Sunday, November 22, 2026
Mario Osava
- Adaptations in the industrial North and prevention in the South form the best strategy for confronting the greenhouse effect, the key environmental problem, according to participants in the Rio plus Five Forum.
Adapting production and consumption in the North to reduce the emission of greenhouse gases would cost between one and two percent of the Gross National Product of the rich countries, according to calculations by Jose Goldemberg, former Environment and Science and Technology minister in Brazil.
But similar measures would have an unbearable cost for the developing countries: eight percent of their goods and services production. In the case of the South, the way forward must therefore be prevention.
Goldemberg said the “fatal error” of the 1992 Earth Summit had been to not give the energy issue due priority. In his opinion the 1992 conference should have determined commitments, aims and time schedules for the substitution of fossil fuels, which represent 90 percent of the world energy consumption.
Five years after the Climate Change Convention was signed, only Great Britain and Germany had kept their emission of greenhouse gases low, he lamented.
The other Northern countries have not fulfilled their commitment to reduce emissions to 1990 levels, which represents a reduction of 10 percent.
Goldemberg considered the US proposal to postpone the aim until 2015 unacceptable, and suggested reducing the deadline to 2005. In his view, solutions like solar energy and the biomass could become “the petroleum of the people.”
Climate change is a threat, but it also generates “many business openings,” like “CO2 (Carbon dioxide) swaps,” said Frank Joshua, expert from the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD).
UNCTAD, which is looking into and encouraging the buying and selling of “environmental credits,” proposed implementing a pilot programme “with nine or 10” of the relevant countries.
The pilot plan will be applied once its objectives, rules and norms have been fixed in the meeting on climate change to be held in Kyoto, Japan, in December.
This mechanism will allow, for example, for a rich country to contribute to a project to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases in the developing world with the results attributed to their own commitment as signatory of the Convention.
Many developing nations, like Brazil, object to this “transferral of responsibilities,” although the swaps “are already a fact,” said Joshua. He added the difference in costs in order to obtain the same results is a decisive factor.
Brazil “is wrong, and should revise its position in the light of what is decided in Kyoto,” said Goldemberg.
UNCTAD’s idea is to start with a limited quantity of countries, to see how it functions during under a three year demonstration programme, keeping a check on the reduction of CO2 emissions, the gas which causes most damage in the greenhouse effect and the most easy to keep tabs on.
“It will not be feasible to do it from the start with all the gases in all 180 countries” within the United Nations System, argued Joshua.
Other ideas, like a tax on gas emissions have shown themselves to be unviable.
“The tax was tried,” but there was no way to approve it, as it demands universal approval, country by country, said Goldemberg in a Rio plus Five press conference.
The Rio plus Five co-ordinator, Brazil’s Israel Klabin, admitted the issue could not be resolved in this forum, where nearly 500 representatives of non governmental organisations, international institutions and environmental councils from some 80 countries are meeting.
But, Klabin, president of the Brazilian Sustainable Development Foundation – mainly made up of members of the business community – stressed, however, that this was a “key element for understanding and projecting what will happen in the future of the planet,
The emission of greenhouse gases far exceeds the planet’s recycling capacities, destroying the balance between the biosphere and the Earth, which is the key to our survival, concluded Klabin.