Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

TURKEY-INFORMATION: Angry Journalists Protest Official Truth

Nadire Mater

ISTANBUL, Oct 29 1996 (IPS) - Turkey’s journalists were dismayed the other day when they heard the minister of foreign affairs describe the situation in their country.

“To all our friends who are concerned over human rights in Turkey… we aim to bring the most civilized modern norms to our country so that the individual may benefit,” said Tansu Ciller.

But she spoke on the same day the Court of Appeals confirmed the sentencing of veteran novelist Yasar Kemal, 78, to 18 months in jail. Alper Gormus, editor-in-chief of the mainstream weekly ‘Aktuel’ started serving his one and a half year term.

Ayse Zarakolu and Ertugrul Kurkcu, publisher and translator of a Human Rights Watch report on Turkey were placed on trial that same day, and faced six years in jail. Another veteran author 70 year- old columnist Cetin Altan was indicted under similar threat — on the very day Ciller maee her statement.

Last Friday, media workers could take no more: they staged a mass protest against increased government pressure on freedom of expression and denounced Ciller for attempting to make the picture rosier that it really was.

Hundreds of reporters, editors, TV commentators gathered in Istanbul’s media district, Ikitelli, to express disbelief that the foreign minister could claim to be “promoting human rights in Turkey up to the most advanced standards.”

“Yasar Kemal, Cetin Altan, Alper Gormus and other publishers, writers, journalists, not necessarily of the same opinion, are in trouble and under the threat of imprisonment. Add this the intentions of introducing a more restrictive new press law,” said Tugrul eryilmaz, editor in chief of the Sunday supplement of the Istanbul daily “Radikal”.

Referring to the protest, he said: “This the least we can do in order to express our concerns for increased pressure on freedom of expression and thought.”

It was the first time in Turkey’s recent history that journalists of all ideological shades and status — liberals, centrists, feminists, leftists, editors in chief, editorial assistants — had joined forces in this way.

However, Yurdagul Erkoca of daily Radikal believes the manifestation was “a little bit too late, and too wide to embrace even those tycoons who bear much responsibility in the media’s present enslaved situation.”

“Protesting against Kemal’s condemnation is of course necessary but why should I unite forces with those who had initially directed the blitz against Kemal himself,” she told IPS.

Kemal himself declared: “I am 78 and they want to prevent me from writing. It seems that those judges believe they will be honored if I would die in prison. But I cannot help writing. I will continue (writing) in the prison.”

Last week, Sweden’s Uppsala University gave its Freedom of Expression award to Kemal. The writer was previously condemned by a local court for his article “Black Skies over Turkey”, and for publishing a collection of articles by several other authors devoted to “freedom of thought in Turkey”.

The court found Kemal guilty of violating Article 312 of the penal code which punishes “provoking public hatred based on ethnic, racial and regional discrimination.” The article in quewtion was about Turkey’s policy towards its Kurdish population.

“I both expected and did not expect such a decision,” he told IPS. “It came like a lightening from the blue. Yet my intention is so clear that I do not even attempt to defend my article. As long as the war with the Kurds continue secession is inevitable, that is what I say and that needs no explanation.”

His contemporary Cetin Altan is also faced with six years in jail for the critical opinions he offereed on the present political situation.

“I wish the state would transform itself from a gang to a lawful state,” Altan was quoted to say in an interview with him in Istanbul based national daily Milliyet. Prosecutors brought a lawsuit against Altan. They charged him with “public defamation of the Turkish Republic.” Another trial for a previous statement by Altan is also pending.

“Can we not express messages what might not please the authorities?” asks Nilgun Cerrahoglu of Milliyet, who interviewed Altan. “Cetin Altan has been commenting on similar issues for 50 years. I cannot understand why his words have been found guilty now after five decades of incessant criticism.”

The chain of arrests began earlier this month. Composer Sanar Yurdatapan, spokesperson of a peace initiative was detained in Istanbul and transferred later to Ankara where he was formally imprisoned under orders by Ankara’s State Security Court.

He was accused under the Turkish Penal Code of “aiding members of an armed organization” – in this case the Kurdish Workers’ Party (PKK).

The allegations against him are that he has directed a TV show for the Kurdish satellite TV channel MED-TV, he has composed the a sound track for a documentary aired by the channel and that he signed a newspaper notice to protest an attempt on the life of Abdullah Ocalan, the PKK leader.

Amnesty International (AI) immediately denounced Yurdatapan’s arrest saying, “the sole reason for Sanar Yurdatapan’s imprisonment is his tireless and imaginative work on behalf of freedom of expression and peace.”

Prosecutors in Istanbul brought charges against Ertugrul Kurkcu and Ayse Nur Zarakolu for translating and publishing a November 1995 report by the Human Rights Watch Arms Project, “Weapons Transfers and Violations of the Laws of War in Turkey.

Kurkcu and Zarakolu are both charged under Article 159/1 of the Turkish Penal Code for “defamation and belittling of the state’s security and military forces.”

“Rather than punishing the messengers, the Turkish government should punish the abusers and end the impunity that has allowed for violations by the security forces to continue unchecked for so long,” says Joost Hiltermann, director of the Human Rights Watch Arms Project.

Journalist Ipek Calislar of the Istanbul daily Cumhuriyet told IPS she hoped the demonstration would warn both the public and the authorities “to withdraw government pressure from over the intellectuals and journalists.”

However, she added: Going out in front of our offices and clapping in protest is terribly insufficient when contrasted with the colossal pressure. We have to be more active or we will lose everything in a slavish manner.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags