Europe, Headlines

NORTHERN IRELAND: Peace Without Progress

Sarah O'Hara

DUBLIN, Oct 16 1995 (IPS) - A year after pro-British loyalist paramilitaries called a ceasefire in their 25-year fight to keep Northern Ireland British, ordinary Catholics no longer fear assassination when they walk the streets of Belfast.

“For me the ceasefire came too late,” says Emily McCabe, whose 23-year-old son, Patrick, was killed by Protestant paramilitaries just before the ceasefire. “But still I’m glad that there is a ceasefire — that there’s nobody else getting shot.”

McCabe lives in what’s known as “the murder triangle” in Belfast, a small Catholic suburb called New Lodge in the north of the city where more than 600 people were killed over the last 25 years.

Asked if the peace will hold, McCabe says: “I hope so. But whether it will or not is another thing.”

While there has been a kind of “peace” for more than 12 months — following the ceasefires of the Irish Republican Army (IRA), which began on Sep. 1 last year and that of the loyalists which began on Oct. 14 — there has been little political progress.

The British Government has yet to announce a date for all-party talks, despite promises that talks would begin within months of a ceasefire — after what prime minister John Major called “a decontamination period”.

“You can’t have all-party talks without all parties,” Michael Ancram, the British minister responsible for political development in Northern Ireland, said last week.

The Ulster Unionist Party (UUP), the main party representing the Protestant majority, say they will not engage in talks involving the IRA’s political ally, Sinn Fein, unless there is a surrender of weapons.

The British insist that the IRA make “a gesture” on weapons, but it is not clear that the unionist parties would agree to talks, even if such a gesture was made. Some Ulster Unionists want more than just weapons — they have called for the breaking up of the command structures of the IRA itself — and the hardline Democratic Unionist Party say they will not talk to Sinn Fein under any circumstances.

For their part, the IRA say that to hand over weapons would be symbolic of defeat, and they were not defeated. They called a ceasefire after three years of secret talks with the British Government.

Many Catholics are sceptical of unionist interest in healing the centuries-old tensions between the two communities. “They won’t even sit down and talk,” says another Catholic resident of New Lodge, James O’Halloran, who still has the defences up around his house. “You won’t get them ones to sit down and talk.”

Thus the peace process is deadlocked. At the moment, the peace is dependent on the will of paramilitaries in both communities, and the determination of the ordinary people that there will be no more violence.

“Only American intervention will push it (the peace process) forward,” Tim Pat Coogan, author of a book on the IRA and of a recent history of the last 25 years, The Troubles, said on Friday.

Coogan regrets that John Major did not get the Nobel Prize for Peace on Friday.

“It might have given him both the courage and the status to be able to say, ‘This peace process needs the breaking out of the ring fence of the King Canutes and the European dimension (a reference to rebels within Major’s Conservative Party who are opposed to some aspects of European integration) and their link with the unionists who have played the Orange card on decommissioning.’

“He might have gone for it … he is more and more dependent on the unionists. And without the intervention of a third force — i.e. somebody of the calibre and status of Anthony Lake (the U.S. national security adviser) — coming in with the imprint of the President (Bill Clinton) behind him, I would be very pessimistic about the present juncture.”

One of the few positive political signs over the last year has been the emergence of fresh thinking among “the hard men” — the political representatives of the loyalist paramilitaries.

Both the Ulster Democratic Party, which was formed by the paramilitary Ulster Defence Association, and the Progressive Unionist Party, which has links with the Ulster Volunteer Force, have consistently taken a more conciliatory line than the mainstream unionist parties.

For which they have received little thanks from their own people. “In many ways, they have sold out the unionist community,” said Belfast city councillor Sammy Wilson of the DUP in typically hardline language. “Their love affair with Dublin is a case in point. Their propaganda efforts on behalf of the Northern Ireland Office is another case in point.”

When the loyalist paramilitaries announced the ceasefire a year ago Friday, they said: “The union (with Britain) is safe.”

It is this confidence in the British link enduring which underlies their openness to political change — and their determination that working-class people like themselves will not risk their lives for the rhetoric of mainstream unionism.

The loyalist parties have as yet no electoral mandate, their only significance being their links to the paramilitaries who were killing Catholics up to a year ago. Now paradoxically, they are the ones using more conciliatory language than “the men of peace” on their own sides.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Europe, Headlines

NORTHERN IRELAND: Peace Without Progress

Sarah O'Hara

DUBLIN, Oct 16 1995 (IPS) - A year after pro-British loyalist paramilitaries called a ceasefire in their 25-year fight to keep Northern Ireland British, ordinary Catholics no longer fear assassination when they walk the streets of Belfast.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags