Friday, November 20, 2026
Jim Lobe
- In a setback for global disarmament efforts, a long-awaited vote to ratify the four-year-old Chemical Weapons Convention Thursday was put off by the U.S. Senate until next year.
Supporters of the treaty, which calls for the destruction of all chemical arms stockpiles and factories within ten years, said they did not have enough votes to prevail. Ratification of international treaties requires approval of a two-thirds majority of senators.
Twenty-five rightwing Republican senators have come out publicly against the treaty, and officials of the administration of President Bill Clinton, which lobbied hard for ratification, said as many as ten ther senators were leaning against it.
Rather than risk a vote, they said they will try to secure ratification next year after the November elections which could alter the Senate’s political make-up.
“This shows that the isolationist wing of the Republican Party has taken over the internationalist wing,” said John Isaacs, prsident of the Council for a Livable World, a disarmament group which strongly supports the treaty.
Indeed, the issue split the foreign-policy advisers of Clinton’s Republican challenger, Robert Dole, who has tried to straddle the fence between isolationists and internationalists in his party. One top adviser, ret. Gen. Brent Scowcroft, who served as Bush’s National Security Adviser, supports the treaty, while former U.N. Amb. Jeane Kirpatrick and Bush’s former Defence Secretary, Richard Cheney, came out in opposition.
Dole, who originally supported the treaty, came out against it in the end in what the treaty’s supporters say was the decisive blow. Several Republicans were unwilling to go against their presidential nominee who is trailing badly in the polls.
It wasn’t only disarmament activists who were upset by Thursday’s action. The Chemical Manufacturers Association (CMA), the major chemical industry lobby, had also pressed hard for the treaty’s ratification.
The CMA, whose members sold more than 60 billion dollars worth of chemicals to foreign buyers last year, fears that trade sanctions, which could be levelled against non-ratifiers once the convention takes formal effect, may cost U.S. producers hundreds of millions of dollars a year.
“We have continuously expressed our concerns over the potential trade effects if the U.S. doesn’t ratify the treaty,” said Mike Wells, a CMA lobbyist. “We are deeply disappointed by today’s action,” he added.
Sixty-three countries have ratified the treaty so far. It takes 65 of the 159 signatory states to ratify it before it takes formal effect.
The treaty, which was negotiated by the Republican administrations of former presidents Ronald Reagan and George Bush, requires member-states to declare and destroy all chemical weapons and production facilities.
It also requires each member state to submit annual reports on the production of certain chemicals which could be used for arms production and sets up an international verification regime which permits short-notice inspections of suspected sites.
The treaty has long enjoyed strong bipartisan support which actually increased as a result of the 1991 Gulf War. Iraq’s reportedly large supplies of chemical weapons — and its use of chemical arms against Iran and rebellious Kurds in the 1980s — brought new attention to the issue.
Then-President George Bush signed the treaty for the United States.
But, under the U.S. Constitution, formal ratification requires a two-thirds vote by the U.S. Senate which, since the 1994 elections, has taken on an increasingly rightwing cast.
A small group of rightwing senators, led by Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Jesse Helms and backed by the new Majority Leader, Mississippi Sen. Trent Lott, have fought hard against the treaty.
They argue that the treaty is fundamentally flawed because countries which have not signed the accord will not be bound by it. Among these are Libya, Syria, North Korea and Iraq — all of whom are believed to have significant chemicals-weapons programmes.
“These are precisely the places where chemical weapons are being made today for potential use against the United States or its allies,” according to Charles Krauthammer, a prominent rightwing columnist.
Treaty foes also contend that the monitoring and enforcement mechanisms — to be based in The Hague — could violate U.S. constitutional guarantees against unreasonable searches and seizures.
Under the convention regime, international inspectors could carry out challenge inspections against U.S. companies. In addition to the expenses and disruption these companies would have to bear, they might also be subject to “industrial espionage” by countries which have placed agents with the inspection teams, according to the treaty’s foes.
But U.S. companies said these fears were largely unfounded. “Only about 200 companies would face on-site inspections, and procedures are in place to minimise disruptions and protect trade secrets,” noted a recent editorial in the ‘Journal of Commerce.’
Top administration officials, including Defence Secretary William Perry and Attorney-General Janet Reno, have also argued that states which do not go along with the treaty’s verification provisions are likely to find themselves isolated.
“Stringent international trade controls will prohibit signatories from selling dual-use chemicals to those who would threaten us,” the two Cabinet officials wrote in the Washington Post this week.
“Not only will that make building chemical weapons more difficult for rogue states, it also will penalise them economically by denying them chemicals they may need for commercial purposes,” they added.