Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

LITHUANIA-HUMAN RIGHTS: Tough Measures To Tackle Gangs Worry Some

Edvinas Butkus

VILNIUS, Feb 27 1996 (IPS) - Newly appointed Lithuanian interior minister, Virgilijus Bulovas, has powers to detain suspects without trial that would make many a dictator envious. But, he says, these powers help his country win the war against organised crime.

Formerly vice-chairman of the Lithuanian-Russian governmental commission on bilateral cooperation, Bulovas, 57, took over as minister of interior on Feb. 23, immediately stepping into a very different and much more intense debate.

The laws allowing “preventative detention” of individuals were recently extended by the Lithuanian parliament to the end of 1996.

Those Lithuanian MPs who were opposed to the amendment and those who abstained from voting complain that preventative detention was out of keeping with both the Lithuanian constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights. Neighbouring states Latvia and Estonia do not have such laws.

But a report produced by prosecutor general Vladas Nikitinas before the parliament voted to extend the detention law, in effect since the middle of 1993, concluded that though a drastic measure, ‘preventative detention’ was undoubtedly effective.

The preventative detention regulations have been used during the first ten months of last year to detain 243 individuals. During the same period, 130 of them were indicted on criminal charges and another 87 criminal investigations were initiated.

At the beginning of February, 14 residents of the Central Lithuanian city of Panevezys were arrested by the police and Interior Ministry’s organised crime investigation agency. The detainees are alleged to belong to three notorious gangs.

A number of firearms, gas pistols, number plates and technical certificates belonging to stolen vehicles have been found in a series of such search operations in Panevezys, sanctioned by the Prosecutor General’s Office.

The local law enforcement officers in Panevezys were not involved in the arrest operation to prevent leaks of information. Panevezys, Lithuania’s fifth largest city, is notorious for its violent gang wars. Around 20 gang-related killings have been recorded there in recent years.

It was the national authorities’ second attack on organised crime this year. The first targeted Henrikas Daktaras, ringleader of The Doctors, one of the most powerful gangs in the city of Kaunas. Daktaras faces up to three possible charges according to sources in the prosecutor general’s office.

According to the daily Lietuvos Rytas, Daktaras participated directly in certain crimes, though in a large number of cases he was not personally involved.

The daily said The Doctors had been involved for years in a range of crimes from murder, blackmail, robbery and theft to smuggling and trading drugs, metals, oil and illicit liquor. More recently the group had also turned to using ‘front’ men to take out loans from banks that they did not plan to repay.

Last year, the paper said, The Doctors had become more involved in government economic and political activity and alleged a series of secret deals with officials. Daktaras was sentenced in 1987 to eight years imprisonment for armed robbery, larceny and other crimes, but was released after serving three years.

In Lithuania there are an estimated 100 organised criminal groups, three quarters in the seven largest Lithuanian cities, with total core membership of about 1,200 criminals. Latvian and Estonian police estimate that there are 10-15 such groups operating in each of their smaller countries.

“If you let underground bosses go free, I am afraid that some politicians may represent criminals’ interests already in the upcoming parliamentary elections,” Bulovas told a recent regional seminar on control of crime. “Big money is like a monster”.

He also predicted that the opening of large scale trading routes — he cited the new oil terminal on the Lithuanian coast north of Klaipeda and plans for major imports of orimulsion fuel from Venezuela — might open up new opportunities for drug smugglers.

For this reason Lithuania is especially interested in international cooperation with law-and-order officials — though he criticised the lack of interest shown by the EU’s Europol police network in cooperating with nations that were not full EU members.

The most influential gang in the capital, the so-called Vilnius Brigade, was shut down by police in 1992-93. “There are no (crime) ‘families’ in Vilnius,” said Chief Area Prosecutor Rimantas Grockis, “this is not Kaunas or Italy.”

He said the “criminal pyramid had collapsed” and people are no longer terrified by such gangs. No other gang has so far moved into the space they left, he added.

But the crime rate still remains high in the Vilnius area, increasing by 10 percent in 1995 compared to 3.5 percent for the country as a whole. And it is estimated that up to 70 percent of reported offences in the area, mostly thefts of personal property, are not reported to police.

Yet in comparison to its Baltic neighbours Lithuania does not have such a major problem. The situation is far worse in Estonia and only slightly better in Latvia. According to latest figures, an average of 149.3 crimes per 10,000 Lithuanian residents were registered in 1995; compared to a dramatic 242.6 per 10,000 in Estonia and 140.8 per 10,000 in Latvia.

This has weakened the case against the ‘preventative detention’ laws, and enlivened the debate on another source of concern to observers of human rights in Lithuania, its retention of the death penalty.

Lithuanian president Algirdas Brazauskas has encouraged lawyers, politicians, public bodies and the press to initiate a discussion on the future of capital punishment legislation, amended in 1990 to ban death sentences for women or children.

Since then the courts have imposed seven death sentences, one of which was later commuted to life imprisonment by presidential decree.

Brazauskas is aware that the public perception of crime in his country may not favour the case to retain capital punishment; yet statistics indicate that it is failing as a deterrent to premeditated murder.

Last July, defending the execution of top Vilnius Brigade leader Boris Dekanidze for his part in the murder of an investigative journalist who probed the gang’s activities, government spokesman Vilius Kavaliauskas said that “abolishing the death penalty was not on the agenda. The crime situation does not allow it and society won’t support it either.”

Amnesty International was one of several foreign groups that criticised the action, saying it was inconsistent with Lithuania’s desire for European integration. Most Western European nations have abolished the death penalty.

“We know the death penalty is not the best example of good democracy,” Kavaliauskas said. “We can begin discussions about abolishing it in some years. We will do it later, but not now.”

Aside from Amnesty, the Council of Europe has also urged Lithuania to refrain from imposing carrying out death sentences, citing the sixth protocol of the European Convention on Human Rights — which has not yet been ratified by Lithuania.

This is clearly damaging to Lithuania’s image throughout the world, Brazauskas admitted.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags