Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

ECONOMY: U.S. Stimulus Package Scored as Unfair and Off Target

Tim Shorrock

WASHINGTON, Oct 16 2001 (IPS) - The 100-billion-dollar Republican stimulus bill being considered this week in the U.S. House of Representatives is badly skewed towards the rich and will do little to stimulate the immediate investment needed to pull the United States out of recession, says Nobel economics laureate Joseph Stiglitz.

Recent drops in sales figures nationwide show “there’s very little doubt we’re in a recession,” says Stiglitz. “The proposals from the White House and House Republicans don’t address this country’s needs.”

“The September 11 attacks have brought us together,” he adds. “It is not fair if a lot of the tax benefits go to a few rich people.”

The House Ways and Means Committee, in a partisan vote of 23-14, passed the stimulus package. Its centerpiece is a tax cut, similar to one implemented during the summer, which would provide tax rebate checks to lower-income workers and accelerate tax reductions for middle- and high-income taxpayers. The bill goes to the full House this week.

The bulk of the Republican package – 70 billion dollars in tax credits – will go to corporations through provisions to establish a permanent investment tax credit, eliminate the corporate alternate minimum tax, and cut the capital gains rate. Corporations will also be given accelerated tax write-offs for investments in plant and equipment. A special tax break was provided to financial services companies with operations abroad.

The importance of the tax breaks to the corporate sector could be seen Oct. 12 in the Ways and Means Committee hearing room, which overflowed with corporate lobbyists from, among others, industries including insurance, home building and oil and gas, as well as companies including General Electric. Its financial services subsidiary, GE Capital, has an enormous presence overseas.

To Stiglitz, who won his Nobel Prize for research into the imperfections of markets and their inability to allocate resources fairly, the bill is a classic example of his theories. Not only are the Republican proposals unfair, he says, they will not stimulate the new investments needed to create new jobs.

He is particularly critical of the tax reduction package for individuals in the 28-percent tax bracket.

How much will a worker making

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags