Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

FINANCE: World Banks Checks Impact of SAPs

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Jun 30 1996 (IPS) - The increasing gap between rich and poor in many developing nations has forced the World Bank to re- examine the impact of its classic structural adjustment policies (SAPs), particularly their effect on the poor.

No one is predicting an end to the Bank’s “market-friendly” development model, but the signs are there for a serious re- examination of the agency’s approach. The Bank’s president, James Wolfensohn is widely credited with the new push.

At his first annual meeting as president last year, Wolfensohn noted that the number of those in absolute poverty – people living on less than the equivalent of one dollar a day – had grown from about one billion to 1.3 billion in just five years. He also warned that “the distribution of the benefits of growth presents one of the major challenges to stability in the world today. We must learn more about the ‘why’ and the ‘how’ of income distribution.”

As the world’s single biggest source of development assistance, the World Bank and its policy preferences have an enormous influence on developing countries, especially in Africa, South Asia, Latin America and the Caribbean. Bilateral donors and other multilateral agencies often make their own support of aid recipients conditional on their following Bank-approved policies.

Such policies are mainly designed to promote economic growth and attract foreign investment. They include measures such as cutting public-sector deficits, selling off parastatal companies, encouraging export industries, and opening domestic markets to foreign competition.

These policies have been assailed, however, by non-governmental organisations (NGOs) operating in developing countries. Among other complaints, NGOs have long asserted these reforms have hit hardest at the poor whose ranks have actually grown in some countries undergoing Bank-sponsored structural adjustment programmes.

The most intriguing signal of a re-evaluation to date has been the negotiation of a joint initiative by the Bank and dozens of mostly southern non-governmental organisations (NGOs) coordinated by the Washington-based Development Group of Alternative Policies (DGAP) to review the social and economic impacts of structural adjustment programmes (SAPs) in 10 to 12 developing nations.

Both sides have agreed that txe review, which has been endorsed by some of the Bank’s strongest NGO critics, should be designed to encourage strong participation by local NGOs and other components of civil society, such as labour unions and peasant associations, in the developing countries themselves.

The unprecedented initiative – which will feature public forums in the target countries as key tool for gathering information – has the personal blessing of Wolfensohn who has made Lyn Squire, Director of Policy Research, the Bank’s principal point of contact for the review.

Squire will meet a steering committee of NGOs here July 11-12 when the two sides are to formally agree on precisely how and where the review will be carried out. The review is to be kicked off at the Bank’s annual meeting here in October and is expected to take at least one year to complete.

Another internal Bank initiative, a task force on social development, is being led by its Vice President for Latin America and the Caribbean, S.J. Burki.

At a meeting sponsored by the Inter-American Dialogue here last week, Burki said that the persistence and growth of absolute poverty in much of the developing world outside East Asia over the last two decades showed that economic growth, the Bank’s watchword during the 1980’s, was not by itself enough to alleviate poverty.

Nor have “targeted interventions,” such as safety nets for specific groups of the poor, had much impact on poverty, he said.

“Of course, we’re saying we have failed,” Burki told the meeting.”We need to move in a different way.”

His task force has concluded, he said, that failure may result from the fact that the poor, especially in Latin America, lack “social capital” — the ability to organise in a way that ensures that the benefits of economic growth are distributed more evenly.

To redress this, he said, the task force recommends giving far more emphasis to building social capital, especially in urban areas where a majority of the Latin American poor now live. This will require the recruitment of more social scientists in the Bank and giving them a stronger role in devising projects and country strategies. The current ratio of economists to other professionals in Bank staff is 28 to one.

“This will have a fairly fundamental impact,” said Burki, who added that it may result in a “new mission statement” for the Bank.

It will also require much more work with local NGOs, both before a project is initiated, to ensure adequate community participation in its design, and after its completion, to ensure that its benefits flow to those for whom it is intended, Burki said.

In addition, the task force is recommending that the Bank send 25 staff – mostly economists – to live in Latin American slums to “gain first-hand knowledge as to what poverty is,” Burki said.

Burki denied that the task force recommendations represent any fundamental challenge to the market-friendly model pushed by the Bank since the early 1980s. “We are not moving away from that model,” he insisted adding that the Bank wanted to identify its “social costs and how can they be minimised.”

But at least one Bank insider said the greater integration of social perspectives in the Bank’s work has major implications for the institution’s direction. “This issue is very hot,” he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags