Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

VENEZUELA-HUMAN RIGHTS: Wheels of Justice Turn Slowly

Humberto Marquez

CARACAS, Feb 21 1996 (IPS) - The pursuit of justice in the case of 14 Venezuelan fishing massacred by police and soldiers in 1998 has come a step closer with the Inter American Court of Justice now considering damages to be paid to families and those who survived the incident.

The court, sitting in in San Jose , Costa Rica, is sifting through the presentations of the government and claimants made last month. Those who suffered by the action are seeking amends for the moral, legal, institutional and economic damage suffered, while the government of President Rafael Caldera said the demands were disproportionate and that they should be satisfied the state had admitted the “error.”

“The fundamental role of the Inter American court is to evaluate the conduct of the States in relation to the observance of the rights granted in the American Convention” on the issue, the foreign ministry declared.

By recognising the facts of what happened in El Amparo, Venezuela had “ratified the inter American convention on human rights” and honoured its international commitments, a Ministry communique said.

It was on Oct. 29, 1988 in El Amparo, a small town on the torrid plains of south east Venezuela separated from Colombia by the Arauca River, that 16 fishing workers were ambushed by a group of troops and police officers. Only two of the fishermen survived – Wolmer Pinilla and Jose Arias who went into hiding in Mexico while Venezuala remained on the list of countries with serious violations against the right to life.

The massacre moved the nation and the case began its journey between civil and military courts, winning contradictory sentences, until it finally reached the Inter American Court.

Venezuela “decided not to contest the facts at El Amparo,” said Asdrubal Aguiar, government lawyer and governor of Caracas, “but it has not accepted the entire compensation claimed by the plaintiffs.”

“The indemnification must consider the economic parameters of Venezuela and El Amparo,” he said, and the pleas for sanctions against those guilty of the massacre may be answered as “the case is being heard in the penal section of the Supreme Court.”

Ligia Bolivar, director of the human rights organisation Provea and defender of the fishing workers killed, told IPS that “accepting the haggling of Venezuela would imply that there were first and second class citizens in the American community.”

The Inter American Human Rights Commission, who took up the case, called on the San Jose court for moral, institutional and legal reparation, with compensation for the survivors and the families of the victims.

They are calling for cash payments of some 2.32 million dollars — two million dollars for the moral damage inflicted and 125,000 dollars for each family group, which Aguiar considered disproportionate.

The families also sought 240,000 dollars to share between the 16 group members for damages as a result of the event, something the State considers unjustified.

They want to charge nearly 5,600 dollars in earnings lost by the families of the deceased, and 2,800 for the survivors. Bolivar told the court the government lawyers felt this was too much, considering the region where El Amparo is found and the normal income of the fishing workers.

“The fact that the victims and survivors are simple peasants and fishing people cannot mean their lives and the suffering of their families are worth less than that of a professional, as the Venezuelan claims make out,” she said.

The nation also objects to the compensation for moral damage as they believe official recognition of the facts should be enough, though “the families stress the memory of the dead has not yet been revindicated,” she said.

The military and police leaders in charge of the group who ambushed and killed the fishing workers had constantly claimed the victims were camouflaged Colombian guerrillas, and many army officers still believe this version.

“The family members feel they are still affected by this story which accuses their relatives of being guerrillas, this is one of the elements which hurts most, and the government does not seem to understand this legitimate need for moral reparation,” insisted Bolivar.

According to the survivors, the fishing workers were taken by surprise one Saturday when they were preparing a celebratory “sancocho” (fish soup), on the banks of the river Arauca, but the corpses were displayed wearing guerrilla armbands and carrying weapons.

The Commission also called for the Code of Military Justice to be reformed, especially the part which allows the President of the Republic to open or close any military process at his discretion.

Bolivar said “we are dealing with norms contrary to the independence of the powers, which correspond to the undemocratic atmosphere which existed in the country in 1938, when this legal code was established.”

Aguiar, former member of the Inter American Commission on Human Rights, said “on the contrary, this norm guarantees the subjection of military to civil power.”

Lastly, those affected fear that impunity is being consecrated in Venezuela, after the endless judicial process produced a sentence by an ad-hoc court martial which is still waiting from ratification or rejection by the Supreme Court.

This court martial decided that the event in El Amparo was not a massacre but a confrontation, that the survivors were never at the place, but that the official fighters had “been excessive in their defence.”

The “excessive” personnel were sentenced to seven and a half years in prison each, though the terms were cut by half considering they had acted “in the line of duty and serving orders from a legitimate authority.”

The Inter American Court of Justice which established the Venezuelan State responsibility in “the facts,” without making this explicit, must pass a definitive verdict in the second half of 1996.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags