Friday, November 20, 2026
Sarah O'Hara
- The British government was angered and embarrassed Wednesday when the European Court found it had violated European human rights conventions in the 1988 killing of three unarmed Irish Republican Army (IRA) members in Gibraltar.
The European Court of Human Rights ruling — which narrowly passed on a 10-9 vote — said the three were ‘unlawfully killed’ and ordered the British government to pay the victims’ families’ legal costs of 38,700 pounds (60,000 U.S. dollars).
But a request for damages was rejected on the grounds that the IRA trio, Mairead Farrell, Daniel McCann and Sean Savage, were in fact planning a bomb attack on the British colony.
The three, all from west Belfast, died in a hail of bullets fired by troops from Britain’s elite Special Air Service (SAS) special forces regiment. All three IRA members were unarmed.
Spanish police over the border at Marbella, 100 kilometres from Gibraltar, later found a car hired under a false identity by Mairead Farrell containing timing devices, 64 kilos of high explosive and 200 gun cartridges. The British government said the three planned to kill dozens of Gibraltans with the explosives.
But the court said Wednesday that the British government had not exercised care in evaluating their intelligence information before passing it on to the SAS, “whose use of firearms automatically involved shooting to kill”.
Niall Farrell, brother of Mairead and one of the relatives who brought the case, called the Strasbourg court’s ruling “a tremendous victory” that would give hope to all those who had lost relatives in killings by the British security forces.
There have been over 357 killings by the British Army and the armed local police force, the Royal Ulster Constabulary, since 1968, according to the independent civil liberties group, the Committee for the Administration of Justice (CAJ).
“Now the people throughout the world know what (the British government) has really been doing for the last 25 years,” he said on Irish state radio Wednesday.
“This is a judgment which defies common sense,” countered a British government spokesman, who said a thorough investigation of the incident was conducted by British courts seven years ago.
“There was an interim ruling by the European court’s own commission which found the British action to have been lawful,” he added, “so it is incomprehensible that the court can have come to a different view”.
Farrell claimed in reply: “My sister and Daniel McCann were standing with their hands up (when the SAS fired). That is what defies common sense.”
Gerry Adams, leader of Sinn Fein, political representatives of the IRA, said the ruling lent credence to the view held by Irish nationalists that the British justice system was flawed and biased in Northern Ireland.
“This decision also raises again the whole question of bias and corruption within the judicial and legal system in the Six Counties (Northern Ireland),” he said. “This system has been tailored to suit the political needs of the British and is incapable of dispensing justice.”
The six mainly Protestant populated counties of Northern Ireland remained under British rule when the rest of the island won independence from London after World War I. The hostility of the pro-British Protestant majority in Northern Ireland to the pro- Irish republic Catholic minority there triggered civil conflict and the introduction of British troops to Northern Ireland in 1968.
The conflict gave rise to the guerrillas of the IRA, formally known as the Provisional IRA, who fought 25 years to reunite the six counties of the north with the Republic to the south before they declared a ceasefire last year.
While the IRA has accepted that the three were ‘killed in action’ the fact that the three IRA members killed in Gibraltar were unarmed has led its supporters to claim that the shootings were no more than an ‘extra-judicial assassination’ by the SAS — a case reinforced by Wednesday’s court verdict.
The families’ lawyer, Barra McGrory, said that the judgment vindicated their case. Although the Court found that the IRA members had procured explosive devices and planned an attack against a military parade, it condemned the British government’s decision to allow the IRA trio onto the island in the first place.
The families said that three were allowed on to the British territory of Gibraltar specifically so they could be assassinated with greater ease by the SAS.
The CAJ, a civil liberties group widely respected by both Protestant and Catholic communities in Northern Ireland, said it would like to see a change in British law so soldiers and police to be prosecuted in cases of killing regarded as ‘manslaughter’ — where there are alleged extenuating circumstances.
At the moment, prosecutions can only be made when the death is defined as murder. “The CAJ welcomes the ruling,” Mary O’Rawe, a lawyer and member of the CAJ executive, told IPS on Wednesday.
“Obviously, it has to be studied in depth but it indicates the pressing need for a fundamental overhaul of law and practice in the area of protecting the right to life.”
Article Two of the European Convention — to which Britain is a signatory — is concerned with the protection of the right to life. The Court determined that Britain violated this provision.
O’Rawe believes that public censure arising from the ruling will force the British government to re-evaluate its human rights record, a move vital to the peace process.
“The British government says that the judgment ‘defies common sense’ but we would say that it doesn’t defy common sense, that a government calling on others to respect human rights must respect human rights itself.”
“(The British government) has lost any moral high ground that it has claimed and until the government acknowledges that it too has played a part in the breach of human rights then it cannot expect people to have faith and confidence in its ability to move the peace process forward,” she concluded.
Farrell added: “The only people who are going to be really shattered by this judgement are the British Government because they’ve got blood on their hands. We’ve known for some time that they’ve got blood on their hands. Now people all over the world know it.”