Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

BRAZIL-POLITICS: Government Closes Debate on Social Security

Mario Osava

RIO DE JANEIRO, Jan 31 1996 (IPS) - The Brazilian government, cutting short a public debate over its social policies, is pressing for an early parliamentary vote on proposals to reform social security legislation.

An initial accord reached by the government and the trade union federations two weeks ago had stimulated a thorough-going national dialogue over the problems of inequality, jobless development, the economy, and relations between unions and the state. There was even headynb talk of a social pact.

But when the United Workers Confederation (CUT) President Vicente Paulo da Silva struck a deal with the government on retirement benefits, debate turned internal bickering within the union movement.

The government sought a quick legislative vote to take advantage of the union dissaray and dissension among the left. It also wanted to conclude the matter before municipal elections due in October, which would complicate the legislature’s approval of unpopular measures.

By cutting the debate short, the government committed an act of “social irresponsibility,” impeding the democratic process that might have produced a better reform and benefitted workers and the future of the country, charged Senator Roberto Freire of the Popular Socialist Party (PPS, the former Communist Party).

The senator was one of the few legislators to defend the dialogue between the government and the unions, which he said “conferred quality on the process.” The legislators generally condemned the agrement, declaring that the legislature had authority over the matter.

Radical factions in CUT and the affiliated Workers’ Party (PT) criticized the CUT leader, Vicente Paulo da Silva, for agreeing to the pact. The critics oppose changing the method of measuring retirement benefits from a worker’s “service years” to her “contribution years,” declaring that this excludes workers in the informal economy and peasants, neither of whom are integrated into the social security system.

The CUT president responded that these workers are already excluded under the present system because they are unable to formally document their work records as “service years.”

The measurements differ in that the “service years” rubric permits workers to retire before completing the required years of contributing to the social security system if they can prove with witnesses and documents that they have worked for the required period, 35 years for men and 30 years for women.

The government backed down from an earlier proposal to impose a minimum retirement age of about 60 years for men and 55 for women. But it insisted that “contribution” replace “service” when counting the years of work that men and women must document to obtain retirement benefits.

The government and unions also agreed to end the many “special retirements” that reduce the required work period to 25 years or less for certain occupations. They retained them only for primary and secondary school teachers, who may retire after 30 years of teaching (for men) and 25 years (for women).

But the agreement’s critics said that this concession was simply a compensation for low teachers’ salaries and was the wrong way to affirm the national consensus making education a priority. They said it would encourage teachers to continue to retire in their forties, their most productive years.

The accord eliminates early retirements for legislators (who can now retire after eight years of service), journalists, university professors, judges, prosecutors, and aeronauts.

Social Security Minister Reinhold Stephanes complained that the concessions made to secure legislative approval of the constitutional amendment had reduced the reform project to a short term palliative. He warned that the country would be forced to return to the issue “within four or five years.”

The government is seeking to control the social security system’s growing deficit. There are now some 16 million pensioners and retirees in Brazil – and their number is growing rapidly – compared to slightly more than 30 million contributors to the system.

Minister Stephanes said that the ideal ratio is four contributors for each retiree compared to today’s ratio of two to one.

Economists and business people see the reform as an opportunity to raise the rates of saving and investment using private pension funds. They often cite Chile as a model.

But for the average Brazilian, the prospect of security the means of subsistence to live out old age in dignity appears increasingly remote. Brazil’s social security crisis is different from that of other countries.

University of Campinas professor and PT leader Marco Aurelio Garcia noted that the welfare state typical of European countries has never existed in Brazil. And this dream, only realized in a few countries, in now disappearing everywhere before the developing countries have had the chance to enjoy it.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags