Friday, November 20, 2026
Jim Lobe
- The administration of US President Bill Clinton is once again appealing to Iran to engage in a “direct dialogue,” although most officials and independent analysts believe any movement toward that end will be a gradual process, even in the wake of last week’s stunning election results.
Still, most analysts believe those elections, swept by reformist candidates who are likely to win at least 75 percent of the seats in the Majlis, the Iranian parliament, moved the day of rapprochement between Washington and Teheran much closer.
“Iran’s elections are a positive development for Iranian democracy and, we believe, for the prospect of better U.S.-Iranian relations as well,” according to State Department spokesman James Rubin. He called the election results “an event of historic proportions.”
Likewise, Iranian Foreign Minister Kamal Kharrazi, suggested he, too, was anticipating positive ramifications to the vote.
“We hope with the international reaction to the large turnout in the election, we will see a major change in Iran’s relations with the regional nations and the entire world,” he said. “No doubt any positive action taken by other countries would receive a positive response.”
Officials here were particularly impressed by the first-place showing of President Mohammed Khatemi’s younger brother, Mohammed Reza Khatemi, in Teheran.
At one point during the campaign, he raised the possibility of government-to-government relations with the United States, a notion likely to be considered treasonous by the conservative majority of the outgoing Majlis.
And the ostentatious embrace by winning candidates of former Interior Minister Abdullah Nouri, who was on leave during the elections from a five-year prison sentence, also received favourable notice here.
Nouri, who was jailed for religious dissent and improving ties with Iran’s enemies, published a letter just two months ago condemning the ritual chanting of anti-US slogans as useless and insulting.
“While the elections were not decided on foreign-policy issues – let alone normalisation of ties with us – the fact is that discussion of normalisation has been made legitimate, and that’s a huge difference from just a few months ago,” noted one State Department expert on Iran.
Still, no one here is predicting a rapid courtship. “Relations will remain largely frozen for the time being,” according to Mark Gasiorowski, an Iran specialist who teaches political science at Louisiana State University.
Conservative forces still hold sway in key areas of government which are more relevant to foreign policy-making, including the armed forces, the National Security Council, the Guardian Council, and the office of Iran’s supreme leader, Sayed Ali Khamenei, who, as the successor of Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, is even more powerful than President Khatemi.
“The Majlis really doesn’t have any say in foreign policy anyway,” according to Gasiorowski, who predicts that the reformists, to the extent they remain a coherent coalition, will be far more inclined to spend the political capital they gained in the elections on domestic change.
In addition, the Clinton administration will be reluctant to make bold moves in Teheran’s direction during this year’s election campaign for fear of angering some powerful constituencies.
In particular, it will likely be concerned with the so-called “Israel Lobby” which itself has spent much political capital in recent years in depicting Iran as a permanent threat to Israel’s existence.
As a result, many analysts predict little or no progress on this end until after the next administration takes power.
Indeed, despite the hopeful words emanating from Washington since last week’s election, the Senate Thursday unanimously approved a bill that would impose sanctions on any country which aids Iran’s ability to produce missiles or weapons of mass destruction.
Washington broke off ties with Iran in 1979 after its embassy in Teheran was seized and 52 members of its staff there held hostage for more than one year. The administration of President Ronald Reagan also provided aid to Iraq during that country’s bloody eight-year war with Iran in the 1980s.
For most of the 1990s, Washington’s attitude toward Teheran actually hardened. When Clinton took power in 1993, he announced a policy of “dual containment” against both Iran and Iraq; in 1995, he banned all trade and loans for Iran; and the following year signed a law imposing sanctions on foreign oil companies investing there.
Congress even authorised 20 million dollars for covert operations designed to undermine the Islamic government.
Despite frantic efforts by US oil companies to reverse policy, Iran was depicted as the prototypical “rogue state,” the world’s biggest sponsor of international terrorism bent on acquiring weapons of mass destruction.
But that image began to change after Khatemi’s landslide election in May 1997. Khatemi’s extraordinary effort to reach out to the US public in a New Year’s message broadcast by Cable News Network in January 1998 was reciprocated by Clinton himself shortly afterward.
Those exchanges launched a delicate diplomatic dance which so far has mainly consisted of sports, cultural and scholarly exchanges.
At the same time, the administration has taken some more concrete steps to reduce sanctions against Iran. Under his executive authority, Clinton exempted European companies from the oil sanctions, lifted the ban on sales of medicine and food to Iran, and last December allowed the Boeing Company to supply safety-related parts to Iran’s aging commercial aircraft fleet.
But the administration has been disappointed by what it sees as the lack of any response, particularly Teheran’s rejection of a US proposal for reciprocal consular visits and for co-operation in investigating the 1996 bombing of a US military facility in Saudi Arabia.
At the same time, it has been careful not to blame Khatemi, whose rhetoric has remained conciliatory. Instead, officials here argue that conservative forces remain in control of foreign policy, and as the struggle between contending forces in Iran intensified during the past year, it became much harder for the reformists to take major new initiatives abroad.
Still, over the same time, Teheran has effectively normalised relations with much of Western Europe. Khatemi himself travelled to Rome and Paris last year, becoming the first Iranian president to visit Europe since the 1979 Revolution.
These breakthroughs have added to the impatience of major US corporations to return to what under the Shah was one of their most lucrative markets.
Other analysts are also eager for restored ties for geo-political reasons. Iran has made significant progress in foiling US efforts to keep it isolated from the former Soviet states of Central Asia and China, says Julia Nanay of the Petroleum Finance Corporation.
“Repairing ties with Tehran would also make it easier for Washington to contain Iraq, whose biological and chemical weapons programs make it a greater threat,” according an editorial in Friday’s New York Times.
But the administration still insists that no major progress can be made until Teheran satisfies Washington on three long-standing concerns: its alleged efforts to acquire weapons of mass destruction; its backing of violent groups like Hezbollah in Lebanon and Hamas in the Palestinian territories, opposed to the Middle East peace process; and its support for international terrorism.
When Washington refers to a “direct dialogue,” those are the issues it wants to discuss.
US demands in these areas – particularly the first two – are probably non-starters, according to Gasiorowski and other Iran experts here.
“Iran lives in a dangerous neighbourhood, and all Iranians feel the need for a strong defence,” he says. In that context, “nuclear weapons make a lot of sense.”
Similarly, Hezbollah and Hamas “seem to most Iranians as a legitimate opposition to Israeli rule.” On these concerns, conservatives and reformers are not very far apart, if at all.
Still, there are things Washington can and should do in the absence of progress in these areas, according to analysts here.
For one, says Richard Haass, the head of foreign policy studies at the influential Brookings Institution, the U.S. should drop all reference to its “dual containment” policy which appears to equate Iran and Iraq. “This would be an important signal,” he says.
Haass, a senior Mideast expert in the George Bush administration, is also urging Washington to stop using its influence to prevent lending by international financial institutions, like the World Bank, to Iran.
While the US representative on the boards of these agencies is required by law to vote against loans to countries on Washington’s “terrorist” list, it can still permit them to go forward.
On Wednesday, Rubin appeared to nix this idea, saying: “The United States does not believe that conditions favour restarting World Bank lending to Iran at this time. Iran has yet to make progress in a number of fronts that should precede such action, including pursuing meaningful economic reform and abandoning support for terrorism.”