Headlines

RIGHTS-MIDDLE EAST: Caught Between Hammer and Anvil

Yasser Talaat

CAIRO, Aug 14 1999 (IPS) - Human rights issues, including gender inequalities, are slowly coming out of the shadow in the Arab world as peace talks seem to be resuming, closer United Nations scrutinies are taking place, and a new generation of rulers is replacing the old guard.

“Democrats and human rights activists in the Arab world are caught up between the hammer of government policies and the anvil of civil strife,” Moroccan Prime Minister Abderrahmane El- Youssoufi told IPS in a telephone interview.

“Violations of human rights have given rise to political problems, leading to a crisis of legitimacy,” added the former militant lawyer who spent nearly four decades between prison and exile before Morocco’s late King Hassan II called him to form a socialist-led government last year.

The London-based human rights organisation Amnesty International called earlier this month for quick improvements of the human rights situation in Morocco under the new king, Mohammed VI, after more than three decades of iron-fisted rule by his father, Hassan II.

In a final statement issued by human rights activists from 15 Arab countries following their meetings in the Moroccan city Casablanca last July, participants united in having suffered suppression by their governments, also agreed on a 10-point action plan, dubbed the “Casablanca Declaration.”

The declaration urged Arab governments to revise legislation and remove laws that conflict with the right to freedom of speech and expression. It also stressed the need for modern legal institutions such as independent judiciaries and parliaments which many Arab countries lack.

A controversial issue raised at the meeting was the rights of minorities in the Arab world, particularly the Kurds, spread between Syria, Iraq, Iran and Turkey.

“The discussions included the ongoing political stability in countries such as Algeria, civil wars in Somalia and Sudan, tight international sanctions against Iraq and the sensitive issue of the role of Islam and conflicting interpretations of its tolerance of human rights,” explained Bahieddin Hassan, director of the Cairo Centre for Human Rights Studies.

Hassan called on the Arab league to revise the Arab Charter for Human Rights adopted in 1994, which he described as “the worst document ever issued” on human rights.

“There is a total suppression of basic human rights in Iraq, Libya, Syria. Besides, there is a back-pedalling practised by Egypt, Tunisia, Yemen and Jordan,” commented the Egyptian human rights activist Ahmed Fikry.

He blamed the worsening human rights situation on the violent tactics employed by the authorities and radical groups trying to install Islamist regimes in countries like Algeria and Egypt.

Ramzy Zaki, a leading economic analyst, suggested the underlying reason is the worsening poverty in many Arab countries, caused by the implementation of economic and social policies under the supervision of international monetary institutions.

But Hassan Wagih, a lecturer at the economic and political studies faculty at Cairo university, blamed the situation on “a deep-rooted anti-democratic tendency among Arab ruling elites.”

Meanwhile, a recent report issued by the Brussels-based International Confederation of Free Trade Unions describes Egypt – a close US ally – as a country where trade unions have to operate in a climate of fear, under constant government scrutiny.

The report, which was designed to complement the World Trade Organisation’s trade policy review on Egypt – published on June 25 – noted that there is no right to strike, and that police have a record of brutally suppressing strikes, since they are seen as a form of public disturbance.

“There is a strong social pressure against women in pursuing a career, and this is not helped by a legislation which limits women’s access to equal employment,” the report said.

“According to the Egyptian government’s own figures, two million children aged between 6 and 15 are working, an increase of over 50 percent in just 10 years” said Saadiya Bahadr, an expert in childhood care.

In their first joint report on human rights conditions in Egypt, entitled “The Issues of Human Rights in Egypt,” the country’s three main human rights groups claimed last week that human rights conditions in the country “deteriorated seriously in 1998” despite some positive changes.

An Emergency Law, which has been in effect since the assassination of president Anwar Sadat in 1981, is viewed as the principal vehicle for human rights abuses in Egypt.

The tenth annual report issued at the same time by the Egyptian Organisation for Human Rights (EOHR), says that 1998 witnessed the passing of a number of freedom-restricting laws, some disguised as measures to curb growing criminality.

Another point of consensus in both reports is concern at the escalation in social violence, despite a significant decline in political confrontations.

Both documents slammed the security forces’ increasing recourse to violence, or excessive force, to disperse peaceful gatherings. They also condemned the continued referral of civilians to military courts and the “significantly large number of death sentences which reached 85 in 1998.”

But the director of the Human Rights desk at the Egyptian Foreign ministry, Naila Gabr, insisted that such violations had been “minimal.”

“I am not saying that we are the best country in the world in terms of respect for human rights, but things are improving,” added Gabr.

“The massacres of the last six years in Algeria have taken against a background of systematic human rights abuses committed by security forces, state-armed militias and armed opposition groups, who call themselves “Islamic groups” stated the Cairo- based Algerian political analyst Khaled Omar Bin Kaka.

Some 100,000 people are estimated to have died, 3,000 disappeared and hundreds of thousands peasants were displaced in Algeria since 1992, when the Algerian army reacted with a coup to the electoral triumph of the radical Islamic Salvation Front (FIS).

The Islamists launched a frontal war against the country’s institutions, frequently through indiscriminate terrorism. In response, “extra judicial executions, deliberate and arbitrary killings, torture, disappearances, abductions, arbitrary detention and death threats have been part of the daily reality in Algeria,” Bin Kaka added.

The violence is coming to an end, however, thanks to reconciliation initiatives taken by Algeria’s new president Abdleziz Bouteflika, combined with strong military actions that have rendered the FIS armed groups ineffective.

The Iraqi leadership, said the UN human rights rapporteur Max van der Stoel last March, has “effectively eliminated the civil rights to life, liberty, physical integrity and the freedom of thoughts, expression, association and assembly.”

In Saudi Arabia, political activities and organisations as such are just banned as “subversive,” while the status of women ranks among the worst in the Arab world. They cannot drive cars, and they need the permission of a male relative to travel abroad and a male escort for domestic travel.

” I think it is time for a more fair and open-minded approach to the conditions of women in the Arab world, if we really want to find a place for us in the New World Order” Galal Amin, a prominent Egyptian writer said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS-MIDDLE EAST: Caught Between Hammer and Anvil

Yasser Talaat

CAIRO, Aug 9 1999 (IPS) - Human rights issues, including gender inequalities, are slowly coming out of the shadow in the Arab world as peace talks seem to be resuming, closer United Nations scrutinies are taking place, and a new generation of rulers is replacing the old guard.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags