequate. They say some of Lome’s special funds like ‘STABEX’, which offsets the decline in commodity export receipts, are under funded and to make up for this, the aid package should rather be in the vicinity of 15.8 billion ecus (20.85 billion dollars).
The Lome budget wrangle has stopped other areas of the so called Lome IV mid-term review from progressing like improved access to the EU market for ACP farm produce.
And it has also delayed agreement on future aid budgets for Eastern European and Mediterranean countries, which are a lot closer to home.
Germany is seeking to make sure that a bigger share of EU aid money goes to Eastern Europe, whereas Spain and France want to make sure that the Mediterranean does not lose out in any carve up.
Earlier this month, the EU tentatively agreed on 1.3 billion ecus (1.71 billion dollars) in grants for Eastern Europe for 1996 and 700 million ecus (924 million dollars) for the Mediterranean.
But Germany blocked this deal with complaints about insufficient funds for Eastern Europe and is now seeking to fasten down more funds in the future for this region on its doorstep.
But France is insisting that it is unable to agree more funds at this stage for both Eastern Europe and the Mediterranean without an agreement on the Lome.
That is another reason why the EU leaders will be keen to cement a Lome deal here this week.