Saturday, November 21, 2026
Mario Osava
- Local people in Porto Alegre, southern Brazil are calling for increased municipal taxes – shocking local councillors accustomed to years of pressure in the opposite direction.
The 180 degree turn-around in public opinion has been one of the most surprising consequences of the Participatory Budget planning system, under which local people have direct say in organising council spending.
This process was initiated in Porto Alegre, a city of 2.1 million people, seven years ago by then mayor, Olivio Dutra, of the left-wing Workers Party (PT).
The system is now more polished, and the people themselves meet in 16 council sub-regional assemblies to decide where the available resources will be spent, where to invest, what areas to prioritise, which projects to carry out, and how to structure the heirarchy.
Sociologist Luciano Fedosi, who made the issue the subject of his master’s degree, said the participatory system gave the locals greater insight into the management of the city.
The people became rudely awar of the problem of income for the first time when the first budget ran out of money ahead of schedule.
In reality there is little room for manoevre within the budget as some 98 percent of the income is already destined to pay staff salaries and unavoidable expenses, leaving practically nothing for investments.
As a result, pressure is now being put on the councillors to increase local taxes in order to improve services. This should not be difficult as the charge was very low in Porto Alegre compared with other local areas.
Fedosi said the Participatory Budget system also promoted “modern citizenship” in the city, breaking with the “patrimonialism” which dominates all levels of Brazilian society.
He explained the “Patrimonialist State” is characterised by the patronisation of the population, where the private and public spheres become blurred, the patronage system dominates all dealings and a there is a large discrepancy between the law and the actual practices.
The enthusiatistic public participation witnessed in Porto Alegre showed that social control over the State was possible, he added, preventing this from serving private interests, showing that reducing the State infrastructure was not the answer, as the international funding agencies like to claim.
Furthermore, the new system provoked a “total inversion of priorities,” with investments moving from supporting the privileged classes who previously had most of the bargaining strength, to meet the needs of the poorest sections, “who have always been excluded” in the peripheral and marginalised neighbourhoods.
The learning experience of this was mutual. The Worker’s Party won the local elections in 1988 on a platform defending public transport, and public debate on the budget imposed sanitation as the main priority for many years.
More recently the stress has moved onto homes and housing, a serious problem in a city where one third of the population live in “favelas” (slum areas) in precarious housing, without legal ownership of the land they have built on.
The PT won again in 1992, with Tarso Genro as mayor, and the party is likely to reelected in the up coming October elections, with present vice-mayor Raul Pont as the new office holder.
The pariticipatory budget was undoubtedly instrumental in achieving this level of continuity.
The assemblies provide direct representation for 20,000 people, with delgates coming from 600 entities, including neighbourhood groups, mother’s circles and sports clubs, unions and business organisations. Some meetings are attended by up to 1,000 people.
Municipal leadership, tax collection and public finances have all become more transparent, and as they are the responsibility of the people themselves, the public feel more obliged to fulfill their duties, like paying their taxes, as well as claiming their rights.
Thus the Municipal Budget Council, made up of representatives elected in the regional assemblies and members from other sectors, is often asked to intervene in strikes by local functionaries, to point out that funding has to be be divided between investments and salaries in order to stimulate good public services.
The Participatory Budget system is now used in 62 Brazilian cities, said Grazia de Grazia, member of the coordination of the National Forum of Urban Reform – making up a small, but slowly increasing force amongst the 5,000 local councils countrywide.
This form of local management will be one of the 18 examples of good urban conduct Brazil will be presenting at the World Conference on Human Settlements (Habitat II) in Istanbul, Turkey, from Jun 3 to 14.
In Belo Horizonte, capital of Minas Gerais State, with a population of 2.1 million, another PT administration has also used popular participation in budget planning in the last three years.
However, in this city the process does not cover all the investments, like in Porto Alegre, but deals only with the “community issues” linked directly to the neighbourhoods. This excludes the “structural” works which affect the city in general.
However, in 1995, this system here dealt with 30 percent of the budget – 33 million dollars, and Edson Martins, the mayor’s Social Communication Advisor said popular participation rose to a peak of 58,000 people.