Thursday, November 19, 2026
Humberto Marquez
- Seven police officers accused of killing two pastry shop robbers in cold blood, were freed when a High Court judge revoked prison sentences imposed on them by a lower court.
Human rights activists expressed shock at the decision by High Court judge Arnoldo Echegaray, saying it was a setback for the cause of human rights. And Justice minister Henrique Meier said he was “concerned” over the decision.
Vladimir Villegas, president of the parliamentary human rights commission, said the Attorney General’s Office should begin new investigations into the affair.
On June 17, three criminals were surprised by units of the Metropolitan Police – a central government controlled force – while carrying out a daylight assault on a cake shop in Caracas.
The robbers opened fire on the police. In the crossfire a policewoman, Rosario Martinez, was killed along with one of the robbers. Martinez was the first female police officer to be killed while on duty.
Radio Caracas Television, one of the two nationwide commercial television stations, filmed the scene, showing the two surviving crooks — handcuffed and one with a shoulder wound — climbing unaided into a police car.
Shortly afterwards, the bodies of the robbers, each with several gunshot wounds, were put on display in a hospital morge. The Metropolitan Police said all three had been killed in “a confrontation.”
On Aug. 18, the television station broadcast footage of the criminals being taken alive. Rafael Bustillos, commander of the Metropolitan Police ordered that the officers involved be arrested. He said he would not allow “attempts against the rights of people, even in the most painful moments.”
Jose Lazo, chief of the Judicial Police, said the officers did not confess to committing the murders. Ruling party deputy Elias Mayadon said the Metropolitan Police had a secret pact to kill anyone who kills one of their officers.
The first judge on the case, Teresa Hoffman ordered that the seven police officers involved should be detained on a charge of “intentional homicide” of varying degrees of guilt,. He said it was unclear which of the seven actually killed the criminals while on the journey from the cake shop to hospital.
Another judge, Gledys Vargas, tacked on the charge of the undue use of firearms.
However, on Sep 2, Echegaray, who was on duty because a colleague was on vacation, revoked the warrants. He claimed there had been irregularities in the process, leaving the investigation open.
Meier criticised Echegaray for not looking deeper into the case “because the video speaks for itself. It cannot be that temporary, holiday cover judges can make these decisions.”
Villegas told IPS that Echegaray “previously stopped a money laundering case,” and before he became a judge he was defender of the Caracas city hall, “and tried to imprison councillors who asked for his management to be investigated.
Parliament asked the Public Prosecutor to call for a new autopsy and ballistic examinations on the bodies to see if they were killed during a confrontation or in executions.
They also asked for an investigation into the reasons behind Echegaray’s decision “as he could have been acting under pressure from police chiefs,” and called for a decision on whether the seven accused officers could go back to work.
Echegaray said his decision had been made because “there were not enough elements to order the preventative imprisonment of the police officers.” He sent a letter to the president complaining of the “interference” of Meier in the judicial sphere.
Amnesty International, in a report presented to the government in July, said that there have been “increasing violations over the last two years” in Venezuela.
The Amnesty report said from January to July 1996 “94 people were tried by officials from the State security forces, after there were 88 extrajudicial executions in the same period of 1995,” according to Juan Navarrette, of the non-governmental Support Network for Justice and Peace, told IPS.
When he presented the report on Venezuela in July, AI Secretary- General Pierre Sane, said the “police officers behave as though they are the unpunishable owners of the law,” and criticised “the lack of political will” to confront the human rights violations.
Navarette said “there is a blanket of impunity over Venezuela, with lethal effects, because this legitimates violent action, strengthens the aggressor and weakens the victims.”
Human rights organisations have criticised the work of the Judicial Police (who support the courts) in the drawing up of warrants, and the Public Prosecutors office and the body which monitor the judges behaviour, for inefficiency.
Navarette also stressed that the majority of the executions “occur at the hands of the state and Metropolitan police forces and, which have the most contact with the public” who are “losing their confidence in the secrity forces.” (FIN/IPS/TRA- SO/HM/AG/SM/fn/96)
= 09061032 DAP0030