Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- North Korea’s unprecedented apology for sending a commando-laden submarine into South Korean waters last September sets the stage for new steps toward detente in one of the world’s most dangerous hotspots, according to senior U.S. officials.
These include the possible resumption of badly needed South Korean humanitarian aid to the food-strapped North and the establishment of new business and diplomatic ties with Washington, officials said Monday.
Most important, Pyongyang has agreed to attend a “joint briefing” by South Korean and U.S. officials on proposed four- party talks with China. Those negotiations are designed to reach a new peace agreement that would replace the 1953 Armistice that ended the Korean War, U.S. officials stressed.
One senior official said such a briefing, which Washington and Seoul have pressed for since shortly after the proposal for the talks was advanced last April, should take place in a “matter of a few weeks” at a site that has yet to be decided.
“We’ll see what happens then, but, for now, virtually all the signs are that the submarine incident is behind us and the diplomatic process is back on track,” said the official. “Just the fact that North Korea has agreed to sit down with the South to discuss this marks an important step forward that we hadn’t reached until now.”
Sunday’s apology, in which Pyongyang expressed “deep regret” for the infiltration and pledged “to ensure that such an incident will not recur,” was the result of three weeks of negotiations between U.S. and North Korean officials at the United Nations in New York.
Officials here stressed Monday that they had consulted very closely with the South during the talks. The South had demanded an apology as a condition for following through on agreements to encourage South Korean business to invest in the North, build safe nuclear plants there, and provide food aid.
As it has since reaching the breakthrough 1994 agreement with Pyongyang on freezing the North’s indigenous nuclear programme, Washington acted as the intermediary during the crisis. “Frankly, we would have preferred that the North talk directly to South Korea,” said Assistant Secretary of State for Asian Affairs, Winston Lord.
North Korea has long preferred talks with the United States to the dialogue with the South. Washington has almost 40,000 troops based in South Korea under an alliance that dates from the Korean War. In its official statements, Pyongyang has depicted Seoul as a U.S. puppet.
Washington’s willingness to engage in talks with the North — especially on issues of special concern to the United States — like nuclear proliferation and the fate of U.S. missing in the Korean War — had contributed to growing tension between Washington and Seoul.
That tension was dispelled in part by President Bill Clinton during a meeting last month in Manila with South Korean President Kim Young Sam whose demands for a full apology — as opposed to a more general statement of regret such as that issued Sunday — were seen as unrealistic by many U.S. officials.
“I think that Kim got what he needed,” said one senior official who noted that the South Korean president was himself coming under increasing pressure among some of his advisors to show greater flexibility.
Clinton, who welcomed the apology in a statement released late Sunday, also stands to gain. Not only has his administration defused, at least for now, a potential crisis point in U.S. foreign policy, but he has also deprived the Republican majority in Congress of an issue on which they had hoped to attack him at the outset of his second term.
The Republican leadership has insisted that Washington should defer almost entirely to the South on improving ties with Pyongyang. In the Republican view, Clinton’s willingness to engage what they see as a hardline, aggressive Stalinist state and provide it with humanitarian assistance smacked of appeasement.
The submarine incident — on which the South Koreans blame three dozen deaths, including all but one of the 25 or 26 commandoes who came ashore — provided the Republicans with plenty of ammunition.
The Republican critique is part of a broader debate within the government about how to deal with North Korea. Earlier this month, Central Intelligence Agency Director John Deutch said the North was likely to either invade the South or implode as a result of its “incredible economic problems” within the next two to three years. But he said that “engagement” leading to unification was a third possibility.
With severe food and energy shortages, North Korea is believed to be headed for a worse 1997 after a 1996 that saw severe malnutrition in flood-ravaged regions and a steep decline in food rations for the rest of the country, including the army.
In the majority view, the North is in the process of falling apart. Republican and like-minded hawks argue that it is counter- productive at best to supply aid and comfort to a Stalinist relic. Much of the administration, on the other hand, favours a policy that promotes a “soft landing” aimed at preventing the kind of total collapse that could bring either the North Korean army or an army of desperate refugees streaming across the southern border.
A minority view — held by some independent analysts and key State Department experts — is that Pyongyang is both more pragmatic and complex than its popular image. Recent efforts to attract foreign capital and initiate some reform in agricultural policy, according to these sources, suggest a flexibility that can keep the country going.
Either way, Sunday’s apology weakens the hawks and strengthens those who favour continued engagement.
Senior officials said Monday they expected to approve a proposal by food giant Cargill to ship more than six million dollars in grain to the North in a barter deal and to resume bilateral talks on exchanging liaison offices in Washington and Pyongyang and cooperation on accounting for U.S. missing-in-action from the Korean War.
If North Korea agrees to take part in the proposed four-party talks, one official said, Seoul will probably restore food aid and encourage more Southern investment in the North.
At the same time, the Korean Energy Development Organisation (KEDO) — the Japan-U.S.-South Korean consortium created under the 1994 nuclear accord to build new nuclear reactors for the North — will resume its work fortified by recent pledges by the European Union (EU) to provide it with 33 million dollars over the next year.