Sunday, November 22, 2026
Thalif Deen
- The United States and Russia will precipitate an arms race in Southeast Asia by introducing two of the most sophisticated missiles into the region’s arsenals, arms researchers say.
The high-tech weaponry being negotiated are the U.S.-made AIM- 120 Advanced Medium Range Air-to-Air Missile (AMRAAM) and the Russian-designed AA-12 Adder air-to-air missile. The countries interested in buying the missiles are Thailand and Malaysia, two nations already equipped with Russian, Chinese, and U.S. weapons systems.
Analysts say the United States and Russia have been virtually telling each other, “You go first, and we will follow later.”
“I have been told the U.S. will not sell them first but will wait for a Russian sale of AA-12 missiles to Malaysia before the AMRAAM is released to Thailand,” Tom Cardamone, Jr., editor of the Washington-based Arms Trade News, told IPS. “The key question is: What is the military necessity for these weapons for Malaysia or Thailand? Frankly, there is none.”
Cardamone says that instead of being reactive and telling the Russians, “if you sell, we will too,” Washington should approach the Russians and say, “we won’t rachet up the technology in the region, so you should hold off as well.”
The U.S. Department of Defence last month proposed a 578- million-dollar arms package to Thailand, which included eight F/A- 18 jet fighters and up to 50 AMRAAMs. The delivery of the supersonic, beyond-visual-range weapon is to be held up until Russia can introduce its own AA-12 Adder air-to-air-missile into the region.
The Washington-based weekly, Defense News, says that U.S. government arms control experts insist that Thailand faces no threat that requires countering with an advanced air-to-air missile. Instead, the majority view the AMRAAM request by Thailand as an effort by a new Thai president to bolster his country’s status vis-a-vis its regional neighbours, Defense News says.
The proposed sale has also sharply divided the U.S. State and Defence Departments.
“In the ASEAN region, there is no compelling rationale for that type of major upgrade” in missile capability, Hugh Hamilton, the State Department’s director of arms transfer and export control policy, said last September. (The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) comprises Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore, Indonesia, Brunei, the Philippines, and Vietnam.)
Hamilton has conceded, however, that the willingness of Russia and France to market their own sophisticated missiles in the region has increased the pressure on the U.S. government.
Rear Admiral John Synder, acting director of the U.S. navy’s international programmes office, has been quoted as saying that the senior leadership of the Pentagon strongly backs the sale.
“Everyone has signed off except the State Department,” Snyder said.
The proposed sale has been complicated further because Thailand has reportedly said it will buy the F/A-18 fighter planes only if they get the AMRAAMs.
“No AMRAAMs, no fighter planes,” the Thais have reportedly told the Pentagon.
Defense News says that U.S. officials are searching for a way to salvage the sale of U.S. fighters without bowing to Bangkok’s demand for the missiles.
Thailand has already threatened the United States by exploring the possibility of buying France’s Mirage 2000-5 fighters equipped with Mica air-to-air missiles and the Russian Su-27 and MiG-29 fighters, both of which carry the AA-12 missile.
Cardamone says the sale of the missiles would certainly start an arms race in the region.
“When other nations in the region see the type of technology, they have to assume it will be used. They then have to assess their options to counter that technology,” he said. “One way is to acquire better radars, defensive missile systems or aircraft that can avoid these mid-range missiles. The other is to trump that technology with something else.”
Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad said last month that “the hard selling of more sophisticated arms to one country would only lead to others wanting to be similarly equipped.” Thus, he said, “they are then blamed for indulging in an arms race while the activities of the arms-dealing nations are regarded as blameless.”