Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-U.S.: Bush Moves to Boost Logging in Federal Forests

Katherine Stapp

NEW YORK, Aug 29 2002 (IPS) - President George Bush is forging ahead with a controversial forest fire management plan that has infuriated the nation’s leading environmental groups.

Seven senior officials from the U.S. Forest Service and Department of the Interior were named Wednesday to promote Bush’s ‘Healthy Forests Initiative’, which the president announced in the midst of the worst wildfire season in U.S. history.

The plan calls for expanded logging and restricts the public’s right to appeal federal forest policies.

Both sides agree that wildfires are a serious problem. Decades of fire management guided by the principle of fighting every blaze allowed brush and saplings to pile up until many southern and western forests were tinderboxes waiting to ignite. About six million acres were reduced to cinders this year.

Forest policy has since shifted toward thinning brush ¡ especially near populated areas – and setting controlled fires, known as prescribed burns.

Environmental groups have no blanket objections to thinning. In fact, most recommend it. But they say that Bush’s proposal to greatly expand commercial logging of both underbrush and more lucrative medium and large-diameter trees could actually make the problem worse.

In particular, they oppose changing regulations to severely limit appeals of logging policies.

The Bush proposal was inspired at least in part by Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle, a Democrat from South Dakota, who in July won congressional approval to exempt parts of his state from environmental reviews.

Spokespersons for the Wilderness Society and the Natural Resources Defence Council (NRDC) said they expect the administration to introduce legislation for the initiative as early as next week, when a Department of the Interior appropriations bill comes before Congress.

Both the House of Representatives and Senate are currently in recess.

“Everything is moving very fast now,” said NRDC’s Amy Mall. “We haven’t seen the specific legislative language yet. But if what they’re proposing is waiving environmental laws and taking away the public’s right to appeal, there can be no compromise on that.”

Bush announced the proposal on Aug. 22, during a tour of hard-hit areas in the Pacific Northwest. It was met with immediate outcry from environmental groups, which point out that the timber industry is a major contributor to Bush’s Republican Party and that the plan also involves millions of dollars in federal subsidies.

“While it is true that underbrush should be reduced in some forested areas, the reality is that logging corporations have no interest in saplings and shrubs,” said Chad Hanson, a national director of the Sierra Club.

“Such material is too small and has no commercial value. The timber industry only wants one thing from our national forests: mature trees.”

Hanson said that the Forest Service’s own National Fire Plan, issued in September 2000, warns that the agency’s fire policy should “not rely on commercial logging or new road building to reduce fire risks” because “the removal of large, merchantable trees from forests does not reduce fire risk and may, in fact, increase such risk”.

The Plan also found that “logging and clear-cutting can cause rapid regeneration of shrubs and trees that can create highly flammable fuel conditions within a few years of cutting.”

But Interior Secretary Gale Norton says the Healthy Forests Initiative “will remove obstacles to creating healthy forests and reducing risks of extreme fires”.

Chief among these “obstacles”, according to the administration, have been lawsuits brought by environmental groups to block commercial logging in national forests.

“There’s so many regulations, and so much red tape,” Bush said when he announced his intention to curtail review of logging policies last week. “My attitude is, if it’s good enough for that part of South Dakota, it’s good enough for Oregon.”

But environmentalists point out that a Jul. 9 report by the General Accounting Office, the investigative arm of Congress, found that only about one percent of the Forest Service’s fuel reduction plans for 2001 had been appealed. None had been litigated, they say.

A coalition of several dozen environmental groups is promoting an alternative plan to reduce wildfires, particularly in so-called wildland-urban interface areas where people have built homes on the fringes of national forests..

It seeks 10 billion dollars to fireproof homes and remove hazardous fuels, shifting the focus of brush thinning from backcountry areas to interface areas, and promoting small, controlled fires to reduce fuel build-up. The plan would prohibit all logging in federal forests.

The groups are now organising their members and lobbying Congress to oppose the Bush plan, and appear to have a sympathetic ear with some representatives.

Ron Wyden, the chairman of the Senate subcommittee on forestry, told reporters the Bush plan will run into opposition in Congress if it seeks to overturn environmental laws that let the public challenge federal timber sales.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags