Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Canada will have to abide by its prime minister’s pledge to ratify the Kyoto agreement on global warming without changes, despite growing pressure from business groups, environmentalists say.
The Canadian government is under intense pressure to back out of Prime Minister Jean Chretien’s promise – made at last month’s Earth Summit in Johannesburg – to ratify the Kyoto Protocol and abide by its existing rules, says John Bennett, director, atmosphere and energy, of the Sierra Club of Canada.
Industries, some provinces and many of the country’s top civil servants, are pressuring Chretien to delay ratifying Kyoto until the agreement is revised, so that Canada gets “credits” for exporting natural gas and hydroelectricity exports – so-called “clean” energy.
“You can’t ratify Kyoto without ratifying all of it,” Bennett said. “The government may try to negotiate energy credits before ratification, but I believe, in the end, they will do what the prime minister said they are going to do, and ratify it.”
“They may try to make agreements with other countries about energy credits, even after the agreement is ratified, but once it is ratified, it’s the law of the land, and they will be held to it,” Bennett said.
In his unexpected speech to the Earth Summit, Chretien cited rapid climate change in the country’s vast arctic territories for his decision to ratify the agreement. As well, Canada’s agricultural heart, the central plains, is now in their third year of record drought, causing farmers to sell their cattle herds.
“Extreme weather events are affecting the Inuit of the Canadian arctic and farmers on our prairies. Indeed, they are affecting people the world over. This underscores the reality of climate change as well as the imperative for global action, an imperative that is strongly felt by Canadians,” Chretien told the summit.
His governing Liberal party should easily win a vote on ratifying the treaty, expected in late October or November.
But a group of Canadian industries have hired the multinational lobby groups APCO Worldwide and Hill and Knowlton to co-ordinate an anti-Kyoto campaign in heavily-industrialised Ontario province, home to most of the Liberal government’s parliamentary seats.
“The-pressure on the government is enormous,” Bennett said. “It’s coming from the oil industry but also from Canadian car companies and banks as well.”
“Industries and oil companies have raised a war chest that will be used to try to convince people in Ontario that their jobs in the car industry will be lost,” he added. “In fact, Kyoto will create more jobs in Ontario as people have to replace older cars.”
“We have a big job in front of us as people are bombarded with propaganda that’s not true,” Bennett said.
Duff Connacher, director of Democracy Watch, an organisation that follows government lobbying, says he is monitoring the deployment of anti-Kyoto forces.
“It’s a massive campaign, but Chretien is retiring soon, so it may not have the impact that we would have seen if he was staying on through another election. Still, it’s a formidable force,” Connacher said.
He added “progressive people in Canada, many of them in Chretien’s own party, won’t let him back out of Kyoto. It will be part of his legacy – maybe even the most important thing he’s done since (he was elected prime minister in) 1993.”
The Canadian decision, along with a similar one by Russia, pushed the number of countries ratifying Kyoto over the threshold of 55 industrialised countries needed to make the treaty international law.
Chretien’s announcement was a blow to U.S. President George Bush, who did not attend the Johannesburg summit and has set out to kill the Kyoto treaty since his inauguration last year. The United States succeeded at the summit in blocking targets for increasing renewable energy supplies.
Pressure on the Canadian government is also coming from the oil-rich western province of Alberta. Its government has hired a popular former premier, Peter Lougheed, as its anti-Kyoto spokesman and has bought advertising in the country’s major newspapers attacking the pact.
As well, Alberta premier Ralph Klein is demanding a meeting of provincial government leaders before the treaty is submitted to the federal parliament. Failing that, he is threatening a court fight.
“It’s Plan B, but we will try to make as strong a (public relations) case as we possibly can, along with the private sector, to convince the federal government that a lot more work needs to be done, a lot more questions need to be answered,” Klein said.
“Ratifying the Kyoto protocol now would be like signing a mortgage for a property you’ve never seen, at a price you’ve never discussed.”