Sunday, November 22, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Angered by President Bill Clinton’s decision to “certify” Mexico as an ally in the war against drugs, lawmakers here are taking action which is almost certain to upset ties between the two nations, and even Clinton’s hemispheric trade strategy.
On Thursday, the International Relations Committee of the House of Representatives voted 27-5 to revoke Clinton’s certification. A similar bill was introduced in the Senate where a vote could take place next week.
At the same time, 46 Republican and Democratic representatives have introduced a bill, called the NAFTA Accountability Act (NAA), that, if passed, could force Washington to renegotiate the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).
If NAFTA fails to meet “clear and measurable performance standards” on labour and the environment or if the U.S. trade deficit with any of the other NAFTA parties is “excessive,” Washington would have to renegotiate or withdraw from the accord, according to the bill’s language. Last year’s U.S. trade deficit with Mexico reached a record 16.2 billion dollars.
While supporters of the bill say they face an uphill fight, they insist that the current controversy over drug certification and renewed debate on NAFTA will hurt Clinton’s chances of gaining “fast-track” authority from Congress to expand NAFTA to include Chile and eventually other Latin American countries.
“Drugs and NAFTA are related in people’s minds,” says John Cavanagh, a trade specialist at the Institute for Policy Studies, which has been critical of the trade pact. “Together, they make it more likely that the NAFTA expansion agenda will be derailed.”
Clinton’s troubles began last month when it was disclosed that Mexico had arrested its top anti-drug official on charges that he had collaborated with the head of one of the country’s leading drug kingpins.
In subsequent days, other reports about drug corruption in high places in Mexico were published in the U.S. press, including one in the New York Times which charged that two powerful governors in the ruling Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) were also complicit in the drug trade.
Despite these reports and mounting anger on Capitol Hill, Clinton certified last Friday that Mexico was cooperating fully with U.S. anti-drug efforts.
Under an 11-year-old law, countries which are not certified can be hit with economic sanctions ranging from a cancellation of all U.S. aid to the withdrawal of trade benefits. The president, however, can “de-certify” countries deemed uncooperative but then waive the sanctions due to overriding national security interests.
That was the course favoured by many in Congress. But Mexican Foreign Minister Angel Gurria warned that any de-certification, regardless of whether sanctions were imposed, could “fracture” bilateral ties.
Immediately after Clinton’s certification, the administration found itself on the defensive, however, especially by the disclosure that another cartel leader, Humberto Garcia Abrego, was permitted to escape a Mexican jail several days before the certification. Adding fuel to the fire, Mexico denied reports, put out by anonymous U.S. officials here, that it had quietly agreed to meet a list of long-standing U.S. demands, including the extradition of major drug traffickers.
The administration, which had been hoping for a triumphant state visit by Clinton to Mexico April 11-12, now finds itself beset with a growing crisis.
One measure of the administration’s panic was the sudden trip to Mexico City Wednesday of a top-level White House delegation. Led by Clinton’s national security advisor, Sandy Berger, the group included his special envoy for the Americas, Thomas “Mack” McLarty; and his drug czar, Gen. Barry McCaffrey. The visit was apparently meant to be secret, but workers at a Mexico airport tipped off local media, according to the Washington Post.
The resolution passed in the International Relations Committee Thursday would de-certify Mexico but waive sanctions. Even that, Secretary of State Madeleine Albright said after the vote, would provoke “increased hostility from Mexico… (and a) breakdown in stability and relationships.”
Adding to the administration’s concern is the new Congressional assault on the three-year-old NAFTA. Under threat are not only ties with Mexico, but also harmony within Clinton’s Democratic Party.
Already, House Minority Leader Dick Gephardt and his chief deputy, long-time NAFTA foe Rep. David Bonior, have broken ranks with the administration. Gephardt, the Democrat most likely to challenge Vice President Al Gore for the presidential nomination in 2000, has warned that he will try to re-open and strengthen NAFTA’s labour and environmental side agreements if Clinton asks for “fast-track” authority to negotiate Chile’s admission to NAFTA.
“Before we expand NAFTA, we have got to fix what doesn’t work,” Bonior told a packed hearing on NAFTA Wednesday. He complained about the huge U.S. trade deficits suffered by Washington, especially in the automobile sector, which is of special concern to his Michigan district.
“It’s interesting that both Gephardt and Bonior got on the drug bandwagon as soon as it started rolling,” noted one Congressional aide. “It seems they think they can make some anti- NAFTA mileage on it.”
Indeed, a headline appearing in an article published in the influential ‘Business Week’ magazine on the eve of Clinton’s certification announcement read: “Mexico’s Drug Problems Are Also NAFTA’s.” Mexico, it said, “must produce quick results (on drugs and corruption), otherwise America’s trade courtship with Mexico could end up on the rocks.”
In defending NAFTA, the administration may have already handicapped itself. In its campaign for the accord in 1993, it predicted that the U.S. would gain hundreds of thousands of new jobs based on its formula that 20,000 jobs would be created for every one billion dollars in trade surplus with Mexico.
But the peso’s collapse which began in Dec. 1994 brought on a deep depression in Mexico from which it has only just begun to emerge. Contrary to the administration’s forecasts, last year’s record trade deficit with Mexico. translated into more than 300,000 lost U.S. jobs under the administration’s formula, according to NAA sponsor Rep. Marci Kaptur.
But administration officials now discount that math. In testimony Wednesday, Ambassador Ira Shapiro of the U.S. Trade Representative’s office, called such a formula “completely fallacious” while a colleague from the Commerce Department noted that U.S. unemployment is currently the lowest in a decade.
At the same time, Sidney Weintraub, an independent policy expert sometimes called the ‘father of NAFTA,’ published his own assessment of the pact after three years Wednesday. He complained that both sides of the NAFTA debate were exaggerating its impact on U.S. employment. “The effect,” he said, “is tiny.”
“NAFTA is performing as expected,” he said. “Two-way trade is up and the rise is continuing. The type of industrial specialisation that one hopes for in such an agreement …is in fact taking place.”
“NAFTA,” he said, “symbolises the process of globalisation (that) would happen whether or not NAFTA is there.”