Asia-Pacific, Headlines

PAKISTAN: Christian Killings May Widen Sectarian Violence

Nadeem Iqbal

ISLAMABAD, Oct 31 2001 (IPS) - Shock continues to ripple through local communities after the killing of 17 Christians during Sunday prayers, amid worries that the first such attack on Christians in Pakistan could signal a widening of sectarian-based violence in the country.

After the U.S.-led air strikes in Afghanistan, opposition to Pakistan’s support for the ‘war against terrorism’ and reports of hate crimes in United States and Europe against Muslims, security agencies in Pakistan have been fearing some retaliation from the religious lobby.

That was why policemen were put on guard at the churches, including the one attacked in Bahawalpur city in southern Punjab province on Oct. 28. But the government had not anticipated the actual magnitude of the threat.

The attack was all the more disturbing for many because officials said that it was the first incident in Pakistan in which Christians were targeted in the central Punjab area — which otherwise has been ridden with Muslim sectarian terrorism.

The chairman of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, Afrasiab Khattak, said that the shooting could only worsen the already bleak conditions under which members of minority communities lived in this South Asian nation.

“If reports that the intelligence agencies had warned the government of such an attack is true, then it indicates the lack of priority attached by authorities to issues affecting the life and welfare of minority groups,” he lamented.

According to eyewitnesses, four men opened indiscriminate firing at around 9 a.m. when worshippers were about to complete their prayers in Saint Dominic Church.

The dead included 12 members of a family, and nine people were injured. The assailants entered the church after killing a policeman guarding the church and fled on motorcycles.

Expressing deep shock and sorrow, President Gen Pervez Musharraf said that the method used and the inhuman tactics employed clearly indicate the involvement of trained terrorist organisations bent upon creating discord and disharmony in Pakistan “where Christians and Muslims have always lived in peace with mutual respect for each other”.

Commenting on the carnage this week, the conservative English daily ‘The Nation’ said: “The shock of this event comes from the novelty of its victims being Christians rather than the violation of the sanctity of a place of worship. Too frequently have Namazis been killed while at prayer, on both sides of the sectarian divide for this to have much shock value.”

“Therefore,” the editorial added, “the frightening dimension is that the methods of sectarian extremism have been extended to another religion.”

“This lends some credence to the initial suspicion that certain groups banned for terrorist activities, one of them avowedly sectarian, have taken some sort of revenge on the United States. That these groups were supposed to have threatened the Bahawalpur Christian community is added evidence,” the newspaper said.

Christians are the largest group in the around 3 percent non- Muslim portion of country’s 15 million population. Most of the Christian population is concentrated in the central and Southern Punjab.

The area is also a battlefield of Muslim sectarian violence spread over last two decades, in which thousands had been killed. During four years (1997-2000), around 400 people were killed.

The government believes that many of the sectarian terrorists got training in Afghanistan and took refuge there after their conducted actions in the country.

On many occasions, the Pakistan government has approached the Taliban to extradite around two dozen hardened terrorists wanted for criminal activities in Pakistan. But Afghanistan has responded none of these requests.

In August this year, the government clamped a ban on two extremist sectarian outfits of the country.

The recent carnage of the Christians was done on the pattern of intra -Muslim sectarian terrorism, where hardened outfits of Sunni and Shiite sects usually target each other’s religious places during prayers.

Similar patterns of violence have been observed against followers of the Ahmadi sect, who were declared non-Muslim by the government in mid- 70s through a constitutional amendment. In one such incident on Oct. 30 last year, in Sialkot city, unknown assailants opened fire in a religious place of Ahmadis, killing five.

Ahmadi religious places have been attacked on different occasions by mobs led by local religious leaders. In similar incidents, the worship places of Hindus have also been vandalised.

But Christian churches have never been targeted in the same way – until now.

Mostly, it was individual Christians who have been persecuted by local religious leaders, invoking blasphemy laws for allegedly passing on derogatory remarks against Islamic scriptures.

In the first three months of this year, 15 cases of blasphemy have been registered with police. More than half of them are against Christians.

The other Christian-related issue is the demand that the present system of separate electorates — under which non-Muslims are to elect their separate representative to the assemblies – be disbanded.

Meanwhile, leaders of the Christian community have appealed for peace. Dr Alexander John Malik, bishop of Lahore city, said: “The people were killed by the terrorists who have no morals or principles as no religion allows such acts especially against a peace-loving and worshipping community.”

He urged the government to arrest the culprits at the earliest and provide security and protection to the Christian community. At the same time, he asked Christians to remain calm and show patience and “let not the extremists and enemies of Pakistan fulfil their nefarious designs”.

Criticising the killings, Christian Liberation Front Pakistan president Shahbaz Bhatti demanded that the government ban and disarm all militant organisations responsible for spreading “religious terrorism” in the country.

A rare condemnation of the gory incident came from the heads of Pakistan’s religious parties. The chief of the Jamaat-i-Islami Qazi party Husain Ahmad said no Muslim could resort to such an action, adding that those who indulged in violence were playing “the game of the enemy”.

The chief of Jamiat-Ulmai-Islam party, Maulana Samiul Haq, said no religious group could be involved in such activities and the government must arrest the culprits at the earliest. He runs many religious seminaries in the North West Frontier Province, from where most of the Taliban have graduated.

Tehrik-I-Jafria Pakistan chief Allama Syed Sajid Ali Naqvi said that Musharraf, while focusing a lot of his attention on the ‘war against terrorism’ and cooperation with the United States and Britain, should not neglect the situation inside Pakistan.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags