Active Citizens, Civil Society, Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines

UKRAINE: Last Chernobyl ‘Incident’ Was More Serious Than Admitted

Andrei Ivanov

MOSCOW, Mar 13 1996 (IPS) - A November 1995 accident at the Chernobyl nuclear plant earlier described as ‘insignificant’ has proven to be more serious than first claimed — raising new fears about safety at the plant, still running a decade on from the 1986 disaster.

Ukraine’s Ministry of Environment and Nuclear Safety has reassessed reports of an accident at Chernobyl’s Reactor 1 last November when fuel-handling equipment failed and marked it up as a serious incident.

The incident is now being rated at Level 3 on the seven-point International Nuclear Events Scale (INES) which is classified as a ‘serious incident’ or ‘near accident’ with severe spread of contamination on site and acute health effects to a worker.

The devastating accident at Reactor 4 at Chernobyl in 1986 was rated at Level 7. Several rooms were contaminated in the latest incident and at least one worker received a radiation dose above the statutory limit.

The contamination was caused by a damaged fuel assembly when it was being removed from the reactor by the refuelling machine. The Chernobyl-type RBMK reactors are the only design which are refuelled while still ‘on line’.

The refuelling is done by a remote controlled gantry and crane which grabs the fuel assembly and lifts it out of the reactor core and then transfers it to a spent fuel storage pool a few metres away inside the reactor hall.

The assemblies are maintained under water both in the core and the pool which absorbs the heat. The transfer from core to pool has to be done quickly to minimise the time the assembly is in the air — it is still very hot as it is removed and could melt down.

Provided the assembly is undamaged, heat is the main problem, though if the casing is damaged and leaking, radiation also becomes a hazard. In the case of November’s incident the contamination was probably caused by radioactive water dripping on to the reactor hall floor during transfer.

“It is a bizarre refuelling process at the best of times,” says a Western expert who has witnessed the procedure. “And at Chernobyl contamination control is virtually non-existent. You just walk out of the hall and into the tea room, wiping your feet on a wet towel.

“I can easily understand how contamination would be spread to other rooms.”

Overall, the safety of Chernobyl continues to cause concern, despite a good safety record compared with other Ukrainian stations.

There have recently been rumours of dangerous developments at Reactor 3, although chief engineer Vitaly Tolstogonov denies there is any problem. He says radioactivity around the unit is well below the maximum permissible levels.

But Reactor 3, which is linked to the crippled Reactor 4 by a small structure known as Building V, has been the focus of increasing concern. The giant concrete sarcophagus built around the ruined Reactor 4 after the 1984 explosion is crumbling and there ar fears that fragments may fall on and damage Building V.

This in turn could break the protection around Reactor 4 if it were operating at the time, threatening a serious accident. A European Union sponsored ‘risk analysis’ is however expected to conclude that this danger can be averted by minimal measures to reinforce Reactor 3.

But all this will cost money. And western governments, answering environmental lobbyists by demanding the plant’s closure, are bing slow in providning promised funds. This is further feeding the debate over Chernobyl’s closure is continuing with the Ukrainian lobby for its continued operation becoming increasingly vociferous.

Ukrainian officials insist that a memorandum signed with the Group of Seven (G-7) world’s richest states at the end of last year on the closure of Chernobyl is not binding. They say it is just a statement of agreement in principle which depends above all on Western finance being made available.

A group of 58 parliamentary deputies have sent an open letter to president Leonid Kuchma stating that there are no good economic grounds for closing Chernobyl and insisting that it should continue operating until 2007 when the fuel channels will need replacing.

Electricity sales from Chernobyl up to then will total an estimated 5.2 billion dollars, they point out.

The deputies also called for dismissal of environment minister Yuri Kostenko as head of the delegation to the G-7 Chernobyl talks. They believe he should take a harder line.

With one eye on his critics, Kostenko now says procedures for obtaining credits from the West need to be simplified if Ukraine is to meet its deadline for shutting down the Chernobyl plant by 2000.

He notes that, according to current procedures, it will be 18 months before Kiev receives any funds for completing construction of new nuclear reactors at the Rovno and Khmelnitsky atomic energy stations, which are to replace the two reactors still operating at Chernobyl.

He warned it would take another 30-35 months to finish construction, after which the lengthy process of testing would have to begin. The minister said he would lobby at the next G-7 meeting on this issue in April in Moscow to speed up the allocation of the 2.3 billion dollars in grants and loans promised by the G-7 to pay for the shutdown.

At present the Chernobyl plant is feeding all of its electricity to the national grid to minimise possible power shortages during the winter period.

However this is only a temporary measure, say Chernobyl officials who expect the plant to soon be selling a proportion of its power direct to consumers again as it did last year, enabling it to use the revenue to directly support the people of the town of Slavutich, where the plant’s operators live.

The Ukrainian government has also adopted a resolution increasing the pay of those working at Chernobyl and in so-called ‘restricted access areas’.

This specifies that until 2000 the workers are to receive wages at double the basic wage rate. However, wages have always been well above average at the plant — a necessary inducement to attract workers to the notorious site.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags