Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Population

HABITAT: Too Many Suggestions, Too Few Strategies

Mario Osava

ISTANBUL, Jun 14 1996 (IPS) - The Habitat II Plan of Action will doubtless disappear into oblivion like all those before it, barring the Agenda 21, as it has picked up recommendations, good intentions and special measures like a lost lolly-pop picks up fluff.

There are so many ‘ifs’ and ‘buts’ that they disorientate the reader, making the Plan all but unviable.

Jaime Lerner, the urban planner behind the posotive changes made in the south Brazilian city of Curitiba, said the document lacked strategies to bring its aims into reality.

The World Plan of Action has two main objectives: “shelter for all” and “sustainable human settlements in an urbanising world” though it is short on ideas of how to achieve this.

In order to “ensure an adequate supply of useable land,” is recommends “encouraging integral rural development through measures like access to land in equitable conditions, improving land, economic diversification, the development of the small and middle-sized cities in rural areas.”

And, “when possible, the settlements on indigenous lands,” it added.

However, this is only one of the 14 measures indicated in the article, and this one part alone could constitute an entire government programme. There are a total of 33 articles on the ‘shelter for all’ issue, most of which include a list of recommendations.

The proposal for the sustainable development of human settlements drawn up in the preparatory meetings was even more extensive, at 53 articles, and the aims practically disappear amidst the contradictory duties and advice.

We have to “strive for all human settlements to have access to clean water for the year 2000 with improvements in technology, and strive for the preparation and application of plans to conserve and protect the environment aiming to cleanse contaminated water systems.”

“And for the year 2025, have all solid waste and waste water in both urban and rural areas disposed of in ways compatible with the national and international norms on the environment,” it added.

The term ‘sustainability’ had previously always been used in reference to the environment, and not to the group of more complex and human phenomena which occur in cities.

The concept of sustainable development broadened with the Habitat II meeting to include socioeconomic aspects, like employment and norms on excessive consumption, said Conference Joint Secretary-General, Jorge Wilheim.

However, urban sustainability was not defined, though it was understood that this should include ecological, social, economic and cultural aspects, said Enrique Ortiz, executive secretary of the International Habitat Coalition, a network of 300 non governmental organisations (NGOs) and a leading force in the Conference.

He said that he took part of the responsibility for the fragmentary treatment the issues had received as the NGOs had come to the meeting with a fixed agenda.

Before coming to Istanbul, the Coalition defined the ‘right to shelter’ as their main objective, and the United States resistence to this had absorbed most of the attention at the Conference.

The NGOs also focussed their efforts on the rights of women, the vulnerable groups, and against forced evictions, to the extent of provoking condemnation of the Turkish policy against the Kurdish minority, which has displaced millions of people.

“There are too many questions, it is difficult to find a core strategy” in the Plan of Action, principles and commitments taken on by the governments at the Cities Summit, said Ortiz.

For while there was much discussion of the right to housing, other issues of the city itself and its relation to rural settlements were not covered, said Diego Carrion, an Ecuadoran NGO representative.

The complexity of the issue has caused the Plan of Action to respond with a startling spread of different measures. First it recommended competivity, then co-operation and solidarity between cities, it also suggested programmes to promote small cities, and listed proposals to deal with every imaginable problem, area and social group.

Meawhile, the key question of the meeting, that of institutional development was at the other end of the Plan of Action.

This section recommended decentralisation, the strengthening of local authorities and the participation of NGOs and grass roots groups.

For Wilheim this recognition of the need for a new form of institutionality was the biggest achievement of the Cities Summit, and he interpreted this as the foundation stone of a new social contract.

This arrangement will allow for more popular participation, with support from local authorities and other groups – like the business community and academics – working together on new strategies to change the cities.

One thing which did distinguish this conference from its predecessors, however, was the diversity of social actors and local authorities given a chance to participate, allowing those who really build and inhabit the settlements the chance to speak.

This means that instead of merely claiming rights and proclaiming policies, this time round the groups are empowered to carry these out, sharing responsibility for the outcome – a factor Lerner considers crucial for the success of any scheme.

The will to take on this responsibility can be exemplified by the level of organisation achieved by the world network of city mayors, who demanded a hearing before the states and the international community.

Habitat II effectively changed the relations between the NGOs and the governments, said Ortiz, adding that his sector was not prepared, experienced, and ready to work all out to fulfil their aims.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags