Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines, North America

FINANCE-CANADA: Green, Rights Groups Blast Export Agency Rules

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Oct 1 2001 (IPS) - Canada’s government has introduced legislation that would allow its export credit agency to exempt itself from most environmental and public scrutiny, warn environmental and human rights groups.

The new law was drafted after three years of public consultations and hearings. It would allow the official Export Development Corporation (EDC) and the finance ministry to exempt the agency from environmental assessment of its projects.

The EDC, which carries some 17 billion dollars of foreign debt on its books, has been criticised by non-governmental organisations (NGOs) for its financial support of hydroelectric projects and mining ventures that have had devastating environmental impact in developing countries.

NGOs say the new law also ignores their calls to make the agency accountable for human rights violations by companies and governments that are partners in EDC projects.

“EDC should be legally obliged to respect international human rights law in all its projects,” says Warren Allmand, a former minister in charge of Canada’s federal police and internal security apparatus who is now president of the NGO Rights and Democracy.

A coalition of 17 groups is reacting with anger to the proposed changes in the Export Development Act introduced by the government in late September, saying it reflects none of the recommendations of an NGO working group.

The NGOs will have a last chance to voice their concerns when the Canadian parliament holds hearings on the bill next year.

“We need to amend the Act to make sure the Export Development Corporation upholds Canada’s commitments to protect the environment, human rights, and the public right to basic information,” says Imilie Revil, coordinator of the NGO working group. “The changes presented will have negligible impact on the daily operations of the corporation. They leave a proven bad driver behind the wheel.”

“Government took the low road in legislating the environment under EDC’s own Act instead of the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act. As in the case of transparency, government has left the fox in charge of the henhouse,” Revil adds.

Although the government has proposed amendments to require environmental review of EDC’s activities, it leaves it to EDC to determine the objective, scope, standards and application of the environmental review.

In May 2001, the Auditor General, the officer of the Canadian parliament responsible for monitoring the efficiency of Canada’s bureaucracy, found the EDC failed to implement its own environmental framework correctly in 92 percent of cases reviewed.

NGOs also have criticised the Canadian government, the sole shareholder in the EDC, for refusing to endorse a Group of Eight (G-8) report that urged the world’s leading powers to stop subsidising fossil fuels and nuclear power. This, they said, shows the government is too pro-business.

The NGOS want the EDC’s environmental framework to be regulated under the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, effectively making the agency follow the same rules abroad that Canadian businesses and government agencies must observe at home. The coalition also is calling for the mandate of EDC to be changed to ensure that the agency supports and develops Canadian trade in a manner consistent with Canada’s obligations to protect the environment and human rights.

In the mid 1980s, EDC stopped releasing project-related information. It is now drafting its own information disclosure policy but is under pressure from several Canadian business groups to limit its openness. The Canadian Chamber of Commerce says businesses could be harmed if information about proposed projects is released.

Even if the EDC does come up with a more open information disclosure system, this will not have legal force. The NGOs say the new law must be amended to require EDC to disclose basic information to the Canadian public and that the agency must be placed under the federal government’s Access to Information Act.

EDC has been involved in a number of controversial investments blamed for social and environmental problems. It facilitated

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags