Thursday, November 19, 2026
Kalinga Seneviratne
- Australia’s aboriginal community is angry and disappointed because they say that just when the country was coming around to facing up to its “racist, bigoted past”, the prime minister has made an untimely and unwarranted intervention.
For several years, liberal historians and aboriginal leaders have been trying to get the government to revise the education curriculum to reflect the history of oppression that Aborigines faced from the time British explorers first set foot on Australian soil in 1788.
Now finally that revised and new accounts of Australian history are making their way into classrooms across the country, Prime Minister John Howard is saying some are not in good taste and do not contribute to the social and cultural well-being of this multi- racial society.
To be exact, Howard said on Sydney’s high-rating radio station 2UE last week that fundamentally he “sympathised with Australians who feel insulted when they are told that we have a racist, bigoted past”.
“…Now of course we treated Aborigines very badly in the past, but to tell children whose parents were no part of that mistreatment, to tell children who themselves have no part of it, that we are all part of a sort of racist, bigoted history is something that Australians reject.”
Responding to the prime minister’s comments, Prof Marcia Langton, Chair of Aboriginal Studies at the Northern Territory University said that the prime minister was not only wrong in his judgement, but that in making such statements showed that he too, seemed unprepared to face up to the country’s bigoted history.
Institutionalised racism towards Aborigines is well documented and cannot be denied, she said, adding that the suffering of the Aboriginal people today is due to the incapacity of white Australia to come to terms with their colonial history.
“John Howard has given us a very clear example of that incapacity,” said Langton. “He is unable to understand that the pauperisation of Aboriginal people which came about because of the theft of our land and resources is the cause of the severe disadvantages which Aboriginal people suffer today.”
Even the prime minister’s brother Dr Bob Howard, who is a well known left-wing academic lecturing in government at Sydney University, came to the defence of the new textbook teachings.
He told the Sydney Morning Herald newspaper that the history they learned at school did not make any attempt to get to the real truth of Australia’s history.
If Aborigines ever appeared in their history lessons it was as those who stabbed white explorers or those who appeared on the margins of white society as nannies and cooks.
“There was no mention of anything remotely approaching genocide…it took me until I got to university before I heard of things like massacres,” said Dr Howard adding that his brother was a keen student of history who got an ‘A’ grade for the subject in the school leaving certificate.
Linda Burney, President of the New South Wales Aboriginal Educational Consultative Group (AECG) recalling her first history lesson at school in 1969, said that she would never forget that day when she was told her people were savages — the closest living example of stone age man alive.
“Teaching of history today is different to those days,” she told IPS. “What everyone has to realise is that Australia’s history is the longest in the world. You cannot ignore all that happened before 1788.”
AECG and many liberal Australian historians were in the forefront of the moves to change the Australian school history syllabus in the 1980s.
History taught until, then was a one-dimensional perspective that glorified the British colonisation of Australia, and either ignored or demeaned indigenous history and its contribution.
Such history texts were “false history, sanitised, biased and very damaging to the Australian society”, said prominent historian Dr Henry Reynolds, adding that the prime minister’s comments were tantamount to a call for censorship of history and an attempt at historical revisionism.
Historians like Dr Reynolds say that both the factual accounts and even the language used in old history texts misrepresented what happened in Australia post-colonialism.
The new texts substitute words like “invasion” for “discover”, “cultural genocide” as opposed to “assimilation” and “violent resistance” rather than “peaceful submission”.
One of the new texts introduced to schools in New South Wales only this year, is called “Invasion and Resistance: Untold Stories”.
It says among other things that the 18th century British naval explorer Captain Cook “invaded” rather than “discovered” Australia, and that Aborigines were not dispersed from their lands but were murdered by colonial settlers.
It is this particular text to which Howard referred, saying that such teachings and use of language makes today’s white Australians feel unnecessarily guilty for past wrong-doings.
The gradual change-over of the texts was opposed all the way by conservative elements in the educational establishments, the Church and in politics. Many private schools still refuse to use these new texts, as it is optional, not mandatory.
“The AECG has been totally involved in the development of these courses… the NSW government has to consult with us,” said Burney adding that “a big priority for the AECG was to make Aboriginal studies a mandatory part of the school curriculum for all children.”
Jaime Dickson, a history teacher from the exclusive upper middle- class Sydney suburb of Mosman, in a letter this week to the editor of the ‘Sydney Morning Herald’, is also of the view that the new curriculum offers a new and welcome balance in history teaching in Australia.
“It is absurd to suggest that they (students) are being fed negativity and bias. They are simply being exposed to the truth,” he said.
Dickson pointed out that students are among other things, now learning how the systematic occupation of the continent resulted in the dispossession of its indigenous people and that within 100 years of white occupation the Aboriginal population of Australia was virtually decimated through disease and countless massacres.
Australian authorities have throughout the past two centuries, forced the separation of thousands of Aboriginal children from their families, he added.
When Capt. Cook made landfall on Australia, there were an estimated 250,000 Aborigines organised in aproximately 500 different tribes. In 1901, only 66,000 of their descendants were still alive. Today, the number is about 200,000, about one per cent of the national population.
“How, in the face of overwhelming evidence, could any reasonable person deny that Australia does not have a history characterised by bigotry, discrimination and racism?” Dickson. asked
Moreover, he explained that the new history books also teach things young Australians could be proud of in the building of nationhood since 1901, and the development of a stable, cohesive democracy and a prosperous economy.
“Let me assure, Mr Howard, young people in schools are learning these things and take pride in them,” he said.