Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

CZECH REPUBLIC: Plan to Return Church Property Opens Pandora’s Box

Jiri Kunc

PRAGUE, Oct 27 1996 (IPS) - The Czech government appears to have unlocked a Pandora’s box when it agreed to return without any charge lands belonging to the Catholic church, and the buildings on which they stand.

Its plan to hand over the assets in December has caused a furore.

Political parties, including from Prime Minister Vaclav Klaus’ own coalition, have denounced the decision. And there is even less understanding among Czechs who have always found it difficult to reconcile the Church need for extensive material assets.

Milos Zeman, leader of the largest opposition party, the Social Democratic Party (CSSD) and speaker of the parliament, said: “The government is only administrator of the state’s possessions and cannot give away whatever they want”.

Besides his own Democratic Civic Party (ODS), Klaus’ coalition includes the Democratic Civic Alliance (ODA) and the Christian Democrats (KDU-CSL).

The conditions set for their return are that they “were of religious or administrative nature to this institution in the past” and that their return “will not hurt the public interest”.

Government officials said they wanted to put an end to the debate that began in Nov. 1989 when communism was overthrown and demands were made for the return of property appropriated or confiscated by the communists in 1948.

But the Restitution Law of 1990 provided for benefits only to individuals. It made no provision for institutions or companies with more than one owner. In one celebrated case two brothers who owned a company and founded a society to administer it, could not claim their property.

At first any consideration that property would be given back to religious institutions like the Catholic Church — the richest institution in the country — got complicated by the fact that some of the property involved, like acres of forests, were confiscated in 1947 and the Restitution Law covers property seized after 1948.

Previously the government was careful to abide by the letter of the law and avoid any legal conflict with the minority Sudenten Germans who have been lobbying for the return of property expropriated before World War Two.

Religious institutions are subsidised by the Czech state which is in charge not only of keeping and restoring monuments but pays Bishops, Archbishops and priests.

The restitution affair and its ups and downs started in April 1992 when the Czech-Slovak Federal Parliament rejected a law on the issue. A year later the government of the newly established Czech Republic agreed that properties on which claims could not be made for financial restitution “for damages caused” would be excluded from any proposed restitution.

In 1994 a commission consisting of four deputies from Klaus’ coalition made an inventory of the church’s properties and proposed devolution. Parts of the proposal were deleted by parliament last year though at that moment the government boasted a majority.

The Czech constitution stipulates that the restitution of property does not need the approval of parliament. The Czech cabinet has thus issued an executive order to return to the church some of their former belongings. “What counts is the principle of justice of the cause and not its economical value,” said Klaus.

The government also decided to ask the ministries of culture and finance to prepare a plan on ways to improve church-state relations, how to deal with properties left after the restitution and procedures to implement these plans.

According to the official list, the church would have to receive 175 square kilometres of real estate and 25 square km of cultivable land if full restitutiion takes place. Also 2,500 buildings not counting the churches.

Catholic Bishop Frantisek Lobkowicz said: “We’re rejected by materialism (capitalism), we’re decimated by atheism and tempted by the properties devolution.”

According to the Institute for the Investigation of the Public Opinion, one in five Czechs believes in God. In 1946 the proportion of believers was estimated to be two thirds of the population.

In the Czech Republic, the Catholic Church has always been viewed with distrust because of its past role. During the 14th century, the church owned more than a third of all the land. The Pope’s financial policies bitterly punished noblemen, bourgeoisie and the people in general. And a great part of the ecclesiastical hierarchy had German backgrounds.

In the 15 century, Jan Hus fought against this order of things, claiming that the corruption of the church had its origins in the excessive material opulence. He was executed on the orders of the church. This act is still considered as an insult to the Czech nation.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Europe, Headlines

CZECH REPUBLIC: Plan to Return Church Property Opens Pandora’s Box

Jiri Kunc

PRAGUE, Oct 24 1996 (IPS) - The Czech government appears to have unlocked a Pandora’s box when it agreed to return without any charge lands belonging to the Catholic church, and the buildings on which they stand.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags