Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Education, Headlines

EDUCATION-INDIA: Ambitious Plans, But Where’s the Money?

Mahesh Uniyal

NEW DELHI, Sep 3 1996 (IPS) - After declaring it would make basic schooling, which is free in India, a legally enforceable right, the government appears to be having second thoughts.

Obviously buying time, the United Front (UF) government recently set up a panel of state education ministers to mull over its proposal to make the government legally responsible for ensuring that children stay in school for the first eight years.

Human Resource Development Minister S.R. Bommai had promised only last month to amend India’s constitution to make primary schooling a fundamental right. He said a bill would be introduced in the current session of Parliament.

Now, more pragmatic ministry officials point out that a decision is unlikely to be taken for a few years. The government does not have the money to guarantee this right, and could face a spate of legal petitions, they say.

Educationists have also raised doubts about the feasibility of the radical proposal. “This (making basic education a fundamental right) will, at best be a token gesture,” observes well known educationist Krishna Kumar. “I still wonder if even that much will happen.”

“The whole economic condition of the country is making it increasingly impossible for us to universalise education and our chances of fulfilling this constitutional mandate are diminishing,” he adds.

When it assumed office three months ago, the 13-party coalition government promised to implement the nearly half century-old constitutional directive on free and compulsory schooling.

Article 45 of the Constitution which came into force in 1950, declares that “the State shall endeavour to provide, within a period of 10 years from the commencement of the Constitution, free and compulsory education for all children until they complete the age of 14 years.”

However, it did not place a legal obligation on the state. Now, the centre-left government says it wants to make Article 45 one of the Fundamental Rights of Indian citizens which can be enforced in a court of law.

This will be no easy obligation. Besides providing easy access to school facilities, the government must tackle economic and social factors which compel parents to keep children out of school, say education experts.

Even the first is not easy considering that the government is not spending enough on setting up and improving the quality of instruction in schools.

Spending has been stepped up in the current education budget by nearly half a billion dollars, but a good portion of the money will go to pay for a free mid-day meal scheme. There has been little or no increase in funds to build and equip village schools.

The decade-old ‘Operation Blackboard’ scheme to equip each village school with three classrooms, three teachers and teaching aids, has not made much progress. Less than a fifth of upper primary schools have been provided teaching kits and only 13 percent of primary schools have a third teacher on the staff.

A bigger hurdle is the growing poverty levels, which are increasing the number of children staying out of school to work with parents. Estimates of India’s child labour force vary from an official low of less than 20 million to more than 100 million, according to a non-governmental organisation (NGO).

Child labour is a main reason for the high drop out rate; only six out of 10 children complete the first five years of education. As a result, India is one of the world’s least literate nations even though nearly all children between six and 11 years are enrolled in primary school.

A deep rooted social bias against educating girls is another reason. In the rural areas, they are the first to be pulled out of school, if they are ever enrolled.

Parents also prefer not to send young daughters to schools, which are often outside the village and where the instructors are mostly male. Only 43 of 100 primary school students are girls.

According to an assessment by the Human Resource Development Ministry, these have also been cited as reasons why governments of states that have enacted laws to make primary education compulsory, have not been able to enforce them despite provisions for the punishment of parents who do not send wards to school.

However, India has in the last few decades made a great deal

of progress in education. Its basic school system is the world’s second largest with 148 million children enrolled.

Nearly 95 percent of villagers have access to a school within a kilometre of their homes. More than 80 percent rural parents can send children to an upper primary school within a three kilometre distance.

There are no tuition fees for the first eight years of schooling in schools run or aided by the government. State governments offer special scholarships, free textbooks, uniforms, attendance incentives, separate schools and are appointing more women teachers to encourage parents to send girls to school.

The U.N. Children’s Fund (UNICEF) has commended the gains made by India in basic schooling noting that it has done better than would be expected for a nation with its level of economic development.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags