Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

POLITICS-PERU: Playing the Race Card

Abraham Lama

LIMA, Apr 4 2001 (IPS) - The possibility of Alejandro Toledo becoming Peru’s first indigenous president has heightened racial tensions in this South American country, where the descendants of Europeans have held a tight grip on power since the Spanish conquest.

Toledo, who enjoys 40 percent ratings in the polls just five days before Sunday’s presidential elections, has played the race card in the campaign, appealing to the one-third of Peru’s 25 million people who are of Andean Indian origin like himself. Another 50 percent of the population is “mestizo” (of mixed-race heritage).

The candidate has dubbed himself Pachacutec, the name of the greatest pre-conquest Inca emperor, and announced that if he won the elections, he would hold his swearing-in ceremony at Machu Picchu, the famous Inca ruins.

Toledo’s wife Eliane Karp, a Jewish anthropologist from Belgium, who he met when they were both studying at Stanford in the United States, proclaimed her husband two weeks ago the incarnation of the mythical “Incarri”, an indigenous chief whose mission was to free his fellow Indians.

Karp has studied Peruvian indigenous culture and speaks Quechua, the Andean Indian language that was spoken throughout what is today Peru prior to the Spanish conquest.

“After 500 years of domination by the whites, the time is coming in which the Indians will recover power. The ‘apus’ (hills) have spoken,” Karp said at a rally in Huaraz, a city in the Andes mountains located 400 kms northwest of Lima.

Toledo’s supporters and his rivals mutually accuse each other of racism.

Toledo himself has sought to discredit his adversaries, accusing them of being opposed to his candidacy “because they refuse to accept an Indian president.”

His rivals, meanwhile, accuse him of appealing to his ethnic identity and humble social origins to gloss over the conservative nature of his platform.

Toledo is a former World Bank economist who has taught at Harvard. In the 2000 elections, when he stood fourth in the opinion polls, he pledged to continue following the neo-liberal economic policies of President Alberto Fujimori (1990-2000), of Japanese descent.

During his first bid for the presidency, Toledo stumbled across the ethnic banner, which helped him take second place in the first round of the elections, and to dispute the May 2000 run-off with Fujimori, who won a constitutionally dubious third straight term in elections widely considered fraudulent, which led a few months later to his impeachment and the calling of new elections.

“In Peru, there is no Chiapas (a reference to the Mexican state where the Zapatista guerrilla movement is active) nor a CONAIE (the powerful Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador) to bring the government to bay,” said historian Manuel Burga.

“However, the Andean indigenous concept of political struggle has been incorporated, which explains the broad support for Toledo,” he added.

“Toledo seems to communicate telepathically with the great masses of Indians and ‘mestizos’, and is seen by them as an equal, although in his political organisation, he is surrounded by non- Indians and ‘criollos’ (people of Spanish extraction),” said Burga.

While one-third of Peruvians are of indigenous descent, around half are of mixed-race heritage, with different mixtures of indigenous, African, Asian and European blood. As the saying goes, “in Peru, he who has no inga (Indian) has mandinga (African)” blood.

Although the white minority has governed the country since the Spanish conquest, five presidents were “mestizos”, known in Peru as “cholos”, like Toledo: Ramón Castilla, Luis Sánchez Cerro, Manuel Odría, Juan Velasco Alvarado and Alan García.

The first four were military strongmen. García, who governed Peru from 1985 to 1990, is still the leader of the social democratic Aprista Party, and will stand in next Sunday’s elections.

In Peru, the line between “indigenous” and “mestizo” is a fuzzy one. The majority of Indians do not identify themselves as such. Even though they speak Quechua, they define themselves as “mestizos”.

Social researchers attribute that to the fact that, although “mestizos” or “cholos” also suffer discrimination, they have more possibilities of social ascent than Indians.

“In Peru, the indigenous masses have turned their backs on their ethnic identity to obtain citizenship, in other words, the right to own land and vote,” said sociologist Carlos Iván De Gregori with the Institute of Peruvian Studies.

“Unlike Ecuador and Bolivia, countries with more clearly defined racial identities, virtual caste systems, where the Indian is Indian and the white person is white, Peru’s Indians have sought to be identified as ‘mestizos’ or ‘cholos’,” said De Gregori.

“The process of cultural ‘cholification’ runs counter to the process of strengthening the ethnic identity of indigenous communities,” said sociologist Jaime Urrutia. “Those who were Indians defined themselves as ‘cholos’. Like Toledo himself, who now claims to be an Indian, but who at the start identified himself as a ‘cholo’ from the Andes mountains.”

Toledo is popularly known as “El Cholo”.

Urrutia, the technical secretary of indigenous affairs at the Ministry of Women and Human Development, said that in government programmes, “integrating” Peru’s indigenous peoples has consisted of encouraging them to stop being Indian.

“Nor has Peru’s left understood the indigenous cultural question,” he added. “José Carlos Mariátegui, the leading ideologue of Peruvian socialism, merely equated the Indian problem with the land problem in the mid-20th century.”

Toledo’s candidacy has attracted the support of a number of prominent intellectuals and politicians of European descent, who apparently place little importance on their leader’s attempts to cultivate an ethnic image.

One of them is internationally renowned writer and former presidential candidate Mario Vargas Llosa, perhaps the most coherent exponent of economic neo-liberalism in modern Peruvian culture.

While Vargas Llosa backs Toledo’s candidacy, in his 1999 essay “The Archaic Utopia”, he described proposals in favour of indigenous rights as “backwards.”

“The most important political phenomena of the last 30 years, including the fast growth of the Maoist guerrillas and the unexpected triumph of Alberto Fujimori in the 1990 elections cannot be understood without taking racial tensions into account,” said sociologist Raúl Viera.

“There is a large sector of Andean indigenous youth who have a radical impatience to find their identity, and are prepared to take up insurgent banners or anything that looks like one,” said Viera.

“That sector swelled the ranks of the Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path) guerrillas, the Maoist party that emerged with exotic slogans and actions, like hanging dead dogs adorned with signs reading ‘death to Deng Xiao Peng’,” the reformist Communist Chinese leader who died in 1997, said the sociologist.

“When it took on the character of an ethnic war,” Sendero Luminoso “was on the verge of defeating the army and the government,” he added.

“Fujimori’s triumph was also explained from the viewpoint that the indigenous and mestizo masses saw someone of Japanese extraction as more similar to them than a ‘whitened’ mestizo putting on airs of a ‘señorito criollo’ (a ‘master’ of Spanish descent), like Vargas Llosa,” who was defeated by Fujimori in the 1990 run-off, said Viera.

He also cited the more recent example of Colonel Ollanta Humala, who rose up in arms last October and waited in vain for other officers to follow suit, but who won broad support among the young with his vindications of indigenous rights.

In the main cities along the coast and in Peru’s southern Andes mountains, brigades of “Humalistas” (Humala followers) emerged, mainly made up of former soldiers, who paraded through the streets asking the baffled colonel to provide them with weapons.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags